Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Shattered by JoAnn Ross

Dear Ms Ross,

045122612701lzzzzzzzLast fall I read the previous book in this series, “Crossfire.” Yes, this would be me reading a book about a (former) Navy SEAL. The same me who often laments the high rate of SEAL heroes on the ground. “Crossfire” worked better for me than it appeared to do for Jane and unfortunately it also worked better than does “Shattered.”

Army Night Stalker helicopter pilot Shane Garrett survived the clusterfuck operation in Afghanistan that cost him his leg. But surviving Army doctor Kirby Campbell was another matter. Shane nobly sent her away then got on with his rehab. Now outfitted with a prosthetic leg that’s almost better than his own was, he teaches private flying lessons and does some lecturing at the military academy in South Carolina near where the sniper evens of “Crossfire” took place.

Former Army doctor Kirby Campbell put her heart on the line when she went to see Shane shortly after his evacuation from Iraq. And he stomped it flat even though he never left his bed during the whole time she was offering it. Since then, she’s continued to work as a doctor with Worldwide Medical Relief and is currently trying to help the desperately poor people of a Central American country ruled by an oily-smooth dictator.

It’s while she’s in Washington, DC speaking to a Senate committee about conditions there that her fellow doctor and best friend is taken hostage by rebels. They don’t know the US government won’t hand over money for Rachel’s release but Kirby knows that if Rachel isn’t rescued quickly, she’ll probably be killed. Now it’s up to the Phoenix Team to do what the US can’t do – and that’s get Rachel out of there. Kirby’s not going to be left behind nor is Shane, once he learns the woman he’s never stopped loving is putting her life on the line.

The first part of “Shattered” jumps back and forth as we get the conclusion of the spec ops mission that wove through much of “Crossfire.” When the first book ended, Shane was in desperate shape having been badly injured. Now we see exactly what happened to him and watch while SEALs Zach Tremayne and Quinn McKade as well as a CIA spook, an Air Force Combat Controller and some Army Rangers battle their way through the snow covered mountains of the Hindu Kush before landing in the relief camp where Kirby is currently working.

Then it jumps to the scenes where Kirby and Shane first met and began having wild nookie while they were off duty – and occasionally on. Then the action finally settles down to what’s happening now in Monteleon and the US as the Phoenix Team gets ready for the rescue. I was glad when the action in the book stopped switching back and forth and we could just move forward.

Kirby is – for the most part – a heroine I like. Shortly before I began this book, I had just finished one with yet another tall, willowy, lithe heroine whose legs go on for miles. Since I look nothing like that, I sent up a silent prayer to get a book with a heroine more like me. Kirby, with the exception of her blonde hair, is perfect. Curvy and vertically challenged. Thank you. She’s also intelligent, passionate about her profession and the work she’s currently doing. She asks smart questions, follows directions and generally avoids TSTL moves. I would wish that she’d made Shane grovel just a tad more since he broke her heart but since he’s obviously head over heels about her and it appears that she’s got him tied in knots, okay.

Shane and all the other Spec Ops guys in this book walk on water. Or so I would believe after reading this book. I liked the action sequences here. They’re very military and sound like what I’ve heard from the military men I know. It’s all understated black humor, dead on seriousness about getting the job done and determination to succeed. It’s when the men are around nonmilitary people that I tended to notice a gushing, fan girl squee factor. It’s not as bad as the “worship at the altar of SEALs” that I’ve read in other books but it’s definitely there.

There were also points in the story that made me wonder why you included them. When the injured Shane is brought to Kirby’s camp, she spends precious minutes debating with Quinn and Zach the proper military procedure. Yeah, they all know it. They’re aware of what they’ve done by bringing Shane there but his leg is shattered, he’s lying in his own frozen blood and he’s probably going to die if he doesn’t get medical care. So stop arguing already Kirby and help him. Which she finally does.

Then we get two chapters of Kirby bonding with the wives of other Phoenix Team members. It’s like a teenage slumber party with wine and discussions of sex. I didn’t need this a book labeled as a “High Risk Novel.” I also wondered about the history lesson Kirby imparts to Shane in a sleazy dive on their way to the rescue as well as the political science discussion Shane and a CIA operative have after a shoot out. Surreal, would describe my reactions to them. WTF am I reading here? would be another.

Quinn, Zach and the other Phoenix Team people along with Shane and Kirby take great care with the rescue plans. Lots of money that this uber rich organization has appears to be spent, special contacts are contacted to produce the special stuff needed that they require to pull it all off. More secretive people get involved once they reach Monteleon and there’s even an undercover agent among the rebels.

But then you spring the news on us that Shane is supposed to go to a nearby government base and steal a helicopter to fly them out. A copter that apparently they all just hope like hell is going to be there. WTF!! I thought. All those plans, all that money, all those other people putting themselves at risk in a country run by a dictator complete with goon squads and the escape plan hinges on the hope that they’re going to be able to get a copter to fly their asses out of there? My cat listened to me rant in disbelief and major points got deducted from the final grade here.

Still, I did like huge sections of the book. It was nice to see poor Michael the former priest find his true love even if she turns out to be a little squirrely, IMO. I hope they’re very happy doing their relief work among gun toting children. I could easily have passed on the slightly emo moments that passed between the men since I found them almost impossible to believe. As I said earlier, Kirby deserved more than one grovel, though it was sincere and lengthy. I liked the way you placed them in a location that will probably make them very happy. But the “gee kids, let’s hope we can find transport out of this jungle hellhole” part of the rescue just about did me in. C+


This book can be purchased in mass market from Amazon or ebook format from the Sony Store and other etailers.

Another long time reader who read romance novels in her teens, then took a long break before started back again about 15 years ago. She enjoys historical romance/fiction best, likes contemporaries, action- adventure and mysteries, will read suspense if there's no TSTL characters and is currently reading very few paranormals.


  1. joanne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 13:30:58

    I just by happenstance started an older Silhouette Special Edition — Dancing in the Moonlight by Raeanne Thayne this morning that has the female protagonist who is a Lieutenant and comes back from Afghanistan where she lost her leg. I’m not very far into the story but she is adjusting to wearing a prosthesis and just walking up a few steps is painful. Will she be able to resuce the world in a year? Dunno …. but then she is just a soldier, not a SEAL…

    I’ve flip-flopped with liked/disliked on JoAnn Ross’s stories, I’ll probably give this one a pass. Thanks for the review.

  2. ReacherFan
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 13:53:53

    Thank heavens. I went nuts trying to get into Shattered and finally decided I wasn’t in the mood or something. I felt really bad about it as I enjoy the her first two. Where DO they get all that money?

    Instead, I read 3 books by Shelly Laurenston (her Pide series). Not as good as the Mangus Pack, but I had some laughs.

  3. Amanda
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 14:27:57

    Joanne, it really depends quite a bit on the physical shape of the person before the amputation and the location of the amputation. Above the knee is much more difficult to adjust to because you lose your knee joint, though prosthetics have improved tremendously in the fourteen years since I lost my leg above the knee. Plus, Seth, the hero in Shattered, is outfitted with all kinds of cool experimental gadgets for his leg that are not available to the average amputee. Every experience is different though. There are some amputees who have little trouble with phantom pain and take to wearing a prosthesis like a duck to water, and then there are others who can’t stand to have anything touch their leg area at all.

    Probably more than you wanted to know:) But it’s rare that amputees appear at all in romance so I was disposed to like Shattered for that reason alone.

  4. Jayne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 14:35:42

    Plus, Seth, the hero in Shattered, is outfitted with all kinds of cool experimental gadgets for his leg that are not available to the average amputee.

    I was just about to post something about this. From the way Ross describes it, the Six Million Dollar Man would envy what Shane gets fitted up with. Plus he’s had a number of months of rehab before the rescue action begins.

  5. Jayne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 14:42:39

    I felt really bad about it as I enjoy the her first two.

    As I said, I enjoyed “Crossfire” more and would give it a B. I’d like to at least try the next book in the series about the Air Force guy.

    Where DO they get all that money?

    And why the f*ck didn’t they spend some of it to have a helicopter already standing by to help them escape? I dunno the answer to either. Perhaps it comes from the specialty teas that Zach’s wife sells.

  6. joanne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 16:05:41

    Plus, Seth, the hero in Shattered, is outfitted with all kinds of cool experimental gadgets for his leg that are not available to the average amputee.

    I’m sure…. but in the book I’m reading the heroine gets the doctor *grin* ….. I just gotta’ love romance books!

    Probably more than you wanted to know:)

    Not more then I wanted to know because this moring I didn’t know anything about amputees and now I know something… so thank you.

    And why the f*ck didn't they spend some of it to have a helicopter already standing by to help them escape?

    Um… because hope springs eternal?

  7. Lori
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 17:24:37

    I’m in the midst of writing my own review of this, and the one thing that irked me the most seemed to be good for you – that is the resolution for Father Michael. IMO, he deserved his own book, or at the very least, not a throw-away one liner that yeah, he got his HEA. I was so disappointed in his story resolution. Ross has been stringing him along for several books now, even across a couple of series, and even has the audacity to call him Father What-a-Waste, then pawned him off with a few paragraphs. I was tremendously put out by that.

    OK, rant over. Big sigh. I feel better :)

  8. Jayne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 19:53:34

    Probably more than you wanted to know:) But it's rare that amputees appear at all in romance so I was disposed to like Shattered for that reason alone.

    Which reminds me that the heroine of Brenda Minton’s next Steeple Hill Love Inspired book (due in May, IIRC) is a war vet who lost part of her leg in Iraq. You might want to check that book out. And I second what Joanne said, thanks for the info.

  9. Jayne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 19:55:40

    Um… because hope springs eternal?

    Now that’s exactly what I want to pin my hopes on as I’m fleeing for my life in a goon infested country with an active volcano adding to the festive atmosphere. Yeah, let’s just hope….

  10. Jayne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 19:58:23

    Lori, I was also surprised that Michael didn’t at least get a larger role in this book if not be the star of his own. It didn’t upset me as much since I don’t have as much invested in the series, having only started it with “Crossfire.” But I can understand your need to vent.

  11. Amanda
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 20:05:48

    Thanks, Jayne. I’ll keep an eye out for that Minton book:)

    Lori, I was sort of bummed about Michael’s all too brief HEA too. Though I wasn’t all that invested in him–at least not enough to be angry. But I can definitely sympathise.

  12. Elly Soar
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 20:27:38

    FWIW Dancing in the Moonlight is available as one of the Harlequin 60th anniversary free e-book downloads at – I just read it and it was pretty good!

  13. Janine
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 20:33:58

    My cat listened to me rant in disbelief


  14. Jayne
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 20:36:19

    Oh, my poor kitty gets to listen to lots of this. When a book is going well I’m quiet as a mouse but when WTFery moments spring up, he gets an earful.

  15. Janine
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 20:46:14

    Poor kitty. Please pet him for me.

  16. Robin
    Mar 02, 2009 @ 22:31:48

    I have been interested in reading Ross’s books since she made this comment on Murder She Writes. Condoms in 80’s Romance??!! Two men equally in love with a Romance heroine??!! I recently purchased Blaze, which I haven’t read yet, but it sounds like Ross is willing to make some unusual choices with her characters, so I’m determined to give her books a try (oh, and I got the free one, too). Any recommendations, anyone?

%d bloggers like this: