Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: It’s All Geek to Me by J.L. Merrow


Dear Ms. Merrow:

From the second sentence of this novella, which mentions a shop window full of “Daisies vs. Ghouls” merchandise, I was charmed. My people! Well, not really, because our narrator is not in fact a gamer or a comic book fan or any kind of geek unless you count Rugby. (And why not?) What he is, is madly in lust with the tall guy behind the shop counter. What he also is is a very entertaining narrator. He may not be a classic geek, but he’d fit right in.

Jez is on an errand of mercy, replacing the comic book that smashed up along with his mate Tel. He’s instantly smitten with comic book store clerk Rhys, fantasizing that working at the “superheroes spiritual home” has given him powers and dubbing him Seducto Smile. He himself rapidly evolves into Blushman. (“Costume: a bright pair of saggy underpants. Socks with suspenders. And sandals.”)

A bad break-up has left Jez feeling down on himself and he can’t imagine Rhys, with his piercings and studs and too-hip-to-shave stubble, wanting anything to do with him. “I’m like the opposite of cool,” he grumbles to Tel. “If I were a supervillain, I’d be Antifreeze.” (For an avowed non-geek, Jez uses geeky metaphors an awful lot; he thinks of Tel in his hospital bed, “with scaffolding all round his legs like a beardy cyborg.”) His only in seems to be getting a crash course from Tel so he can pretend to love all things geeky. And the amazing thing is, it seems to work.

With his blathering and low self-esteem and self-described “cuddly” body, Jez’s spiritual home would probably be chick-lit. I might have gotten utterly sick of him except 1) It’s a short novella, 2) Blathering sounds so much better in British vernacular, and 3) He and Rhys are delightful together:

“Um. Just so you know, I don’t actually make a habit of asking blokes to go to sex shops with me the second time I see them.”

“More a third date thing, is it? Got it.”

“I mean, it’s not like this is even a date, or anything,” I babbled on. “Just, you know, me buying and you selling. Stuff. Comic-book stuff. Not, like, sex or anything. Um. Is there an apocalypse happening any time soon? Because that’d be good.”

Rhys was laughing helplessly. “Sorry. Fresh out of apocalypses. You’ll have to come back next week. Or I could ask Kelly if we can order one in for you.”

Their actual date turns out to be at a Rugby match, and culminates in some playful sex and some not very surprising revelations. It’s a slight story, and the ending is fairly obvious from the get-go. But it definitely did its job as a short comic romance; I read pretty much the whole thing with a smile on my face. B-



AmazonBNSonyKoboAREBook DepositoryGoogle


Willaful fell in love with romance novels at an early age, but ruthlessly suppressed the passion for years, while grabbing onto any crumbs of romance to be found in other genres. She finally gave in and started reading romance again in 2006, and has been trying to catch up with the entire genre ever since. Look for her on twitter or at her blog at


  1. JacquiC
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 08:41:22

    I absolutely love this author’s voice. Her book, “Slam!”, is one of my favourite reads ever. I am rushing to buy this one.

  2. Willaful
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 11:32:28

    @JacquiC: I tend to prefer her for rich characterizations, like Muscling Through and Pricks and Pragmatism, and that’s obviously not the case here. But I still enjoyed the sparkle a lot. I have yet to read Slam!, which even I pre-ordered! [shameface]

  3. Fake Geek Guys Unite | A Willful Woman...
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 11:39:06

    […] I have a review of It’s All Geek to Me by J.L. Merrow at Dear Author. […]

  4. JacquiC
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 12:40:18

    @Willaful: I have been meaning to read the ones you mention. I read Hard Tail and Slam! and one other that I don’t remember now. I started with Slam! because I read a review and it talked about one of the heroes as a martial artist that is nicknamed “karate crumpet” by the other hero. I clicked instantly to buy it. I have a black belt in karate myself, so couldn’t wait to see how karate was included in the story! I was not disappointed…

  5. cleo
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 15:07:28

    Interesting. My favorites are Muscling Through, and Pricks and Pragmatism, and I didn’t care for Slam! or Hard Tail. I didn’t hate them, but I didn’t love them the way I expected to (and I really I didn’t like how Hard Tail handled domestic violence – I thought it was too slight a story for a serious topic).

    I’ve been on the fence about this one, since I was disappointed by Slam! and the tone seems similar. Maybe I’ll save it for a crappy day when I need the sparkle. I do like British blathering and JL Merrow’s voice.

  6. Willaful
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 18:27:19

    @cleo: I’ve also been sorry that her more recent books don’t have the depth of those novellas. Since this was just aiming for fun, I was okay with it.

  7. Julia
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 18:49:34

    @cleo & @willaful I’m with you on Muscling Through and Pricks and Pragmatism being favorites. But I pretty much always enjoy her humor, so I might give this one a try. I’m just wary of the length – I prefer at least novella length and this one seems closer to a short.

  8. Kaetrin
    Feb 10, 2014 @ 20:56:35


%d bloggers like this: