Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view


REVIEW:  Seducing Cinderella by Gina L. Maxwell

REVIEW: Seducing Cinderella by Gina L. Maxwell

Dear Ms. Maxwell:

When I saw this book featured an MMA fighter as the hero, I immediately snapped it up. The $2.99 purchase price didn’t hurt and neither did the trope: best friend of the older brother. Forbidden loves can be delicious.

Seducing Cinderella by Gina L. Maxwell Lucie Miller is a physical therapist in love with the orthopaedic doctor she works with. Unfortunately he is asking for the phone number for her best friend. When Reid Andrews, an old friend, offers seduction lessons in exchange for one on one physical therapy, Lucie agrees.

Both Lucie’s profession as a physical therapist and Reid’s profession as a fighter are only given light attention. Very little of either occupation – either therapy or fighting – is shown. Most of the time is given over to Reid’s seduction lessons which included shopping scenes, make up scenes, and kissing scenes. Finally they both agree to sleep together in order to bolster Lucie’s confidence. (If that isn’t one of the weakest lines to get a girl into bed, I don’t know what is). Of course, at the same time, Lucie is out trying to hook her doctor.

I didn’t learn much about MMA and fighting as a sport which was disappointing. Reid needs to be in shape for a Championship bout in two months. The ability of the top of the card to fight an event is very important. A recent MMA fighter dropped out due to injury and the remaining title contender refused a different challenger. He is being criticized all over the place because the undercard events for the smaller fighters won’t take place either which means many people will go without a payday. There wasn’t even a hint of jeopardy for Reid not fighting and not being prepared. There isn’t any concern that he won’t be ready. Even the big fight was a fade to black. Missing out on that scene, when his entire focus for living was the championship title, was a bit like reading a bunch of foreplay scenes and then getting the bedroom door slammed in my face.

There were a number of plot threads introduced and then ignored including the fight thread but also Reid’s dream to be a sculptor and artist; Lucie’s dream for a family and the white picket fence house; Reid’s concern that his identity is wrapped up in being a fighter. I wondered instead why a man of his age didn’t take up sculpting or art classes if he loved them so? It couldn’t be the influence of his father because he had broken from his father, moved away from his father, had a different manager, trained at a different gym. Those weren’t signs of a man controlled by his father. Lucie’s desire for the picture perfect (she literally had a magazine photo cut out of what she wanted her life to be like) kind of faded away. As Lucie’s feelings for Reid developed, I wasn’t sure why she couldn’t place Reid in her picture perfect life.  Yes, he lived in Las Vegas and trained there, but there wasn’t any internal exploration of why Vegas wouldn’t work for Lucie.  She had no family in town to keep her where she was and I am certain there are houses with picket fences even in Las Vegas.   There was just no exploration of how Reid could be that guy in the picture for Lucie. I guess we were just supposed to assume that romance and love takes the place of idealistic dreams.

It’s a standard insecure frumpy girl gets a makeover to get a man. In this pygmalion story, Reid is the teacher showing Lucie how to attract a man by wearing the right clothes, exuding confidence, and employing coyness when necessary. There are no surprises in how the story plays out. It was a cute story but supremely superficial. C

Best regards,



REVIEW: A Brand New Me by Meg Benjamin

REVIEW: A Brand New Me by Meg Benjamin

Dear Ms. Benjamin:

My blogging partner, Jayne, reviewed a few of your books and I always meant to see read them. When I was perusing the coming soon catalog I spotted the print release of Brand New Me and hopped right over to Amazon to order it. I spent the weekend reading the entire series. The reason why is because they are charming, sexy, and sweet.

Brand New Me Meg BenjaminFor long time followers of Benjamin, this is the first book that doesn’t feature a Toleffson male as the hero but they appear, in full. Having not read the entire series, I didn’t miss the Toleffsons but I was totally intrigued by the writing and their brief appearances to go back and buy all four previous books.

Before I get into the book, I have give some backstory.  When I first started reading romance regularly, many of the books that I read were category romances I found at the library.  I remember fondly the Candlelight Ecstasy romances, the Rapture romances (who can forget the distinctive maroon covers?), but some of my favorites were Silhouette Desires written by Lass Small and Anne McAllister (McAllister’s are part of the Harlequin Treasury books if readers are interested in checking them out although my favorite – The Eight Second Wedding – is not yet digitized).  There is a sweetness and solidarity to the communities that they wrote about in the late 80s, early 90s.  This entire series kind of swept me back to those books, but in a really good way.  The town of Konisburg, Texas, is a modern version of those communities.  It’s still fairly homogenous (lots of Norwegians down there in Texas) but not as innocent.  The books are all pretty sexy, living up to trademark tongue in cheek warnings provided by Samhain.

This one comes with the following warning:

Warning: Contains dirty dancing, hot summer sex, a honky-tonk makeover, and one nippy iguana.

The honky-tonk makeover could be applied to Tom Ames, the hero; Deirdre Brandenburg, the heroine; or even Tom’s bar, Faro. They all undergo a change, one wrought by their shared experiences, their exposure to each other, and ultimately, the feelings that they develop.

Tom Ames is a man with a troubled past.  (cue the spaghetti western music)  Are you back? Allow it to play in the background.  Tom came to Konisburg a few years ago and claimed ownership of Faro, a bar with a bad reputation.  No one in Konisburg knows much about him and he’s not been eager to change that.  He does want to succeed and he’s joined the Konisburg Merchant Association to ingratiate himself with the townies, but it isn’t enough.  The town wets its whistle at the Dew Drop, a place that Tom describes as dark and dirty with the tap beer as bland as dishwater.  Tom’s an outsider and thus his bar, while attractive to tourists, is not frequested by Konisburgers.  (turn the music off now)

Deirdre Brandenburg has a fancy MBA and good business ideas but her father is a raging mysogonist.  His not so secret plan is to get her to marry his newest acquisition, a former Dallas Cowboy football player turned employee for Big John Brandenburg.  Deirdre decides she’s had enough of Big John, enough of the shithead football player who steals all her ideas and passes them off as her own, and leaves Houston and the family empire to pursue her dreams of being a coffee roaster.  Big John is enraged and cuts her off from nearly every cent that Deirdre has access to because she foolishly never took her dad’s name off the accounts he started for her so many years ago.

Deirdre takes herself off to Konisburg where her cousin Docia lives. It’s the perfect place for Deirdre to start a coffee roasting business.  The next best place to get roasted coffee is too far from Konisburg, a town that does a bustling tourist trade.  Deirdre can start there and move outward but starting is a problem when she has nearly no funds.  She gets a job waiting tables at Tom’s bar and leases a tiny space from Tom next door to the bar.  In between waiting tables, Deirdre starts her coffee roasting empire by, glamorously, cleaning and painting the space.

Big John is furious with Deirdre and orders the designated future son in law to get Deirdre back into the family fold by any means possible.

Tom and Deirdre both need a makeover.  Tom needs to figure out that being a loner isn’t all that it’s cracked up to be and Deirdre needs to learn to stand on her feet.  She’s had too much help and he’s not had enough.  I love how their character conflicts mirror and intersect.  (The title is also brilliant because, as stated previously, Tom, Deirdre and the bar, find themselves reborn).  While the standard make over trope is included here (Deirdre unleashes her inner bombshell), it was nicely offset by Tom’s emotional makeover.  Further, this book avoids some obvious traps for misunderstandings. Instead of hiding information from each other to “protect them”, both actually talk about things that happen, allowing the other to make decisions about what is going on in their own lives.

The bar family is wonderfully done with small sketches from the bossy female chef and the deceptively sleepy looking mountain of a bouncer to the troublesome regulars who come to Tom’s aid when he least expects it.  While Tom and Deirdre both think that the other is attractive, they don’t immediately fall upon each other like wolves who haven’t eaten in a week.  So why the B grade for this book?  It’s because the suspense element was disappointing and over the top in the end.  I thought the trouble that was brought into Tom and Deirdre’s lives was believable as it seemed to take on unintended consequences but the ending to that plot element was a disappointment. I also felt that the story could have gone deeper into developing some of the inadequacies that Tom felt. Those were painted with a light hand. There are multiple points of view in the story including from the “villain” but that didn’t bother me. It might be an irritant to other readers.  Still, after reading this book, I went and purchased all four previous Konisburg books.  For the record, this one and the first one: Venus in Blue Jeans, are my favorite.  I felt my $20+ was well spent.  B

Best regards,


Goodreads | Amazon | BN | nook | Sony | Kobo

P.S. So the book is out in print now and it’s fairly pricey. I’m not sure what the word count is for this book but I am guessing it is over 80,000. My best advice is to go and read the sample at Amazon or Samhain. If you like the sample, I think you’ll like the book.

PPS.  A little excerpt. This is from the start of the book:

Tom Ames could never figure out the attraction of the Dew Drop Inn. It was dark. It was dirty. The beer on tap tasted like dishwater and the bottled stuff was overpriced. The barmaids looked like they ought to be performing community service, and they acted like they were.

Tom took a sip of his draft, holding back his grimace with an effort. Ingstrom, the owner, was watching him from the bar. No doubt he wondered why the owner of the Faro Tavern was in his place at five on a weekday. Maybe he thought Tom was trying to steal his trade secrets. Tom wondered briefly what trade secrets Ingstrom could lay claim to, besides the flattest beer he’d ever tasted.


The next booth held the Toleffsons, or two of them anyway. Tom squinted in the gloom, trying to identify which of the Toleffson brothers was sitting there tonight, given that they were all the same size—massive—and all had the same dark hair and eyes. He thought the one with his back to him was the County Attorney, Peter, and the other one was maybe the accountant, Lars. Lars Toleffson actually did Tom’s books, and he was damn good at it. But in the darkness of the Dew Drop, it was hard to tell who was who.