Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Sindustry II

SindustryDear Authors:

I opened THIS anthology because I liked Sindustry I. But this volume is so obviously all the leftover stories from the Sindustry I anthology that didn't quite make it into the first volume. And most of these stories should NOT have been included. This anthology had very few redeeming stories and some that make me want to puke, which kinda dampens any enthusiasm I might have for the whole. Mostly it's filled with stories with awful, weak, boring, TSTL characters who couldn't characterize their way out of a paper bag, and their ridiculously over-protective and unrealistic saviors. I have never really understood what m/m readers are complaining about when they say that that one of the characters doesn't have to be the woman, but I do now. In this volume, one half of the relationship was invariably the damsel in distress who needed saving, the other the knight in shining armor who knew just how to take care of things, pretty lady-uh, I mean lad. Yech.

As in Sindustry I, the premise is that these are all stories about people in the sex industry, either strippers, prostitutes, or porn actors. This volume does a much worse job of speculating about whether it is possible to have a realistic representation of tricking and yet still have a good romance. Because the other problem with most of these stories is how glamorized prostitution or stripping is made out to be. And it's not. That's why I liked "Sunshine" so much, I think, because it showed some gritty realism about what money does to a relationship.

"Package Boy" by Connie Bailey
A strange little story about a high-end rent boy who has fallen in love with a client who happens to be the heir to a Mafia family. He hears a hit ordered on his lover while on another call and the rest of the story deals with how he and his lover respond to the news. Told mostly in choppy, untagged dialogue, the conflict is mostly external. The relationship conflict isn't sign-posted very well so I didn't know that it existed until it was solved. The affection between the lovers is genuine and the sex is pretty hot, but there's a bit too much grating, unexplained mafia language. Grade: C

"Dance for Me" by Maria Albert
This story was both so melodramatic it was funny, and so completely disturbing I was sickened. Carlo is saved from an abusive john by Michael, a bouncer at a club. Carlo is barely 21 and has been kept in literal sexual slavery for 7 years, only to have been thrown out by his captor 2 weeks previously. Michael is 43 and lives at the club, which seems to be a kind of halfway house for gay homeless men, complete with Leprechaun-like Irish owner. Carlo and Michael instantly fall in love, but can't communicate enough to actually figure things out without intercession by Michael's boss. Carlo is a complete mess and Michael seems a few cards short of a deck and to have a relationship between them when Carlo is only 2 weeks out of 7 years of abuse and Michael seems emotionally unstable was unbelievably appalling. There's a limit to what can be solved in a novel, let alone a short story. Don't set up characters who need years of therapy and think some sex and a few kisses makes everything all better. Ew. The ending’s even worse, the HEA degraded beyond compare by the creepiness of Michael’s final words to Carlo. Grade: F

"Unorthodox Utopia" by G.S. Wiley
Stephen owns a salon but needs extra cash. He hires on as hair and makeup artist for a low budget porn shoot, where he meets Jeff, one of the actors, who has an abusive boyfriend. The story, told from Stephen's first person point of view, is a nice, gentle blossoming of a good relationship, as Jeff leaves his boyfriend and grows closer with Stephen. There's no sex, just two men getting to know and care for each other, even if they do it rather too quickly considering Jeff's abusive relationship. Grade: C+

"Leather Dancer" by Andrew Grey
Denny is dragged to a Leather Expo by his way-more-outgoing friend. There he sees Robbie, the next-door-neighbor he's been crushing on for months, dancing at a booth. Over the next month, they build a solid relationship. The characterization seems non-existent. Denny is a shy introvert, then he's the driving force behind the relationship. Robbie is an annoying wet noodle who seems to bend to Denny's whim and whatever the story needs him to do. Complete lameness: having Denny buy books from a booth at the Expo that is obviously the Dreamspinner booth, complete with titles mentioned. Stretching credulity: Robbie takes Denny to his father's restaurant on their first date. Boring writing, very little conflict. Grade: C-

"Corona & Lime" by Sonia Devereaux
Jacob hasn't wanted or had a relationship — or even sex — in ten months, since his boyfriend dumped him. Race is paid by Jacob's friends to pick him up in a bar. They go to Race's apartment, but Jacob puts on the breaks and they fight in a very amusing way (to me, at least). The next morning, they find a way to the beginnings of a relationship. The story is told from the point of view of both Race and Jacob as they each feel out their vulnerabilities and find how the other could fix them. Each convinced that the other couldn't want them, the end is sweetly optimistic. Grade: B

"Sunshine" by JL Merrow
I thought Merrow’s story in Sindustry I was one of the best in that volume. “Sunshine” is definitely the best in this. The story is set in England, I presume in London, and replete with British slang. Daniel is a street-walker, Rob a bouncer at a bar who checks up on Daniel on the way home. He takes Daniel home with him once, paying for sex, ruining their tentative friendship and the story tells how they find their way back to each other. Sweet and sad and wonderful. Unfortunately, it doesn’t look like Merrow has any full-length novels yet, just short stories. Pity. Grade: B+

"Night Moves" by Patric Michael
Guy who is NOT a trick spontaneously rescues a hustler and vows to protect and keep him all of his days. Huh? Over-emotional, crying at the drop of a hat, unbelievable love at first sight, out-of-left-field motivations, and generally a story that makes absolutely no sense. And don’t people know that relationship tattoos are incredibly bad juju? They’re a death knell to a relationship, so if characters go out and get one, I’m pretty much ready to chuck the book. Not sexy and romantic, just stupid! (But that might just be me.) Grade: D

"Wanting More" by Cari Z
Alex is a stripper who goes home with a trick, only to be discovered by the guy's long-term partner. He is surprised when the partner, James, shows up at the club 2 weeks later and asks for a private dance. Surprised but thrilled, because he's very attracted to James. They establish a relationship of sorts, with lots of really hot D/s sex, that eventually works into something more. A satisfying development of a wonderful relationship. Although if James didn't learn from his previous lover or from Alex, when IS he going to learn?: a fact which threatens my belief in the HEA. Grade: B-

"The Cowboy and the Movie Star" by Kate Roman
Oh, blech. Jake is the foreman of a ranch hired out for a gay porn shoot. Matthew is the star of the show and a complete and utter wet blanket. If any heroine acted like Matthew-‘completely unable to take care of himself in any way-‘I'd chuck that book across the room without hesitation. One night of hot man-lovin' changes their lives and Matthew quits in the middle of the shoot, except Jake doesn't believe him-.blahblahblah. The core of the story is when Matthew says to Jake, "Jake, do you know how long it's been since someone's touched me because I asked them to? Or because they wanted to? Because they wanted me?" And, I mean, sure. That's the fantasy, right, that prostitutes and porn stars want their One True Love as well, that sex isn't worth it without love. But these characters are awful, the story is unbelievable, the villain is ridiculous, and the sex is boring. Grade: D

"The Meaning of Perfection" by Taylor Lochland
A prostitute falls for the owner of the hotel who rents him and his roommate rooms for their jobs. Julian, the hotel owner, takes payment in kind from Felix's roommate, which makes Felix very jealous because he wants to be the one servicing Julian. He eventually gets the chance, only to have Julian reject anything more in the morning. They eventually find their way back to each other, and poof! Felix quits whoring. Um, yeah, not so much. Grade: C-

"See Me, Feel Me" by Zahra Owens
A stripper takes a private gig for a friend, only to be wined and dined by a blind massage therapist, who does his own, unofficial sex work during his business. A fun little read, but the length of these "short" stories sometimes leaves me feeling like the story could be 2000 words shorter. Very little conflict and merely a progression of the relationship ensues and while that's enjoyable, there's no incentive to keep reading besides some moderately enjoyable sex-‘nothing's at stake. Grade: C+

"Exposure" by Marguerite Labbe & Fae Sutherland
Whoa, hello head hopping! Give me whiplash, why don't you! Ahem. That aside, this was a surprisingly hot story about a photographer introducing one of his models to a little bit of BDSM. The instant attraction between the two made me roll my eyes a bit, but then I was completely sucked in to the sexual and relationship tension between the characters and was very happily following along until the photographer called the model "Pretty baby." That just stomped on all my squick buttons and pulled me right out of the story. I could tell that it was still hot in the same way it was before, except every time "pretty baby" showed up again, I'd get squicked all over again. Except for that, very enjoyable, and very very hot, very well-written D/s sex with a little bondage thrown in. Grade: B

Looking through the whole, now that I'm done, there's quite a few more Bs than I thought there were. But still, the awfulness of "Dance for Me," "Night Moves," and "The Cowboy and the Movie Star" overshadows the good of "Exposure," "Sunshine," and the quirkiness of "Corona and Lime." Skip this volume unless you can find those three stories separate.

Overall grade: C-

Best regards,
-Joan/Sarah F.

This book can be purchased at Amazon or in ebook format from Books on Board or other etailers.

Sarah F. is a literary critic, a college professor, and an avid reader of romance -- and is thrilled that these are no longer mutually exclusive. Her academic specialization is Romantic-era British women novelists, especially Jane Austen, but she is contributing to the exciting re-visioning of academic criticism of popular romance fiction. Sarah is a contributor to the academic blog about romance, Teach Me Tonight, the winner of the 2008-2009 RWA Academic Research Grant, and the founder and President of the International Association of the Study of Popular Romance (IASPR). Sarah mainly reviews BDSM romance and gay male romance and hopes to be able to beat her TBR pile into submission when she has time to think. Sarah teaches at Fayetteville State University, NC.


  1. Fae Sutherland
    Sep 19, 2009 @ 17:17:18

    I’m glad to hear you enjoyed our story, despite the issues you had with the POV and the ‘pretty baby’ endearment. :) And since you mentioned buying the story separately, it will be available on its own next spring, along with 6 other shorts featuring the same characters in a print/ebook collection of their own.

    I’m sorry the anthology as a whole didn’t work for you, however. But thank you for taking the time to read and review it!

  2. Taylor Lochland
    Sep 19, 2009 @ 18:35:06

    Thank you for taking the time to read and review the book, as well as my story. I do have to point out, however, that it’s not a definite that Felix immediately quits whoring…he says “it’s almost time for me to retire, anyway”. It was meant to imply he’s going to start phasing out of it. I apologize that it wasn’t more clear — looking at it again, I can completely understand the misinterpretation. (I’m still a newb at this writing thing, lol).

  3. Moth
    Sep 19, 2009 @ 20:07:58

    What’s the last line in Dance for Me?

  4. Emmy
    Sep 19, 2009 @ 22:30:55

    ouch. Mean Gurl is Being Mean.

    I tried to read the synopsis and didn’t make it past that very delicious looking cover. So glad I didn’t waste my money. Will still happily perv on that very talented cover model. NOM!

  5. SonomaLass
    Sep 19, 2009 @ 22:40:49

    Oh, anthologies. Always a risk. I’ll be watching for a couple of these if/when they become available separately.

    Thanks for taking the time to assess each story!

  6. Joan/SarahF
    Sep 20, 2009 @ 10:39:31

    @Moth: Um, I think, “Dance for me,” actually. It’s the context that makes it creepy and yucky.

  7. Angela Wilson
    Sep 20, 2009 @ 11:53:45

    I have a really hard time finding romantic anthologies that keep me reading. It stinks when I find a really terrific one, then run out and buy the next volume, only to realize it is filled with rejects – which happens too often in this genre. I finally gave up and try to find individual stories that work for me as a (fickle) reader.

    The breakdown of stories was really informative. I rarely see that in reviews, but it added something “extra.”

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

  8. JL Merrow
    Sep 20, 2009 @ 12:21:10

    While I winced on behalf of some of my fellow authors, I was pleased you liked my story! Thanks for reading and reviewing this and the previous volume.

    I don’t have any full-length novels yet (I’m trying to work up the word count gradually!) but I have some more short stories coming out soon and am working on a novella. :)

  9. K. Z. Snow
    Sep 20, 2009 @ 19:50:16

    Ah, the health hazards of being strenuously gracious. I’ve found it helps to stick a sock in my mouth before I read reviews of my books; it keeps down the number of cracked teeth resulting from a clenched jaw as I type Thank you. ;-)

%d bloggers like this: