An Afternoon at Harlequin
From time to time whenever I would see Harlequin executives, editors, and marketing people at various conferences, we would joke about me coming to the Toronto offices and serving as an intern for the day. While I did not do any interning, Malle Vallik (whose unofficial title appears to be the head of fun in the office) me up from the airport and drove me to the suburb of Don Mills where Harlequin’s home offices are located.
I had been warned by Sarah Wendell of Smart Bitches–who had visited the Harlequin headquarters before–that the offices where Harlequin is housed is a rather ordinary building featuring a plain exterior. Inside is where the magic takes place.
And it is a sort of magic. Malle took me around to editing, production, and the art department and I came away impressed.
First up was various editorial individuals (names which I should remember but do not. I apologize in advance to all). Harlequin puts out approximately 110 new titles a month and around 150 to 175 when adding in digital first and backlist.
Each book starts at the editor’s desk and is logged electronically. Once the editor provides the edits back to the author, they have about a month (sometimes less) to make those changes. The book returns from the author and then is sent through the process into copyediting and proofing followed by production (typesetting where the PDF is created) and then it is sent off to printing.
I took a picture of the copyediting and proofreading department to show that it’s not a unicorn!
At every juncture, there is an electronic notation of where the book is in the process and all of the corollary items that need to be needed in order to push out a final product. For instance, the blurb needs to be written which will then be accessed by the art department. There is a survey the author fills out about the cover that is shared.
Fonts designs are debated for authors. The fonts of a title and an author are part of the overall branding experience. Take a look at all the Shannon Stacey titles, for example. Each book in the nine book Kowalksi series has the same font treatment as well as the same overall feel. You get an even better sense of this with the Marie Force’s rebranded Fatal series. One of the Art folks had the entire series printed on one page and the effect was so obvious but I honestly never really noticed it before.
Stacey has a new series coming out with Carina Press and they are internally testing out new font treatments for her author name and title.
They will often do several mock covers for one title to see if they are evoking the right feel, both for the digital only books and for the single title stories. Their cover budget is still an important component of their books. For the Harlequin Historicals (which sell really well overseas despite having lackluster North American sales), individual cover shoots are done so that the clothing is period appropriate and even more fascinating, the backgrounds are often painted by an illustrator.
Ten years ago the photoshoots took place in NYC and one of the reasons why is Toronto lacked the costume rental availability. That’s changed quite a bit. Some of the costumes rented are reproductions but others are the actual pieces from that time period. And at many photoshoots, they’ll rent more than one costume to ensure that there is one that fits the model. A photoshoot also requires a makeup artist and stylist.
There is also photo manipulation that occurs, not just of stock photos but of the photo shoots as well. There are head transplants (where they take the head off of one model and place it on another) and more. I was shown one of the series American Romances with several babies on the cover. Most of the babies you see are three months old and the baby photoshoots take place at 10:00 AM because that’s right after their morning nap and breakfast. They are smiley and happy unlike the afternoon. And for every baby on the cover, they have to have three in the studio. Some are not happy to be there. (Head transplants happen for everyone including non happy babies).
Frankly I was surprised and pleased at the effort they take for even the category romances.
Another Art Director shared conceptual covers for a single title. One was more genre focused and one looked more like a big lit fic book. I was fascinated by the different covers and how they conveyed different messages. I told them when they decided on a cover, they should do a blog post about it so I could share with you at DA.
One thing I remember being said about the Twilight series is how well it was “published” in terms of the marketing and publication. I get what that means now. Covers are conferenced in house as are the blurbs for books. The colors that are used along with even what types of filters are overlayed, what types of fonts are used both for the text of the book along with the fonts on the cover are important. Even the amount of text is important. On the back cover, they want to make sure that the space is used efficiently and consistently from book to book. For instance, some back cover copy is left justified while others are centered.
And just the sheer number of tasks that are undertaken to shepherd a book from manuscript to retail product is impressive. I don’t think I fully appreciated it and I wish you were all there with me when I went on this little tour.
There is a hall of books where apparently you can take a copy of anything you’d like. Since I don’t read print, I left them there.
My day ended with a Harlequin tea where I had tea, little desserts, finger sandwiches and got to talk about books, Jane the Virgin television show, and a few Harlequin office romances! The really wonderful thing about being with Harlequin people is that they all read and love romance.
I’m going to be getting a lot of books from Harlequin to tell you about but one title being published in February is a chick in pants story featuring a bisexual hero. Yes, I am totally interested in that.
Very interesting. Thanks for sharing your behind-the-scenes tour.
Well. It’s a good thing I look good in green.
Thank you for sharing your day.
Weird, though, I love Harlequin Historical and the Love Inspired Historical lines. I wonder why they don’t sell as well in the US?
Fascinating to get an insight into how a romance publisher works. I especially love the mural with the different cover styles over the decades. I’m looking forward to the follow up story on covers.
What an interesting account of your day at Harlequin. Thanks for sharing it. Now I’D love to go through that hall of books!
Thanks for sharing this Jane. Enjo your stay in T.O. If you have some free time head over to Soma in the Distillery District for some excellent chocolate.
… Enjoy… (Fingers aren’t cooperating)
I’m putting a trip to the Toronto office on my bucket list. I got to visit the New York office this year for a blogger tea and it was awesome!
Any books you wanted from the boxes along that hallway?? Bliss.
Thanks for sharing this. So interesting.
I can’t believe you could walk through that hallway without being tempted!
@Ros: This. So, this!
How fun! I am so jealous- thanks for sharing.
A hall of books, I think my heart stopped beating for a second.
I love the inside view into how books are born.
The hall of books photo! They need covers on the walls! So plain – they have so much gorgeous art, don’t they just have some posters left from book signings or old banners or something? They gave me a beautiful foam board poster version of my first cover – and I brought mine home – but they must have something they can hang in that long hall …
OMG. WANT.
I would love to see the photo shoots for the historical covers. And my fingers would have been twitching if I’d walked down the Hallway of Books.
That was very interesting. Thanks for sharing.
I have to say that I would love to walk down that hall of books. I wouldn’t be able to resist them!
I’ve understood the traditional publishing process since the late 80s, but to be able to actually see it up close would be fascinating and awesome. I LOVE the covers representing each decade!
And thanks for sharing a realistic picture of what kind of overhead and expense goes into the traditional publishing process.
Thanks for sharing that Jane, what a fascinating visit! It’s always interesting to hear the multitude of decisions that are made before a book goes into the public eye. And I would have so snatched up armfuls of books from that hallway!
Thanks for that look behind the scenes, Jane. Another article for me to point at when someone asks why I don’t just self-publish and keep all the money for myself. :-) There are a lot of things that go into making a marketable book, and the manuscript is just the start of it.
@Jayne:
Just popping up to share if you hadn’t seen it before — Harlequin video of a cover shoot for Historicals :)
@Amalie Berlin: Thanks for that!
Oh, what a fun post! I’m envious but I’m so glad you got to go and shared the experience with us. I never would have made it through that hallways without filling my arms with books, either.
Hah, I go past there several times a week and could only wonder about the magic inside — so nice to see a glimpse of it! The Scholastic offices are on King Street and all I can see from the street is GIANT RED DOG (Clifford!) so I’m betting they are just as awesome. You were here in time for the book festival too, although you might not have had time to go! Margaret Atwood was celebrating her birthday there, it was loads of fun.
When I worked at a nearby bookstore, we’d have people come in to buy Harlequins just because they were the models on the covers — definitely cool.
Enjoy your stay in Canadaland!
@Kaetrin: Me too! What’s the title of that February book?