Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

Review Policy

Dear  Publishers, Publicists, and Authors:

The following is our review policy.  These are guidelines to help you decide whether Dear Author is a blog where you might want to submit a book for review.  Please feel free to contact us using the contact form in the navigation menu above or email jane at dearauthor.com.

Type of Query:

If you are an author, please fill out the form here. Any author submitted review queries will not be considered if they do not follow this format.  The reason for this is because a) we receive at least 10-20 requests a day  and b) we base our acceptance of a book on the excerpt and blurb.  We do accept self published books but prefer that they are professionally edited.

If you are a publisher, we recommended sending us one email a week or a month, depending on your release schedule identifying all the books you are publishing in that week or month and we can then review the list and identify the books that interest us.

If we have a preexisting relationship with you, please continue to do whatever it is that you do.

Dear Author Promotes Retail Diversity

As of January 1, 2013, we will no longer review books that are not available in at least two digital platforms: Kindle and ePub.  The reason for this is twofold.  First, many of our readers here do not own Kindles and do not want to own Kindles.  If we review a book and the reader is unable to purchase it in their desired format that is frustrating for them.

Second, we believe in promoting healthy competition.  Amazon as the sole provider of digital books hurts readers because without competition there is no real impetus for Amazon to keep prices low or constantly innovate.

Form of Review Copy:

We accept galley copies and finished copies of books for review.  We prefer to receive digital ARCS but will read paper form. We post reviews around the time of the release, generally within a week of the release.   We accept digital galleys/ARCs for review. Our preferred method of receiving e-galleys is through NetGalley, where we are a listed Review Organization Accepting NetGalley Titles.   We do not receive any compensation for NetGalley, but it is an easy way for the diverse set of reviewers here to find books that will interest them.

Timing of Review Publication:

Not every book accepted for review will be reviewed.  We review approximately 30-40 titles a month, with two reviews posted every day except for Saturday when only 1 review is posted.  The earlier a book is sent to DA for review, the more likely a timely review will be posted.  If a book is sent a few weeks before the release date, it is generally not going to result in the posting of a timely review.

We will not send you a link for the review.  We do this as a courtesy for authors.  While the majority of our grades are B- and above, around 40% of the reviews we give are C and below.  Many authors do not want to read that type of review.  Further, we believe reviews are for readers and in keeping with that philosophy, we do not send links of reviews regardless of whether the review is positive or negative.

Areas of Interest:

We review contemporary romance books, paranormal romance books, historical romance books, urban fantasy, science fiction, fantasy, and young adult.  From time to time, we will review mystery books but rarely.  The site is primarily devoted to the romance genre.  If you are looking for a review of a non fiction or a memoir, our site is not right for you.

Point of Contact

Jane Litte is the individual in charge of collecting arcs, fielding review requests and sending out books to the DA reviewers. You can reach her at jane @ dearauthor.com or by using the contact form.

Stats

We will provide a PDF of Google Analytics stats upon request.  We believe Google Analytics is one of the best, most reliable statistic compilations out there.  There are others but they often inflate the numbers.

Response Time

Generally, we respond to all review queries within a week.  If you haven’t received a response, I encourage you to email again.

What Type of Review to Expect

We believe that reviews are for readers, particularly a romance reader who has limited amount of time and money to spend and use the reviews to help them cull out their reading / buying list.  The reviews are also the start of a conversation with a reader.  Even though the reviews are written in a letter format to the author, the reviews are still for the reader.  By the time that a book arrives at our doorstep, the time for editing is past. Any critiques or complaints or praise we offer in the review is intended for the reader, not directed at the author.

We post negative and positive reviews, depending on the reviewer’s reaction.  We are not professionally trained but are life long readers who bring with us our own set of biases and preconceptions.   We do our utmost to provide honest, consistent, transparent opinions about why we did or did not enjoy the book we read.

From time to time, we may write a DNF review. DNF stands for Did Not Finish.  You can read more about the concept here.

Grades

Our romance book review grades are our own opinions, obviously, and therefore fraught with subjectivity. You may or may not agree with our opinions, our grades, or anything else.  We’d love for you to comment on the reviews and tell us what you think, whether you agree and disagree. If you are wondering if there is any objectivity in a review, we can only provide you with the information below:

  • A: I loved it and would cry if someone took it from my library. I would need lots of chocolate to get over its loss.
  • B: It’s good and I would buy it again, given the chance.
  • C: Eh. Not bad but I probably would never read it again.
  • D: I want my money back.
  • F: I want my money back and repayment for the time wasted reading it.
  • DNF: does this really need an explanation?

Errors in Reviews

There will be times that we post reviews that have errors.  We encourage you to contact Jane and inform her of the error and we will do our utmost to correct the error quickly.  You can reach her at jane @ dearauthor.com or by using the contact form.

3 Comments

  1. Mark Green
    Nov 19, 2012 @ 09:31:50

    Dear Jayne,
    I chanced on your review of my eBook: The Travel Auction whilst searching for supporting info for my website. (currently under construction) I just wanted to say thank you for taking the time to read my first ebook and for writing such a comprehensive review. I can see the reasoning for all of your comments and have taken note of where I need to apply more thought for character development and plot quirks for my next book or screenplay. I really appreciate your honest feedback – it’s extremely useful to a new writer like me. I wonder whether you’d consider sparing me a few more valuable minutes of your time to copy the review (or a shorter version – as suits) to my Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk, B&N, Sony, Kobo and Smashwords pages please? Smashwords coupon code: SM86T

    I fully understand if this isn’t possible – I know it’s a pretty cheeky request, especially given the amount of time you’ve already spent on my book. But to be honest, I need all the help I can get promoting my book. And so long as I ask politely and take an equally polite ‘no’ on the chin, I hope I won’t irritate you too much for asking the question.

    Thanks again for a fantastic review.

    Mark

    ReplyReply

  2. Allen Mack
    Feb 13, 2013 @ 09:42:01

    Dear Dear Author: I have one m/m story published (showing on Amazon, B&N, GoodReads) called Just Call Me Kris. Another due next month: Relatively Speaking. Three others due by the end of May. They range from over 5,000 words to over 15,000 words. Each has a main romantic element, but also quite graphic scenes. I would rather not send material to DearAuthor that would be found awkward, or to be discarded for content by an editor. Should I seek elsewhere for reviews? Or are such m/m romances accept for review consideration?
    My thanks for your candor.
    Allen Mack

    ReplyReply

  3. Ultimate Book Promotion Database | MoneyMakingDiscussion
    Jul 15, 2013 @ 23:28:08

    [...] Books, A True Story Books With Bite Book Briefs Martini Times Romance Reviews* The Book Binge Dear Author A Tasty Read The Urban Book Source From Left to Write Review From [...]

Leave a Reply


+ 2 = 6

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.