Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

Friday Film Review: Young Frankenstein

imagesYoung Frankenstein (1974)
Genre: Comedy Spoof
Grade: B+

“Ah, sweet mystery of life, at last I’ve found you!”

When Mel Brooks is on, he’s fabulous and this is one of his directorial efforts which holds up for me just as well today as it did then. Over the years, I’ve discovered that not all of his movies work for me (History of the World, Part I) and some that did then (Spaceballs and Robin Hood, Men in Tights) don’t now. But this film has a great cast, doing fabulous work on wonderful sets that ends with not just one but two romances.

Dr. Frederick Frankenstein (Gene Wilder) – and that’s pronounced Fronkensteen – initially has little interest when told of his inheritance from his greatgrandfather in Transylvania. He’s a world renowned brain expert who pooh poohs the work of his famous cookoo grandfather and is due to be married to his fiancee Elizabeth (Madeline Kahn) in two weeks. But he’s persuaded to at least visit the old home castle and is supplied with laboratory assistant Inga (Terri Garr), general dogsbody Igor (Marty Feldman) and a housekeeper named Frau Blucher – whinnying! – (Cloris Leachman).

On his first night there, mysterious violin music leads him to the private library of his grandfather where Frederick discovers a neatly bound account – “How I Did It” – of the Baron’s work. After an all night cram session, Frederick decides that It. Just. Might. Work – if he can find the right body (it needs to be big) and the right brain. Fired with enthusiasm, he and Igor dig up a freshly hung corpse – filthy work only made worse when it starts raining – after which he sends Igor to the brain depositary to snatch the brain a brilliant scientist – oopsie when Igor drops it. Can Frederick correct where his grandfather went wrong and get the angry villagers to give him and the Creature (Peter Boyle) a chance?

After thinking about it and listening to the commentary by Mel Brooks, I’ve decided that Young Frankenstein works because they’re actually playing it fairly straight – which makes it all the more funny. And because the movie has emotion as well as comedy. Brooks says it can’t just be funny and nothing else – and this is why some of his later films fall flat for me. Actually the best relationship here is that between Frederick and the Creature.

Wilder, with his wild Einstein hair, is the one who initially gets you interested in the film and who carries that interest along. He can play “on the edge of insanity” better than a lot of actors as seen when he questions Igor about exactly whose brain is now in the Creature’s body. Terri Garr looks sweet and innocent, yet sexy, so Brooks can get away with all the double entendre jokes (“What knockers!”). Marty Feldman is the only one who could play Igor and he elevates the role beyond a mere gopher. I love watching to see which side his hump will be on in any one scene.

Peter Boyle does an amazing job getting me to love the Creature even though his lines are limited for most of the movie to whimpers, Hmmmmmms and Mmmmmmms. But when, after the brain transference, he does finally speak he makes an eloquent plea for those judged as “different” by society. Madeline Kahn chose the smaller role of Elizabeth but it’s only smaller in terms of the number of lines she has. When she’s onscreen, she’s dazzling. Leachman is a delight as the woman whose name makes horses whinny in fright.

And lets not forget the angry villagers with pitchforks and torches. Never underestimate villagers with pitchforks and torches. Kenneth Mars is the Inspector whose thick accent even the other villagers can’t always understand (“Footschtops!”) but who knows how to win a dart game. However I think one of the loveliest scenes in the film is that between the Creature and a blind hermit. I don’t know how many times I saw the movie before realizing who plays the hermit.

The film isn’t above silly sight gags – such as the “walk this way” arrival in Transylvania and “extra hand” after digging up the body scenes – but since they’re funny too, I agree with Brooks and Wilder in including them. But in the screenplay and choice of B&W photography, Brooks and Wilder reveal a comfortable knowledge about and genuine love of the films they’re spoofing. Honestly I’ve never watched the originals, but after seeing Young Frankenstein I feel that not only have I seen them but that someone’s gone them one better.


Another long time reader who read romance novels in her teens, then took a long break before started back again about 15 years ago. She enjoys historical romance/fiction best, likes contemporaries, action- adventure and mysteries, will read suspense if there's no TSTL characters and is currently reading very few paranormals.


  1. Aoife
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 08:40:07

    What a great review, Jayne! For me, Young Frankenstein is the only Mel Brooks movie that has stood the test of time. Even Blazing Saddles, which is probably my next favorite MB film, seems a bit dated, although still worth watching for the wonderful Madeline Kahn. I first saw Young Frankenstein when I was in college, and watched it again a few years ago when our daughters were in college. They found it as hysterically funny, and as touching, as my DH and I still did.

    And we’ve never been able to listen to “Putting on the Ritz” in quite the same way since.

  2. Sandy James
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 10:42:46

    Great choice, Jayne! One of my favorite movies ever!
    I think the cast is fantastic, but Madeline Kahn steals this show.
    I’ve seen the musical stage version, and it doesn’t come close to touching the magic of the movie.

  3. wikkidsexycool
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 11:22:32

    Thanks so much for this review.

    OMG, when Frankenstein is in a top hat and tails and trying to perform Putting on the Ritz I always LMAO. And Marty Feldman, what I can say. He died much too soon. Leachman and Kahn are a riot, and this is one of my favorite classic comedy films.

  4. Cynthia Sax
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 13:12:06

    I LOVE Young Frankenstein. I watch it every Halloween and LMAO. My dear wonderful hubby and I quote it all the time. At dinner, all he has to do is make the yummy sound and I laugh. Oh, and whenever someone tells me her name is Abby, I can’t help but smile.

  5. cleo
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 13:35:06

    I think Young Frankenstein might be one if those movies you have to see at a relatively young age to love. Either that or I just have no sense of humor.

    I saw it for the first time in my late 30s and yeah, I didn’t get it. Perhaps because I’d already heard all the quotes from misc fans or because I was watching it with my husband, who loved it as a youth and kept looking at me hopefully during the “good parts”. (Interestingly, at least to me, we had the opposite experience watching a beloved movie from my youth – The Princess Bride, which he just didn’t get at all).

  6. Cate
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 15:20:37

    A film that absolutely lives up to the hype. I only have one problem though…I can no longer hear Putting on the Ritz ( so sorry Mr Astaire), without hearing Peter Boyle’s dulcet yodel ….

  7. Jayne
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 15:59:17


    I think Young Frankenstein might be one if those movies you have to see at a relatively young age to love.

    I’ve had that experience with other films. By the time I got around to seeing “Alien,” I knew all the parts that were supposed to be scary from film clips and word of mouth and so spend the film thinking – “I should have seen this years ago when it would have had a greater impact.”

  8. Mary Jo Burke
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 16:16:50

    I saw Young Frankenstein when it came out. To me, Marty Feldman and Madeline Kahn owned the movie. “Taffeta”

  9. Fiona McGier
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 16:35:47

    We own the original of Frankenstein, as well as this movie. Husband always wants to watch both for Halloween, but sometimes I can talk him into JUST this one. Madeline Kahn is so sweet while she denies poor Gene Wilder, her fiancee, even the right to kiss her. Until the monster teaches her about the “sweet mystery of life”…and despite the low-brow humor, which dominates in Brooks’ other movies (maybe not “The Producer” so much, but definitely in all the rest), there is a sweetness and gentle touch that makes this movie a gem. For this alone, Mel Brooks deserves to be remembered as a great director.

  10. Michelle
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 17:38:56

    Love this movie. Put the candle back!

  11. Sandra
    Feb 21, 2014 @ 20:37:51

    I loved, loved, loved Gene Wilder once upon a time. Mostly because of this movie and Silver Streak. Never get tired of watching it.

  12. Darlene Marshall
    Feb 23, 2014 @ 13:31:51

    Ah, the classics! So many of Mel Brooks’ movies seem to lose steam by the end (Blazing Saddles), but YF had a great storyline, arc and characters you could appreciate. One of the best comedies of the 20th century.

    One of my favorite characters is Gene Hackman in his cameo as the Hermit. Hysterical!

%d bloggers like this: