REVIEW: Skid Row Serenade by J.S.Cook
B- Reviewsm/m romance / noir mystery6 Comments
In the tradition of novel noir, nothing is ever quite as it seems.
Novelist and war hero Tony Leonard sees private investigator Edwin Malory being mugged outside a seaman’s mission in downtown Los Angeles, so he takes him home and gives him clean clothes and access to a hot shower. It doesn’t take him long to discover Malory was hired by wealthy industrialist Linton Vanderbilt Stirling, the father of Tony’s estranged wife, Janet. The reason for this is simple: Tony’s father-in-law suspects him of drinking away his daughter’s personal fortune.
On a whim, Tony drops in on Janet one night and finds her naked, dead, and tied up, her skull beaten in. Horrified, Tony flees the scene, knowing that as her husband, he is the number one suspect in the killing. He sees only one way out. He needs to fake his own death.
And who better to send his “suicide note” to than Edwin Malory.
Review:
Dear J.S. Cook, there was a time in my life when I read a lot of Raymond Chandler in Russian translation, so while I cannot claim extensive knowledge of the noir mysteries, at least I can claim to be somewhat familiar with one of the classic writers of the subgenre. I read some of your work in the past, but have not read anything for a while so I was curious to see whether this story would make me want to come back or not.
The story is dated “California, 1947”. Let’s talk first about what I really liked – the chemistry between Tony and Ed. And that *is* important to me in a Romance, or in a story that has a Romance storyline, and this one surely does. If a classic noir mystery had had a gay romantic storyline, I could absolutely see the characters communicating the way Tony and Ed did. For me it felt restrained enough, and I could feel sexual tension between them whether they were in bed or not (there are several sex scenes which I quite liked and I thought they were important to the story). Tony narrates the story in the first person and I thought he was effective at conveying Ed’s feelings to the reader, not just his own.
“Ed tapped two fingers on the postcard.
“Mind if I keep this?”
“Not at all,” I said. “If you can pick apart this particular Gordian knot, I’d be grateful.”
Ed took another drag off the cigarette.
“Cut, you mean. The Gordian knot was cut.”
“Cut.” I gave him back the yellow envelope with the tickets. “And by the way, I’d love to go with you… if you still want me to.”
I did all the right things, made all the correct romantic gestures. I even brought flowers when I showed up for our date, a huge bouquet of heliotrope. I didn’t even know if he liked them, but they were my favorite flower. He answered the door on the first ring. “Tony. Flowers.”
“Very good,” I said. “You’re beginning to master the language.” I closed the door behind me and pushed him up against it. He tasted like heat and good scotch. “Sure we haven’t got time…?”
I also really liked Tony and Ed as characters, but I had an issue with something in the Tony’s backstory. The blurb reveals that Tony is an alcoholic, and under the spoiler cut I will discuss why he is an alcoholic, according to the narrative. SPOILER.
Spoiler: Show
So there was that, but I am not downgrading based on what I wrote under the spoiler because although this is an artistic choice which did not work for me, I thought it was integrated well within the story.
Of course there is mystery here which is just as important to the plot as the romance is, if not more; it was probably fifty/fifty split. The blurb tells you what the mystery is about – Tony wants to find out who killed his ex-wife — but I am not going to talk much about that. I am just going to say that besides Tony making a couple of idiotic choices in the beginning, I really liked how it was executed and was even surprised by the couple of revelations. And I really liked Tony’s voice.
Grade B
AmazonBNKoboAREBook DepositoryGoogle
Funnily enough, I was just suggested this book by Google and added it to my wishlist because I’m a huge fan of noir. (BTW, I read a lot of Raymond Chandler and Dashiell Hammett in Spanish when I was younger so I get ya).
I’m not sure about the spoiler (it’s no so much that I’d think it’d be incredible or impossible to go through that kind of ordeal. More like I don’t know what the author’s intentions were in bring that into the table. Was it for atmospheric purposes? Because it’d be historically great timing wise? Who knows).
Regardless, this seems like an intense book and I’m always in the mood for those. Thank you for the review. :)
It does sound intense, I agree.
The little excerpt you posted really had me smirking. I love good voice. I’ll have to check this one out.
@Maz: could you clarify what your issue with the spoiler was, because I am not sure I understand. I cannot talk about my reasons because I put it under spoiler cut, but I am not sure if your issue is the same or not. I mean I definitely agree that we are not in the author’s head and cannot know her reasons, but my point was that because I did not buy it as historically authentic the way it was written, I then speculated that I saw the reason I disliked for doing it. But of course that was only speculation. I hope you enjoy the book if you end up getting it.
@Viridian: I like strong voice too! Let me know if you end up reading the book.
@sirius Not having read the book (yet), I was wondering outloud whether or not the event from the spoiler was really necessary in a novel that comes across as meaty enough. It sounded to me like the author wanted to augment the drama, but (again) maybe it’ll make sense to me once I read this novel.
In any case, I can see why the spoiler would bug you.
@Maz: Thanks for clarifying! Indeed looks like are reservations are similar.