Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

BEA Day One: Book Blogger Con

Introduction

It is 11:15 pm as I write this post so forgive my incoherence and forgetfulness. However, I feel that should I delay in putting permanence to my thoughts there will be very little I will remember by the end of the week, as one event rushes on the heels of the next.  Today was my first BEA Blogger conference. I recognize that having been blogging since 2006 and an internet denizen for much longer than that, my expectations of educational events associated with blogging might be quite different than others.  The focus of the BEA Blogger conference appeared to be what bloggers can do for the industry instead of what can bloggers do to service their audience, with a few exceptions.

BEA BloggerCon Commences

The BEA Blogger conference begins with a breakfast roundtable.  It is marketed as a networking event but it is really a speed dating / pitch session for authors.  An author pitched his or her book for about 15 minutes and then moved on and another author filled their spot.  I’m not certain that all the authors who signed up for this had a clear understanding of their audience.  At least one author asked a table of bloggers what books they had written recently.

Keynote

The keynote followed and was given by Jennifer Weiner who was at times vulgar and funny. You can read her entire speech here as she has posted it online. I think it is good that she posted her remarks because as I was listening and tweeting them, I could tell some of the online audience did not believe I correctly transcribed her remarks.  Ms Weiner spoke very little about blogging and a lot about her persecution by the mainstream press as a female author.  She did label Oprah as the first book blogger and herself as the first author blogger:

Of course, this brave new world of overlapping conversation and unprecedented access was not without its complications and growing pains.

Consider the rise and fall of the women I consider to be the world’s first book blogger: Oprah Winfrey.

….

If Oprah was one of the first book bloggers, than I was part of that first wave of novelists who used blogs to invite readers to step into our parlors, and our lives, to share intimate details of what went on behind the scenes and between the books. …I launched my blog, then called SnarkSpot, in January of 2002, and, as bloggers did, I treated my life as material.

I’m not sure if Weiner edited her this latter section or, off the cuff revised them while speaking, but many of us heard her say she was the first author blogger.  There was a real sense that Weiner was not aware of the existence of say, SFF.net, or romance bloggers like Carolyn Jewel and others who predated Weiner.  Weiner gave little insight into blogging until her closing paragraphs when she brought up the importance of transparence and encouraged us to spread fairy dust in the form of good things.

I am so pleased to be in a position where, instead of just complaining about the Times’ bias, I can actually do something about it — that I can now be part of someone else’s magic, that I can be the one sprinkling the fairy dust.

If you’ve got a blog, you can it, too.

I’m not saying never write bad reviews, or that there’s no place in the world for some well-deserved snark. I’m not saying not to be honest…or that even the projects with the absolute best and most politically-correct intensions can’t go down in flames.

But there’s something to be said for talking up the things you love instead of talking down the things you hate.

The majority of Weiner’s focus was on the success of her books and the failure of the mainstream media to responsibly report on her success.

I wanted to attend the next panel which included Patrick Brown from Goodreads. I’ve heard him speak before and Goodreads gets bloggers and communities, but unfortunately, Jennifer Weiner had a book signing after her speech in the room where the next panel was taking place and after a half hour had past, the panel still hadn’t started and I had to leave for lunch. Alas.

While I Was Away, These Things Were Said

I wasn’t able to attend all the panels but a couple of things were said during the panels I missed that should be mentioned here.  First, during the “Blogging Today: What you need to know and what’s next” panel, KatieBabs asked a question about plagiarism and bloggers maybe obliquely referencing The Story Siren scandal. Erica Barmash, Senior Marketing Manager, Harper Perennial and Harper paperbacks, said that they will not work with plagiarists.  Another panelist said that plagiarism could ruin bloggers much like it does journalists.

In the panel “Demystifying the Book Blogger & Publisher Relationship”, the Booksmugglers recorded the NetGalley panelist as asserting  “‘mature’ coverage of books is more than writing a review. Is also posting covers, QAs, promoting the book as much as poss[ible].”  Color me confused as to what that means.

Critical Reviews

When I returned I attended the last half hour or so of the panel of Critical Reviews.  The panelists included Mark Fowler, Attorney & Blogger, Rights of Writers who proceeded to scare the crap out of bloggers about possible libel suits.  He ended the panel promising bloggers that the likelihood of being sued is very low…so long as you know a little about the law.  Janice Harayda, Blogger, One Minute Book Reviews, reviews only the books she buys or gets from the library.  She does not accept any review copies of books.  She recommended that bloggers always begin with the good content even in a negative review.  Florinda Vasquez, Blogger, The 3 R’s Blog, spoke about the importance of having a review policy that is clearly identified on the blog. (I actually think this is a good idea).  The moderator was Barbara Hoffert, Editor, Prepub Alert, Library Journal and she was fantastic.  She spoke about how book reviews are for the audience and thus she doesn’t think about the publisher or the author.  She stated that she is not an extension of the publicity department for a publisher.  She said she doesn’t feel obligated to review any book or to give a good review.

Florinda pointed out that having a well stated review policy can help clarify a blogger’s intentions such as they only accept books that will be considered for a review. Accepting a book is not a promise for a review.  Hoffert also noticed that at the Library Journal their negative reviews are longer because they feel the need to substantiate their negative reviews but also went on to state that any review needs substantiation and that positive reviews with no reasoning behind them aren’t helpful either.

This was a fairly decent panel other than the focus being so much about libel and bloggers getting fearful of being sued over it.  I will admit that I was invited to be part of this panel but declined because this is the first BEA I was attending and I wanted to attend just to learn and absorb information this first time. I did regret not accepting the invitation, though, so I could have allayed some unnecessary fear about the potential for a libel suit.

Creating Community & Driving Engagement

The next panel I went to was on community building.  The title was “Creating Community & Driving Engagement”.   I’m not going to name all the panelists because while I appreciate their willingness to participate, the panel was really dull.  There were a few good tips being handed out but the energy of the panel seemed very subdued.  The one useful and interesting tip that was offered was from the blogger, Well Read Wife, who uses google adwords to craft the titles of her posts.  For instance, she was writing something about Charlaine Harris’ last book. Google Adwords revealed to her that Charlaine Harris garnered about 8,000+ searches but that Sookie Stackhouse phrase saw about 40,000+ searches (I don’t know if that is one day or a week or what) so the blogger titled the post using “Sookie Stackhouse” instead of “Charlaine Harris”.  She also stated that Google will place you higher on the search engine list if the first paragraph of your blog post contains the same words as your title.

The Well Read Wife also is a fan of memes.  She participates in a number of them.  A meme is a topical post that is hosted by one blogger and then everyone links back to that one blogger (link backs are a way to build SEO ranking).  I’m not a huge fan of memes but I know it is fairly popular amongst the YA crowd and perhaps in mommy blogging?

Other panelists recommended blogging about things other than books.  One blogger admitted to writing about her depression, PTSD, and other mental illnesses but admitted that she was estranged from her family because of her public posts.  However, the blogger noted that her blog reach was beyond books because of this.

We don’t do any of these things here at DA and I don’t think any of you would stand for it if I did. Although, honestly, I did like the SEO idea for titling but most of our reviews show up on the first page anyway so I’ll probably be too lazy to do anything different.

BEA Buzz

The Bloggess closed the BEA Bookblogger Con but I decided to go to BEA Buzz instead.  Over 200 books were submitted and only six were chosen.Of 6 books, only two of which I had any interest in.  The first was The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry by Rachel Joyce which I thought Jayne might like. It has been published in the UK already and is about a journey that Harold takes to his friend Queenie who is dying.  Harold believes that if he does something extraordinary such as walk 500 miles to see his friend Queenie, she will do something extraordinary like recover.  The two main protagonists are Harold and his wife.  I’m not sure it has a happy ending though. The editor speaking about the book mentioned something about a tearful ending.  That could mean a lot of things, many of them bad.

The other book of interest to me was In the Shadow of the Banyan by Vaddey Ratner which appears to be like a fictionalized memoir of a young girl coming to age during the genocide in Cambodia.

