REVIEW: Ties that Tether by Jane Igharo

JanineBook Reviews / C- ReviewsAdvertising / Contemporary / family drama / interracial marriage / mothers and daughters / Nigeria / POC / POC author / pregnancy / Toronto2 Comments

Dear Jane Igharo,

It was the premise (and the pretty cover) caused me to request an ARC of your debut novel, Ties that Tether, a contemporary romance. The story concerns Azere, a Nigerian-Canadian advertising executive whose life is turned upside down when she meets and falls in love with Rafael, a white American of Spanish descent, despite her mother’s demand that Azere marry an Edo (Azere’s culture) and Nigerian man. This is a situation I’ve seen play out several times in real life (it’s commonplace in my community too) so the concept interested me.

Azere and Rafael meet when Azere takes refuge in a Toronto hotel bar after a date her mother set her up on goes awry. She and Rafael, who is in town for a job interview, strike up a conversation. One thing leads to another and they get a room and have sex. But the next morning Azere leaves before Rafael wakes up.

A month or so later, Rafael shows up at Azere’s workplace; he’s a new hire. To Azere’s dismay, her boss insists that they work together on a project. Despite Azere’s insistence on keeping everything professional, she’s attracted to Rafael. But standing in their way is her mother and Azere’s deathbed promise to her father that she would marry a Nigerian man.

For a good part of the book, Azere’s mother doesn’t know about Azere’s attraction to Rafael but she sets up Azere on dates and insists her daughter marry and have children soon. At Azere’s age of twenty-five it’s past time, her mother feels. When Azere’s mother sets Azere up with Elijah, the man who, unbeknownst to her mother, took Azere’s virginity when she was nineteen and then abruptly left for medical school without a word, Azere chafes.

But even so, her promises to her father and her mother’s insistence that she marry a Nigerian man cause her to try to keep Rafael at arm’s length. Azere’s half-Nigerian best friend, Christina, is the product of an interracial marriage and she urges Azere to live her life for herself and not for her mother. But Azere fears that if she does her mother will disown her. When Azere realizes that she is pregnant and Rafael is the father, the situation becomes even more difficult.

Rafael is also in a difficult situation. It is obvious to Azere and to the reader that he has lived through a trauma and is only now beginning to recover. The event took place three years earlier and it left him a miles-deep heartache. Azere notices this in his eyes but he will not tell her what happened.

Will Azere tell Rafael she is pregnant? What will her mother do when she finds out? Will Elijah’s presence complicate things further? Will Rafael’s past be revealed? And most of all, will Azere find the courage to stand up to her mother and follow her heart?

There was no one thing egregiously bad anywhere in this book but it was disappointing almost across the board. I liked Azere. She was a generally nice person and her situation made me sympathetic to her. She was successful at her job and we got to see her perform well at work, something I always appreciate. Her background was interesting. But her obedience to her mother and her passivity when it came to pursuing her happiness took away any sense of her strength. Beyond her background she had few distinctive characteristics and that made her fade into the woodwork a bit. Her sister was a more charismatic and appealing character.

Rafael was likable too. He was recovering from something painful and was into Azere right from the beginning. Both these things made him read as a nice man. I wanted him to have more personality outside of that, though. There were no real flaws in his character.

Azere’s background was the best thing about the novel. I enjoyed the details about Edo Nigerian culture—the food, the clothes worn to a traditional wedding, the practice of omugwo (the pampering of a new mother).

But other than that, most of the book felt bland. Azere’s mother, though entertaining, was something of a caricature and the only source of humor in the novel (and that only for a short section in the middle). There was only a little humor, contrary to the blurb’s description of the book as a romantic comedy.

Awkwardly-placed exposition disrupts the reading experience, too. For example, in the midst of staggering toward the hotel bed and having her bra clasp unhooked by Rafael, Azere thinks:

This wasn’t where I envisioned my night going. A few hours ago, I was having dinner at Louix Louis, located on the thirty-first floor of the St. Regis hotel in Toronto. My date was not the man currently undressing me, but Richard Amowie, the engineer my mother referred to as “husband material.” Like me, he was Nigerian, of Edo descent. He was also Christian and, from the series of questions he had been asking, the kind of man who believed a woman’s single purpose was to breed babies and cater to her husband. Was I surprised by his archaic mentality? Not at all. My mother’s matches usually have this trait in common. As well as being Edo—the most important trait of all.

The book then plunges into a longer flashback scene. Honestly, I don’t know anyone who, in the midst of hot sex with a hot guy, would spend her time ruminating at such length about her bad date with another man.

The book is narrated in first person, mostly by Azere. Occasionally we get short sections in Rafael’s first person POV and their voices seemed too similar. Azere thinks in movie metaphors and in Rafael’s viewpoint he launches into one of these too. I wanted their voices to be more distinct.

More generally, there was a lot of telling and not enough showing in the book.

Rafael’s decision to keep his past secret from Azere made no sense. There was no way she wouldn’t find out about it since she was the mother of his child. Additionally, the nature of the trauma in Rafael’s past was obvious.

Another problem is that when Rafael and Azere’s lives intertwine because of her pregnancy the main conflict between them is a lack of communication. Though each faces other personal conflicts too, neither of them discusses these with the other. For most of the relationship there’s no hashing out of these problems, learning to compromise, or even a confession that these conflicts exist. When the black moment comes, we are supposed to believe they love each other deeply but their unwillingness to confide in each other keeps it from ringing true.

There were also a couple of contrivances with regard to Azere’s ex, Elijah.

With regard to the resolution of Azere’s conflict with her mom:

The sex scenes in the book are relatively tame and fade to black. More heat would have been good; it would have given more glue to the relationship.

So—I liked the depiction of Nigerian culture and the main characters were nice people. The book kept me turning the pages well enough. But I was never wholly absorbed and the novel felt tepid. It wasn’t awful in any one way but it disappointed me in several. C-.

Sincerely,

Janine

AmazonBNKoboBook DepositoryGoogle

Janine

Janine Ballard loves well-paced, character-driven novels in romance, fantasy, YA, and the occasional outlier genre. Examples include novels by Ilona Andrews, Mary Balogh, Aster Glenn Gray, Helen Hoang, Piper Huguley, Lisa Kleypas, Jeannie Lin, Silvia Moreno-Garcia, Naomi Novik, Nalini Singh, and Megan Whalen Turner. Janine also writes fiction. Her critique partners are Sherry Thomas and Meredith Duran. Her erotic short story, “Kiss of Life,” appears in the Berkley anthology AGONY/ECSTASY under the pen name Lily Daniels. You can email Janine at janineballard at gmail dot com or find her on Twitter @janine_ballard.

→ Janine