Filed under: Book Reviews, D Reviews
The following is a spoiler filled tale in the spirit of Green Eggs and Ham.
I am a zombie fan!
Zombie fan I am
That zombie-fan-I-am
That zombie-fan-I-am!
I do not like that Forest of Hand (and Teeth)!
Do you like
The village and Mary?
I am not being contrary.
This story is not
believable or scary.
Would you like Mary
On the run?
I would not like her
On the run.
I did not find the story fun.
I did not like
The escape plan.
I did not like it, as a zombie fan.
Did you like the love story?
Did you find the ending gory?
I did not like the
Love story.
I did not like the ending,
I did not find it gory.
I did not like the vagueness
of the undead.
I did not understand what was going
on in Mary’s head.
I did not like her
Selfish outlook.
I did not like
This Forest book.
I did not like it,
Zombie-fan-I-am.
Would you like it if the author
Moved Mary
To someplace
A little more scary?
Not in the new place.
Not with zombies in her face.
Not behind the fences please.
Not in a platform in the trees.
I did not like Mary
here or there.
I did not like her anywhere.
I did not like her selfish outlook.
I did not like this Forest book.
Why not? What’s wrong? Everyone else loves it.
It’s the tale of the zombie apocalypse! And how Mary overcomes it!
I did not enjoy it. For others, it might be a hit.
You may like it. Read it again!
Everyone else gave this book a ten!
I cannot like it, you cannot make me.
The world-building made no sense! Hide from zombies in a TREE?
I did not like how Mary was never satisfied
No matter how hard Travis or Harry tried
I did not like that the zombies are hardly shown
We are barely given a severed limb or groan
I did not believe in the world that was given
I did not like how the characters were driven
I did enjoy the appearance of Gabrielle, so bold
But her real story is never $%%&&* told!
On the run! On the run!
What about when the characters go on the run?
They find another village
Weren’t you stunned?
Not in the new town nor in the old!
Not at the ocean! I am still not sold!
I did not like Mary.
I did not like how she insisted that they end her sister-in-law’s life
I did not like how she mooned over her friend Travis.
Even though she was practically Harry’s wife
I did not like the glimpses we were shown
And then never told us about. This made me groan.
If you like this book, you must assume.
Assume some zombies are fast! No reason! Just are!
And that despite all these safe paths, no one ever went that far!
This zombie apocalypse did not feel very ‘apocalypse’ to me.
I did not like it, zombie fan though I be.
Say! What about the zombies?
Weren’t they scary?
Didn’t that part of the book appeal
Even if you didn’t like Mary?
I did not find it super-scary. I thought the characters were not
appropriately wary.
What do you mean? Did you read every scene?
I read every scene and thought Mary was dense.
If there’s a zombie apocalypse, why stick your hands through the fence?
She doesn’t get hurt. Someone always saves her tail.
I would have let the zombies eat her. TSTL Fail!
You did not like the Forest book?
I did not like it or the vague end.
But I like Ryan’s writing. Or is it too late to defend?
What grade would you give it? This Forest book?
I’d probably give it a D, given my sour outlook.
This book can be purchased in mass market from Amazon or ebook format from the Sony Store and other etailers.
I wasn’t charmed by this silly rhyme.
I hope we get a new reviewer next time.
Awesome! It’s art in its own right. And exactly what I needed to know to finally make a decision about reading the book.
So you did finish reading the book.
Zombies are rarely shown? Really? We are only aware of their existence through characters’ conversations?
Holy cow, this is one of the best reviews ever. Genius!! :D
Guest Reviewer is my rhyme-hero. I love your reviews!
Entertaining review but I am still going to read the book because I too am a zombie fan.
Nice to see another point of view
Good reviews there are quite a few
So this zombie book I will read
To see who is right indeed
I am not worthy. *bowing to Guest Reviewer*
Wow great review! But I have to say this book scared me silly. I hate zombies!
This…..is awesome. That is all.
I always love the poetic reviews. This book is getting some really wide-ranging responses, which I usually see as a sign that the author hasn’t played it safe. I think I’ll give it to my teenage daughter to read — she plays all those zombie computer games. Me, I’m holding out for Pride and Prejudice and Zombies!
Having never read Green Eggs and Ham, I was a wee bit…confused…but a quick google search helped me out. The book’s on my to-read list, and I’m fine with the low severed-limb count – we’ll see how the rest pans out.
Oh dear on a book that I thought would be really something.
But major ‘hee!’ on Sam I Am homage! The original is now running in my head (Say! In the dark! Would you, could you, in the dark? Maybe with a zombie mark?)
OK I’m really not a candidate for poetic review.
This may be my favorite negative review ever, in rhyme!
Kudos on another wonderfully witty review. It was fantastic!
Sabrina, for the sake of anyone else, I sincerely hope not.
=D Guest Reviewer, I know not who you are, but you are now next on my list of worshippable Gods.
Sam I am FTW!
For zombie lovers, “Breathers: A Zombie’s Lament” is pretty good. It even has a romance (well…two) in it.
Fabulous review in G.E.A.H. style; and I’m thinking that I’d feel about the same about the book as you did based on all i’ve read (even through the glowing reviews)
@Maili: Our guest reviewer, Jaiku, probably won’t respond due to inexplicable shyness, but there are zombies present. It’s just that they don’t necessarily have the same visceral presence you’d expect a zombie horde to have. The main point of the book isn’t so much the zombie horde but how their overwhelming numbers have isolated humanity into these self-contained pockets of civilization, with devastating effect to their mentalities.
But Jaiku is correct in that the zombies aren’t ever really explained. You just have to accept them as they are, even if there are inconsistencies and contradictions.
I’m at a standstill with this book ATM. I was excited to get it and will finish, but man is it dreary. I know it’s the Apocalypse and all, but DREARY!
I’m still before the halfway mark, but I’m already getting that “selfish” vibe from Mary. I also wonder if we’re even meant to sympathize with her at all. There are moments at the beginning, but geeze, Mary makes it hard to maintain that sympathy after a while.
The one thing I definitely agree on is the writing – it’s great! But with no likable characters (so far) and other not-so-great elements, great writing only goes so far.
Great review in rhyme, guest reviewer.
This review is made of win!!!
I think I’ll just go read World War Z again . . . not just a great zombie book, it’s simply a great book! And soon to be a Spike Jones film. Yea!
Guest Reviewer Win!!
I may or may not read this book, but I will definitely re-read this review!
@ SonomaLass “Me, I’m holding out for Pride and Prejudice and Zombies!”
Me too!
If you’re going to give a book a “D”, this IS the way to do it!
hahahahah *snort*