Mar 2 2012
If I had to pick my top (current) thirty favorite historical romances….
In the past five years, I’ve read over 1500 romances. Some I loathed, some I loved and many I thought were-eh–better than the last three Star Wars movies. I’m fairly narrow in my general genre reading. Out of the 1500 books I’ve read, at least a thousand have been historical romance. I’ve read next, in decreasing number, contemporary romance, romantic suspense, and, in fairly low numbers, paranormal romance. I’m new here to reviewing at Dear Author and I thought I’d share with youall, since you’re reading reviews based on my preferences, what my favorite romances are. Rather than spend lots of prose on my favorites in all three of my preferred genres, I thought I’d write three pieces, each about my ten favorite books in a genre. And, since it’s the genre I’ve read and loved the most, I thought I’d begin with my ten favorite historical romances. And so, I looked at my list—I have it stored on my Kindle in the extremely politically incorrectly titled collection Ballin’ Bodice Rippers–and realized ten wasn’t possible.
My Ballin’ Bodice Rippers collection has 160 novels in it, all historical romances I enjoy enough to read again and again. There are some authors whose names are represented frequently—Meredith Duran, Anne Mallory, Elizabeth Essex, Sherry Thomas, Julie Anne Long, Lisa Kleypas, Elizabeth Hoyt, Melody Thomas, and Madeline Hunter—and others who’ve authored only one book I treasure: Anna Campbell, Lisa Valdez, Judith James, and Tessa Dare.
My first cull got the list down to 35—this still seemed like an excessive number to share in one post. I tried again, cut a few more, and then was stuck. There are 30 historical romances I love; books I’d recommend to anyone who wants to see what it is that so draws in the thinking reader of romance. Still, 30 books is a lot. I tried to force myself to pick twenty; I tried to limit myself to one per author. Ultimately, I gave up. These are 30 books I love and, if you want to know, when you read my reviews, what sort of historical romances float my boat, these are the tomes that do. So, in alphabetical order by the first name of the author, here are my (current) favorite historical romances.
| Anna Campbell | Untouched |
| Anne Mallory | Three Nights of Sin |
| Anne Mallory | One Night Is Never Enough |
| Anne Mallory | Seven Secrets of Seduction |
| Anne Stuart | Reckless |
| Carolyn Jewel | Lord Ruin |
| Courtney Milan | Unveiled |
| Elizabeth Essex | The Danger of Desire |
| Elizabeth Hoyt | The Raven Prince |
| Jennifer Ashley | Madness of Lord Ian MacKenzie |
| Jo Goodman | The Price of Desire |
| Joanna Bourne | My Lord and Spymaster |
| Joanna Bourne | The Forbidden Rose |
| Julia Quinn | The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever |
| Julie Anne Long | What I Did for a Duke |
| Julie Anne Long | I Kissed an Earl |
| Karen Hawkins | An Affair to Remember |
| Laura Kinsale | Flowers from the Storm |
| Laura Lee Guhrke | Guilty Pleasures |
| Lisa Kleypas | It Happened One Autumn |
| Loretta Chase | Lord of Scoundrels |
| Loretta Chase | Lord Perfect |
| Madeline Hunter | The Rules of Seduction |
| Melody Thomas | A Match Made in Scandal |
| Meredith Duran | Written on Your Skin |
| Patricia Gaffney | To Have and to Hold |
| Sherry Thomas | Private Arrangements |
| Sophie Jordan | One Night With You |
| Stephanie Laurens | The Lady Chosen |
| Tessa Dare | Goddess of the Hunt |
If you would like to see the entire Ballin’ Bodice Rippers list, check out my blog. I’m happy to share. A good book is a great thing and, if I can turn you onto more reading joy, my work here is done.
Send to Kindle
Mar 02, 2012 @ 15:40:20
Oh, there are some good ones here. In fact, I think that every one on here that I’ve read, which is maybe 3/4ths, I loved. Except It Happened One Autumn, which I seemed to have missed the boat on. I loved Summer’s Night and the Spring book better. I will have to check out the other ones, since our tastes align.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 15:52:50
I just re-read Lord Perfect for about the millionth time last night. So many titles on this list that I really loved so will definitely look forward to your reviews.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 16:20:52
Hmmmmm, well, I loved Flowers From the Storm. Is that the only Kinsale on your list?