I admit while I was listening to this hour long presentation about 6 books, most of which are likely destined to be book club books (and often do not sell well despite the BEABuzz I was told by another frequent BEA attendee) that it was evident why 50 Shades blew the minds of so many mainstream readers.  One of the books discussed was published by McSweeney and the editor rambled on for about 15 minutes and claimed that the book was for everyone.  I thought to myself that he couldn’t even manage to describe the book with any coherency. How could it be for “everyone”?

Conclusion

So the BEA Book Blogger Conference really wasn’t what I had hoped it would be. I plan to write a long list of suggestions to the BEA Bookblogger organizers to recommend things that are more from a blogger’s point of view. Right now, BEA Book Blogger Con is good for very young, new bloggers.  I don’t think they are offering much for established bloggers.

Jane Litte is the founder of Dear Author, a lawyer, and a lover of pencil skirts. She spends her downtime reading romances and writing about them. Her TBR pile is much larger than the one shown in the picture and not as pretty. You can reach Jane by email at jane @ dearauthor dot com

26 Comments

  1. Nadia Lee
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 01:24:54

    I did regret not accepting the invitation, though, so I could have allayed some unnecessary fear about the potential for a libel suit.

    Why not write a post about it, Jane? I’m sure many will appreciate it. :)

  2. Edward
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 01:36:32

    I second Nadia. It would be a great topic to blog about. Also, this is your first BEA? I always thought you attended them.

  3. Janine
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 02:45:43

    If memory serves, Jane has written on that topic in the past. Though it does sound like a good idea to post about it again.

  4. Marguerite Kaye
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 06:16:34

    I have just finished The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry and it was one of the best books I’ve read in ages. It’s difficult to describe, and it probably helped that I had no expectations of it at all and had never heard of it, but it left me with such a lovely warm feeling, even though I also cried buckets. If I could have bought Harold a pair of walking boots that he would have accepted I would have, because my feet were aching with his.

  5. Heather Massey
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 07:17:27

    Thanks for the recap! I hope the conference organizers will have open minds about your feedback in order to make the next one more blogger-centric.

    >Harold believes that if he does something extraordinary such as walk 500 miles to see his friend Queenie, she will do something extraordinary like recover

    That sounds a little bit like the film BREAKING THE WAVES. Loved that story but it was so heartbreaking. I may have to check out that book because I did enjoy how the theme was explored in BREAKING THE WAVES.

  6. Joanne
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 07:46:54

    Re: Jennifer Weiner’s keynote address.
    I’m not sure if she had a point but if so, I missed it.
    If you take out all the references to Oprah – that great book-blogger-who-wasn’t-a-blogger? – and Ms Weiner’s journey as an author, there really is little said about book blogging.

    Well, there’s fairy dust, but I think that’s an FDA controlled substance and bloggers should be very, very careful where they try to spread it.

    Thanks for the re-cap.

  7. jmc
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 08:12:47

    I feel like I’m missing the point of Weiner’s “keynote” address. In what way does that really address the business of book blogging? How is Oprah relevant in any way?

  8. Mireya
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 08:13:18

    I know you were going with an open mind, Jane. Personally, I can’t say I was expecting a different result from what you got. Maybe they will listen to you and implement suggestions, but I still believe that BEA being an industry marketing/networking event more than anything else, chances are slim that they would seek to benefit bloggers rather than the BEA intended audience. Of course, if you can make them see that by making it more blogger centric they would be benefiting their marketing strategies bottom line, me thinks that would up the chances that they would implement at least some if not all of your suggestions.

  9. Rebecca
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 11:01:19

    Thanks for posting your thoughts on the conference. I’m a new book blogger who’s blog is still evolving, and I’m interested in the bigger conversations about the relationship between bloggers and publishers.

  10. Anon
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 11:35:09

    So now Oprah is the world’s first book blogger?

    Well.

  11. Violetta Vane
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 12:21:48

    @Joanne Yeah, my jaw dropped at “fairy dust”. I really hope DA doesn’t start flinging PCP on their readers.

  12. Stephanie
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 13:40:20

    I was at the conference also (and wrote my thoughts in a post on my blog this morning) and felt very much the same as you. I’ve been blogging about books for six years and even though I enjoyed some of the sessions, I didn’t learn as much as I had hoped. I also thought that the author breakfast and lunch were not very successful.

  13. KzoeT
    Jun 05, 2012 @ 17:55:26

    The NetGalley bit set my teeth on edge.

    …recorded the NetGalley panelist as asserting ”‘mature’ coverage of books is more than writing a review. Is also posting covers, QAs, promoting the book as much as poss[ible].”

    So, bloggers are expected to fill in for the publishers’ marketing departments? Will they be compensated as such?

  14. Charlie
    Jun 06, 2012 @ 03:22:52

    I’ve not been to BEA, but hearing how the Book Blogger Unconference went, I’d be inclined to go to that one, especially since the BEA conference doesn’t sound like it’s for bloggers any more. Incidentally I’m confused about this law suit idea, we get sued if we write a negative review? Where’s freedom of speech in that, and where do snarky newspapers fit in…

  15. melissa @ 1lbr
    Jun 06, 2012 @ 11:31:58

    It’s odd to me that the Blogger Con would be better for new bloggers, since I think most new bloggers aren’t heading straight to BEA right off. Maybe they are and I just don’t know it :)

  16. Reflections on the BEA Blogger Con 2012 | Read React Review
    Jun 07, 2012 @ 14:38:22

    […] Jane of Dear Author  […]

  17. Pam
    Jun 07, 2012 @ 19:31:19

    I never go. It never seems to be anything for bloggers who have been blogging more than five minutes.

  18. Book Expo America and BEA Bloggers Conference 2012: A Recap | The Book Smugglers
    Jun 08, 2012 @ 10:09:45

    […] attend that panel (as we were mired in monetization craziness), but you can read all about it from Jane at Dear Author – if you don’t know, in addition to being one of the internets’s preeminent book […]

  19. Florinda
    Jun 09, 2012 @ 15:39:17

    Thanks for your recap of the Critical Reviews panel (and for not making me sound like an idiot!). I agree that Barbara was a terrific moderator, but I think we were diverted from the “fine-tuning your craft” angle on critical reviewing by the legal tangent–an interesting one, but possibly better suited to a different setting.

  20. BEA Bloggers Conference 2012 | Fantasy Cafe | Reviews of Fantasy and Science Fiction Books
    Jun 09, 2012 @ 17:30:41

    […] Dear Author […]

  21. Carrie at In the Hammock Blog
    Jun 10, 2012 @ 12:30:08

    thank you for the informative post!

  22. The BEA Blogger Convention 2012: My Thoughts | Starmetal Oak Reviews
    Jun 10, 2012 @ 16:45:36

    […] BEA Day One: Book Blogger Con – Dear Author Share! Tweet(function() {var s = document.createElement('SCRIPT'), s1 = document.getElementsByTagName('SCRIPT')[0];s.type = 'text/javascript';s.async = true;s.src = 'http://widgets.digg.com/buttons.js';s1.parentNode.insertBefore(s, s1);})(); This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL. « Weekly Update: May 28 – June 2, 2012 […]

  23. It's A Wrap! 2012 BEA Book Blogger Conference | There's A Book
    Jun 12, 2012 @ 00:18:22

    […] Book Smugglers Dear Author Michelle from Galleysmith Mandy from The Well-Read Wife Read React Review (Which also has a nice […]

  24. BEA Bloggers: Where Were the Bloggers?
    Jun 12, 2012 @ 12:39:49

    […] Dear Author — “So the BEA Book Blogger Conference really wasn’t what I had hoped it would be. I plan to write a long list of suggestions to the BEA Bookblogger organizers to recommend things that are more from a blogger’s point of view. Right now, BEA Book Blogger Con is good for very young, new bloggers.  I don’t think they are offering much for established bloggers.” […]

  25. jennygirl
    Jun 12, 2012 @ 14:44:35

    Referred by the book Smugglers. Thanks for your wrap up, I enjoyed it.
    I also see there’s a reason why I never read a Jennifer Weiner book, and apparently never will. Oprah as the first book blogger…really? Please!

  26. What is a Fan? A Response to Justin | Ruthless Culture
    Jul 31, 2013 @ 09:16:14

    […] Even worse, the conference also featured a panel on critical reviews and one of the panellists was an “author’s rights” lawyer who, according to Jane at Dear Author: […]

%d bloggers like this: