2008 Holiday EBook Reading Buying Guide, Part II
Last week we talked about the dedicated ebook readers from the high end Sony Reader PRS700 to the Kindle. One thing that commenters addressed was the conversion issues. I.e., how difficult is it to convert content to be read on the Kindle, Sony, et al. I think that there should be a whole post on that sort of thing. Additionally, if you are worried about what device to purchase based on the non DRM books available from stores like Samhain and the like, then you should check out this format table.
On to the topic of the day: Multi function devices.
I started reading ebooks on a multi function device. My first portable device that I read ebooks on was my Palm m505. I moved on to the HP IPAQ 4700 with a 4″ screen. It was wonderful for me and really marked my wholesale embrace of ebooks.
When the Sony Reader was released, I was all over it. But I purchased an iPhone shortly after and found myself reading more and more on the iPhone because I could read the iPhone in bed without a booklight. Having a light for nightime reading was supremely important to me as I do most of my reading there. Oh, I read in lines and some during the day, but the majority of my reading time is at night so the Sony Reader was left more and more unused. I finally realized that I wasn’t using it at all and shipped it down to Jayne. I know she had been using the iPAQ 4700 and now uses the Sony Reader. She has said that she prefers the larger screen.
i do think that one of the major drawbacks of the multi function is the screen size. There isn’t a decently prized multi function device with a screen size comparable to an eink reader and that has the right form factor. What I mean by that is there are netbooks, like the Asus eeepC or the HP mini or even the dell mini that are priced under $500 but becuase the keyboard is not detachable, it really doesn’t work well as an ebook reading device. There are four types of multi function devices that I see as reasonable ebook reading devices:
PDA. Personal digital assistant.
As mentioned above, my first portable reading device was a Palm m505. It was classified as a PDA, a personal digital assistant, and it’s primary role was to provide me with an electronic calendar, rolodex, and to do list. There were other functions, but those were the primary selling points. PDAs have largely fallen out of favor given the rise of the affordable smartphone, particularly the iPhone which married the big screen concept from the PDA to the Smartphone. The advantage of a PDA is that there is a one time outlay v. the smartphones which require a monthly cellular contract. I think that the iTouch, because it has wifi capabilities, falls more in this category than the Smartphone or netbook/UMPC category. A PDA should have a decent sized screen (something 3″ or larger). You have the option of the Palm OS, Windows Mobile, or the Apple platform.
|Operating System||eReader||Mobipocket||Secure Adobe*||Non Secure Adobe||MS Lit||html/rtf||Sony/Kindle|
|Palm OS||Yes||Yes||No||Yes||No||requires conversion||No|
PROS: Many supported formats, built in backlight, ability to surf the net, grab emails, play music and video, do some light notetaking, organize contacts and appointments. With keyboard, can perform some light wordprocessing duties.
CONS: Screen size (most run betwen 3-4″), cost (most run between $200-$400).
If all you are going to use the device for is reading, then it makes more sense to go with a dedicated reader for the same price. If you want to surf the net, grab emails, do some light notetaking, and a host of other conveniences, but don’t want to get a smartphone, then a PDA might be the right product. If the PDA seems right for you, I would pick up the iTouch ($229 for 8GB), Palm TX ($259) and IPaq (starting at $299). EBay is a good source for older, used devices such as the iPaq 4700.
A smartphone is defined by Wikipedia as ” mobile phone offering advanced capabilities beyond a typical mobile phone, often with PC-like functionality.” Essentially, what used to be a PDA market has morphed into the smartphone market. The Smartphone has the same pros and cons of the PDA described above (and the same format limitations) but with one proviso and that is the smartphone is, of course, a phone and therefore can offer up two major functions for the ebook loving person. In the smartphone category, there are two other platforms in addition to the ones above: Blackberry and Android.
|Operating System||eReader||Mobipocket||Secure Adobe*||Non Secure Adobe||MS Lit||html/rtf||Sony/ |
*Currently there is no secure format available for Android. The developers of FB Reader are developing FB ReaderJ for the Android. FB Reader J will eventually read all the platforms for the main FB Reader program but currently supports only: oeb, epub, and rb2will.
**There are very few ebook reading programs for the Blackberry. There is a text reader but your best bet is to use Mobipocket Creator (free) to convert the files into a mobi file to be used with Mobipocket for Blackberry.
PROS: Many supported formats, built in backlight, ability to surf the net, grab emails, play music and video, do some light notetaking, organize contacts and appointments, make phone calls and text message. Constant access to the internet via the cell phone data package. Over the air purchases (i.e., like the Kindle, purchases can be made via the cell phone and then downloaded).
Here is a table for those platforms that can make over the air or untethered purchases:
|Mobipocket||eReader||MS Lit||Secure Adobe||Sony/Kindle|
CONS: Screen size (most run betwen 3-4″), cost (most run between $200-$400 + monthly fees).
The smartphone you buy will depend on your carrier and the cost. My preference is the iPhone but others might prefer a Windows Mobile or the Blackberry (although David Pogue of NYTimes and Matthew Miller of ZDNet was highly critical of the Blackbery Storm)
At RWA, Angela James of Samhain and SB Sarah both had small pcs known as netbooks. These are mini laptops weighing 1-2 lbs and having screen sizes of 8-10″ screens. These mini laptops ship with Linux or Windows XP. If you purchase the ones with Windows XP, you can read all the formats (even Sony if you have the software for the Sony bookstore but not Kindle). the problem is that you’d only be able to read about one book on the netbook before you need a charge (unless you get the 6 cell battery) and the form factor isn’t really designed for ebook reading. There are programs (eeeRotate) that you can download that will allow you to rotate the screen so that you can read more text per screen page, but you still have to grapple with the keyboard. If the netbook was a convertible, i.e., the screen could turn and flip allowing a slate like form factor (like tablet pcs), then the netbook would be a more likely ebook reader.
PROS: Lightweight computer.
CONS: Cost, function and battery power.
My suggestion is to go for the 10″ screen. I looked at both in person and the HP Mini with the 10″ screen just gives you so much more real estate than the 8.5″ screens. The following are good choices:
- Asus EEEPC (offers 7″, 9″, and 10″ screens at various starting prices (link for comparison chart)).
- Dell Mini (starts at $349 with 8.9″ screen).
- HP Mini (starts at $349 with 8.9″ screen. Saw the 10″ screen at Costco with WindowsXP and 60 GB harddrive for $449).
With the advent of the netbook or mini pc, the Ultra Mobile Personal Computer has fallen by the wayside, mostly because these puppies were super expensive. The one benefit of the UMPC over the netbook is the form factor. Most UMPC’s have a slate form function with a 7″ screen. Like the PDA, the UMPC is hard to find. Here are a few of the Windows UMPCs:
- Asus R2H (this has no slide out keyboard).
- Fitjitsu (this has a 8.9″ screen and runs around $1600).*
- Sony VAIO UX390 (this has a 4.5″ screen with slide out keyboard).
PROS: Lightweight computer with slate form factor.
*If cost were no object, I’d buy the Fitjitsu Lifebook 1620.
So many choices, right? Well, let me help you distill.
- If you want a slate like form factor and want to spend under $400, then you must ask yourself whether you want something that serves more than one function in your handbag. If NO, then buy a dedicated eink device. If Yes, buy the iTouch. More software programmers are dedicated to getting content on the iPhone than any other platform right now.
- If you want a multi function device and form factor is not an issue and want to spend under (or around $400), get a netbook (but you’ll need to be worried about battery life).
- If you want a slate like form factor and computing like capabilities and price is no object, I would buy the Fitjitsu Lifebook (again, you’ll need an extra battery).
- If you want a slate like form factor and phone capabilities, I would go for either the iPhone or a Windows Mobile smartphone. I probably wouldn’t go with the Blackberry given what the reviews have had to say about the Blackberry Storm.
This is a wonderful guide! I’m trying to figure out what to do when my Dell Axim PDA finally dies, so this was very useful.
I use both an Asus EEE PC (7″ screen) and the PDA for reading. I use eeeRotate for the Asus, which flips the screen (as you said), and I don’t find the keyboard to be too cumbersome. In fact, it gives it the feel of reading a hardback book; I like the feeling of having more to hang on to. It’s a great multifunction device. I use it as my sole computer when I’m traveling. Battery life is definitely an issue, though.
That said, I find I use the PDA even more. It’s so portable. I imagine I’ll get the iPod Touch or iPhone to replace it when it finally gives up the ghost. (The internal battery has already died, so I have to reload the backup every time I change batteries, and it’s only a little over 3 years old.)
I stuck at the Ipaq 4700 with the 4 inch screen. The Ipaq 3850 is a nice choice, too. And – um – ebay? I keep my phoneand reading device separate because of the battery issues. On long haul flights you want to make sure you have enough juice left to ring for a taxi!
And although I’ve looked at the e-ink devices, I’m not impressed. The other thing is that the e-ink devices are monochrome. I rather like the color, and the ability to see the covers properly!
I’ll probably pick up another ebookwise when I’m in the States next year. $99 is a decent price, but I’ll still use the Ipaq for portable reading.
I had the Asus eee at last year’s RT in April and people kept asking me what it was like. I showed it to Angie James and she got that “ooo shiny pretty” look but I knew it would. It’s perfect, and it’s the right price. But I don’t read on it very often. On the other hand a friend of mine who has a bad back and spends most of her time in and out of bed sitting up, finds it ideal.
Thank you. Excellent review and guideline! Everyone considering their options for ebook reading should be using your guide to find the reader that will meet their individual needs.
My own ebook reader needs are met with a combination of both Palm OS pda and netbook. From my experience with continuing to use both in conjunction with each other, I’d like to add a few thoughts.
…>For the pda one additional plus is short booting up time. My pda is less than 10 seconds from picking it up to reading my book.
…>Everyone considering a netbook should definitely ask themselves this question: “Realistically, how often will the netbook be used away from any power source for any length of time?”. For myself, the answer was not often at all.
…>Both are excellent for organizing or keeping your ebook library organized.
…>One word for those concerned about their pda dying – Ebay.
Argh. I was just about sold on getting an iphone when my current smartphone dies (it’s getting close). How did I miss that it only reads ereader and html? Thanks for the table, Jane, I have over 500 mobipocket titles in my library, it might have gotten ugly around here!
Amberlit converts lit to ereader/pdb.
Mobipocket Creator converts non-secure Adobe/rtf/html/word doc/ to non-secure Mobi with good conversion
@KB: There is a mobipocket crack but it requires some technical know how (at least be able to follow step by step instructions) to strip the mobipocket drm to html and then you can convert but for 500 titles, it would be a bear.
iPhone has two programs that read Mobipocket – Stanza (which is free) and another one that I think is called Bookshelf. Neither of them will read DRMed files, but there are ways to remove it that aren’t too hard to do if you’re not scared of the command line, but they require digging around on the net a bit.
I’ve only bothered to remove DRM from my unread mobi books, and Stanza was only unable to read a few of them – probably due to the compression format. There’s a way to expand it and turn it into HTML, which I’ll eventually get around to doing when I want to read those books. I’ll only be buying eReader from now on, unless Amazon decides to make a mobi reader for iPhone, so there are a few books I need to wait to buy because they’re mobi only.
If your mobi books are from most of the major ebook publishers, then they probably don’t have DRM, and you’ll most probably be just fine. If you want to check if they have DRM, it’s in the properties information on the Windows Mobipocket software.
There are ways to write DOS batch files to convert multiple books. Still time consuming, but not so manual…
I’m assuming the iPhone/iTouch can read unsecure Adobe/.pdf?
I’m still leaning toward iPhone, but all my files are unsecure Acrobat. I played with SB Sarah’s Kindle and iPhone this weekend while visiting and much preferred the iPhone interface to read–much more intuitive.
@Joan/SarahF: Stanza can read them but the conversion isn’t always great. Your best bet is to buy a low cost adobe converter. If you have Adobe Acrobat, simply save as an RTF or a html file. That’s what I do.
I am over the moon with my Palm Centro and eReader formats. The eReader software is wonderful, and the Centro’s screen, though it appears small, really isn’t because of the sheer clarity and crispness. There’s even a PalmPDF app that will read unsecured PDFs (I will never, ever, EVER buy an Adobe Digital Editions ebook again, even if Adobe does come out with something functional for Linux, because they’ve so recently slapped us all in the face by declaring that they won’t be bothered to develop an Acrobat that can read ’em for Linux. Consequently, I will not be burdening them with my business because they so obviously don’t want it).
I’m not crazy about the Palm rendering of the PDFs, but they do in a pinch. My Ipod Touch does fine with ’em, though, although I’d really like an app that could read them without having to swipe. I’d love to tap the screen and page down.
My Centro also lasts quite a long time on battery when I’m reading – I got at least six hours out of mine on a single battery charge.
“I am over the moon with my Palm Centro”
Me too! It’s less expensive than a lot of other smart phones (depending on who your cell phone carrier is, of course. Mine’s through Verizon and was $99.00 before discount.) It runs on Palm OS and it can run Mobipocket as well as display unsecured PDF files. It’s a touch screen and has a full keyboard as well. The screen IS small, but you can enlarge the type in most programs, and XandraG’s right – it doesn’t seem small when you’re reading. You can dim the backlight to save battery power too. And I find a dim backlight is easier on the eyes in the dark.
Would love easier conversion. *sigh* Lately when I use convert lit gui, I find that many new books convert into a bajillion html files instead of one.
I saw this Consumer Reports comparison of Netbooks today. Here is the link in case anyone is interested:
Unfortunately, I didn’t see any mention of the battery cell size mentioned. The battery longevity would really be affected by whether a 3 cell or 6 cell battery was used in the comparison. I have an MSI Wind with a 6 cell battery and 5.5 hours of battery time.
A cheaper Android phone from Aust.
At the rate apps are appearing for the Iphone, I think the Iphone would be my choice too.
I ended up getting the iphone and I love it a lot more than I thought I would. I tried Stanza and ebookreader and they were ok, but I finally bought Bookshelf and it reads my mobipocket books just fine. Maybe not the drm’d ones, I might not have tried any of those yet, but they are a much smaller percentage of my library, since I usually buy straight from the epublisher. Now I’m going to go play on the Dear Author bookshelf :)
Yes, There are conversion issues with Kindle and Sony reader. But i being an author prefer ebookconversion.com which provides me with 100% accurate ebooks for my scanned documents and PDF’s.
When buying Cellphone Batteries make sure that you are not getting those chinese fakes and knockoffs.:`;