Mar 02, 2012 @ 16:39:56
@Keishon: Do you mean on my big BBR list? I have one more Kinsale: The Shadow and the Star.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 16:40:22
Dabney, I think you’re my reviewer soul mate.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 16:41:31
@Dabney: *thumbs up.* Now more importantly, are you a Judith Ivory fan? LOL. I am just messing with you. I’ll email you for the list.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 16:42:08
@Faye: Oooooo! That sounds lovely. I’m planning on putting out my top lists from my “Chick Lit I Love” and “Bad Guys, Good Sex, True Love” collections as well. You’ll have to see if we mesh in other realms!
Mar 02, 2012 @ 16:43:40
@Keishon: I actually like The Proposition by Ms. Ivory. That’s about it, though!
Mar 02, 2012 @ 16:44:32
Finally! Someone who loved “The Secret Diaries of Miranda Cheever”! I actually liked “What Happens in London” better, but they’re both SO GOOD.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 17:51:44
@Maya S.: I love The Secret Diaries of Miss Miranda Cheever. I think it is, despite the hero’s arrogance, a perfect romance for those of us who always thought smart, rather than beautiful girls, deserve the brilliant hottie. I also, in the Quinn oeuvre, like the sexiness of When He Was Wicked, the wit of The Viscount who Loved Me, and the joy of the nerd girl winning in Romancing Mr. Bridgerton.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 18:03:06
@Dabney: yes to Miranda Cheever, and Lord of Scoundrels (of course)… and a lot of other favorites here too. I would love to see your full list!
Mar 02, 2012 @ 18:12:08
@may: I need to figure out how to give out my email without it being dangerous. In the meantime, I’ll put the whole list up on my blog, the passionate reader. You can access it at http://thepassionatereader.blogspot.com/.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 18:15:25
Wow, I think I like your list. Some of my all time favorites are on that. But was anyone else bothered by the Meredith Duran book? I loved the characters, but she sprinkled in some science that was way too early and that really threw me out of the story. Popular science is another favorite read so that popped out at me.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 18:19:10
@KR: Tell me more. That didn’t slow me down. I love her books in general. I had a hard time choosing between Written on Your Skin and The Duke of Shadows.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 19:09:48
@Dabney I’ll add a permalink to the original post.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 19:11:54
@Jane: which one?
Mar 02, 2012 @ 19:15:45
@Dabney I linked to this.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 20:24:18
Great list! I love to see someone else admit they read Barbara Cartland novels way back when- they were probably my “gateway drug” to “serious” romance novels along with Victoria Holt etc. before I got my hands on some Kathleen Woodiwiss books. I’m also delighted to see “My Lord And Spymaster” by Joanna Bourne among your favorites as I think it’s her most underrated novel but one of my favorites. Looking forward to reading your reviews!
Mar 02, 2012 @ 20:57:21
@Christine: I went directly from Dame Cartland to Rosemary Rogers and was forever changed.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 22:19:42
I am so excited and looking forward to your reviews. I read and loved more than 20 books in your list and scoured your blog for books to add to my TBR pile. Like you I have stopped reading romance books after college and started again about 3 years ago. I really enjoy discovering new authors and buried treasures from reading online reviews.
Mar 02, 2012 @ 22:44:23
I love lists! They make me happy, what a fantastic way to find new-to-me books. I admit that historical romance isn’t my favorite genre, but I can’t wait to read your other lists. I hope you post them soon!
Mar 03, 2012 @ 06:02:23
@Brie: I am looking at the “Chick Lit I Love” one today, in between judging a high school debate tournament. So, I think that one will be up next week.
Mar 03, 2012 @ 06:20:40
The Raven Prince! My favourite Elizabeth Hoyt too, yay! I don’t think that novel gets nearly as much love as it should. :p And yessss, my favourite Meredith Duran too! *high fives*
Mar 04, 2012 @ 02:58:04
I love all of Sherry Thomas’s books and was interested that my very favorite, Not Quite a Husband, didn’t make your BBR cut. Just proves the “different strokes” adage!
I, too, grew up reading Woodiwiss, Cartland, and those gothic-type romances (but have never read Rogers) before giving up romances altogether for many years. Sure glad I gave them another shot.
Great list(s). I’ll have to revisit the books I know, and check out the ones that are new to me (such as the Elizabeth Essex books). Thanx.
Mar 04, 2012 @ 10:53:04
@Susan: Not Quite a Husband just didn’t do it for me. I know I am in the minority there. I think the heroine was too severe for me.
I love the Essex books. My least favorite–and the hardest to make sense of–is the first. The second two are fabulous.
Mar 04, 2012 @ 11:11:55
I LOVE It Happened One Autumn and I see very few readers, particularly Lisa Kleypas fanatics like myself, who list it as a favorite. Usually it’s The Devil in Winter, which I did like but wow, I LOVED Marcus.
Mar 04, 2012 @ 12:58:17
@Sarah: I think The Devil in Winter is pretty good. I like the heroine. But I love Marcus and Lillian. The scene in the library where she’s bombed is one of the best scenes I know of that combines plot, humor, and sensuality.
Mar 04, 2012 @ 19:42:19
We share a lot of favorite writer, although not necessarily the same books. I enjoyed looking at the longer list (positive reinforcement and all).
Mar 04, 2012 @ 20:08:34
Bookmarking this list! I agree with many titles in your top 30 list and I will be downloading/finding a physical copy of the remaining titles that I haven’t read yet.
Fantastic compilation!
Mar 05, 2012 @ 07:23:48
Dabney, I’m going to have to read the rest of Duran’s books. I really liked her characterizations, especially the male lead. The science that popped out to me was the characters talking about anesthesia – too early for general experience of that, although is was being experimented with in that era – and the male lead mentioning he was taught about magnetic poles and that they reverse as a child. That was theorized in the early 20th century and proved after WWII. I’ll look for Duke of Shadows. Thanks for the great list.
Mar 05, 2012 @ 09:48:10
@KR: It’s funny, I asked my surgeon spouse about the anesthesia and he felt its use in the book was viable–it was being used in England in the 1860′s in some cases. I didn’t even notice the magnet thing.
I love the heroes of her first three books–Julian, James and Phin. I was nowhere nearly as fond of Simon, the hero of her last book. I thought Alex, the hero of Wicked Becomes You was interesting but not as compelling as the heroes of the first three. I think I like Phin the best. His use of language is so sexy and smart. I love the scene where he lists to an uptight MIna all the things he’d like to call her “girl parts.” I just wanted to yank him out of the book and have him as my own!
Mar 09, 2012 @ 12:47:42
I take it the reviewer didn’t read a lot of 90s historicals? I don’t see a single Balogh, Putney, Gaffney, etc.? Hint: they’re awesome.
Oh, and the only two really great Star Wars movies were the first two anyway (and I actually like the whole saga).
Mar 09, 2012 @ 15:34:17
@Natalie: You are right–I didn’t read romance at all during the 80′s, 90′s or early 2000′s. But I’ve been reading recommendations from those eras as I get them. If you look on my big list, at http://thepassionatereader.blogspot.com/2012/03/my-ballin-bodice-ripper-list.html,
you’ll see that I list three Baloghs, one Putney, and on Gaffney. In fact To Have and To Hold is on the above list.
bad guys, good sex, true love: my top fifteen romantic suspense novels
Apr 12, 2012 @ 13:15:07
[...] recently shared with Dear Author my favorite historical romances. Today I’m pulling out my favorite romantic suspense novels. These are kept in my Kindle [...]
Apr 13, 2012 @ 21:15:55
Thus far, 2012 has been a great year for historical romance. Since I published my list of Ballin’ Bodice Rippers in the beginning of March, I’ve read seven more historical romances I’m putting on my list. They are:
This Wicked Gift (a novella) by Courtney Milan
Capturing the Silken Thief ( a novella) by Jeannie Lin
At Your Pleasure by Meredith Duran
Beguiling the Beauty by Sherry Thomas
Not Quite a Husband by Sherry Thomas
The Price of Innocence by Susan Sizemore
A Week to Be Wicked by Tessa Dare
Capturing the Silken Thief, At Your Pleasure, Beguiling the Beauty, and A Week to Be Wicked are all 2012 releases. This Wicked Gift was published in an anthology, The Heart of Christmas in 2009. I’ve reread Not Quite a Husband, published in 2009, and realized I under-appreciated it the first time I read it. The Price of Innocence was first published in 1999 and has been re-released as an eBook.
Happy Friday the 13th!
REVIEW: A Week to be Wicked by Tessa Dare
Dec 06, 2012 @ 08:29:28
[...] the Hunt, and I haven’t enjoyed any of your others as much as I did that novel which is one of my favorite historical romances. A Week to Be Wicked isn’t as wonderful as Goddess of the Hunt, but it’s damned amusing, [...]