Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Wishes and Stitches by Rachel Herron

Dear Ms. Herron,

A few years ago it seems quilting in romance books was all the rage. Now it appears that knitting has taken over. I’ve resisted reading any of these books since I’m not a knitter but in my quest to expand my single title contemporary repertoire, I decided to take the plunge with your book “Wishes and Stitches” since it features an outsider heroine who’s also a doctor. I figured that way, she’s got some other interests besides yarn.

Wishes and Stitches by Rachel HerronNaomi Fontaine had a great time at a recent medical conference which included a hot night with a handsome fellow attendee. Thinking she’d probably not ever see him again, she let it all loose and both had a night to remember. So when Rig Keller shows up in the small town of Cedar Hollow, CA where Naomi practices Family Medicine (GP), she’s shocked. Her next stunner is when she discovers that her pretty much absentee partner is selling out and that Rig is taking his place in the practice.

Rig, so called because up til now he’s practiced on the Gulf oil rigs, enjoyed the time he spent with Naomi at the conference and has no intention of not pursuing a relationship with her now that they’re living in the same town and seeing each other on a day to day basis. But he can’t seem to figure her out. The warm, confident woman of That Night is not who he’s seeing. Yes, she’s an excellent doctor but outside of work, she keeps a tight rein on her emotions and doesn’t appear to want to let him back into her private life.

Her secret is that Naomi desperately wants to be a part of her new community but a natural reserve keeps her from just jumping into town life. Rig, on the other hand, seems right at home with a long established brother in the community. If he presses for more from her, will Naomi open up personally and professionally? And if she does, is Rig ready and willing to commit to a future together?

Good God the people of this town love to knit. Rig calls it correctly when he says something to the effect that this is the knittingest town he’s ever seen. I wonder if the townsfolk would shun someone because that person – gasp! – crochets or, worse, merely sews or scrapbooks? Is there a roadblock at the edge of town to check for balls of yarn before a person is allowed within the city limits? I like characters with outside interests beyond sex or their jobs but this borders on obsession.

Naomi Fontaine is reserved to the point of almost being an emotional stone wall in the face of others yet she’s got such a deep well of need to fit in and be accepted. That plus the fact that this is a small, blue collar town whose townsfolk feel a social gulf between themselves and the doctor don’t help her to fit in and be welcomed with open arms. Rig has an “in” since his brother has lived there for years and is an accepted part of the community. And he’s also a more “open” personality. Meanwhile, Naomi has spent her childhood and most of her adulthood, on getting good grades in order to fulfill her lifelong goal of being a doctor with little time spent socializing outside of those in her profession. Her difficulties in small talk and being part of the crowd might seem exaggerated but they also feel poignant and serve to show the glass wall between Naomi and what she wants – to be accepted.

Naomi’s got some baggage in the persons of her younger and – in Naomi’s mind – favored sister Anna and her mother with whom Naomi has never gotten along. These issues don’t feel made up or too far fetched. A lifetime of this also helps shade in the details on why Naomi would feel as if she’s trying but not getting anywhere with the people of Cedar Hollow. The flashes of anger Naomi shows when Anna appears on her doorstep expecting Naomi to fix the mess Anna has made of her life show that Naomi isn’t a pushover. The fact that Naomi doesn’t just tell Anna to take a hike show that deep down, she does love her sister but this time it’s going to be tough love.

Despite the fact that Rig is apparently more self assured than Naomi doesn’t count for much in their relationship. The book starts off with them already having met and spent a night of hot sexing at a medical conference and it’s Rig who spends the book chasing after Naomi while coaxing her into a repeat of the best sex of his life. This is a neat turn on the usual heroine who is shy of and bumbling at sex with a cool, confident hero. The Big Mis, when it came, arrived out of Naomi and Rig’s profession and seemed relevant to who they are and how they see themselves – plus a healthy dollop of family love. It takes Rig a little while to get over what happens but as he does, he comes to a greater and deeper understanding of this woman he loves.

I loved the humorous scenes scattered throughout the story. The one of Naomi running into Rig’s father Frank – in the condom aisle of the local pharmacy store – when Frank knows Naomi and Rig are about to go out on a date, had me in stitches – sorry bad pun. The men of the Keller clan were fun to read about and such…well, men. Of the two secondary romances, Frank’s worked better for me than the quickie of Rig’s brother Jake. That one is just too fast though the fact that both Keller brothers end the book happily living in sin at the instigation of their ladies is cool with me.

I will admit to a partiality for books with the hero chasing after his heroine so on that score, the romance in this one works for me. What I got tired of is the almost cult like mania for knitting. If this is a reader’s craft of choice then they’ll probably be happier while reading about it but for those uninterested in it – like me – it felt like a cup of Kool Aid along with a pair of knitting needles was being pressed on me by a group eerily smiling people. C+


Goodreads | Amazon | BN | nook | Sony | Kobo

Another long time reader who read romance novels in her teens, then took a long break before started back again about 15 years ago. She enjoys historical romance/fiction best, likes contemporaries, action- adventure and mysteries, will read suspense if there's no TSTL characters and is currently reading very few paranormals.


  1. Isobel Carr
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 12:20:35

    I’m not a knitter, but I love Herron’s voice. Haven’t read this one yet, but I find her books to be emotional reads (which is rare for me).

  2. Jayne
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 12:27:11

    @Isobel Carr: Well, if you’d like to try knitting, there’s a pattern included at the end. It’s the shawl that Naomi knits throughout the story.

  3. Isobel Carr
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 12:57:39

    The last thing I have time for is yet another time consuming hobby, LOL! But I will say that I’ve seen Rachel’s scarves (she’s a local RWA chaptermate) and they are GORGEOUS!

  4. Ros
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 16:05:48

    I knit but I am always wary of books with knitting in them. There was a whole genre of ‘knitting books’ which always featured one romance, one single-parent, one person with terminal cancer, one ‘kooky’ woman. And so on. The person with terminal cancer dies at the end.

    Is Naomi’s problem with fitting in with the community that she can’t knit?

  5. Ros
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 16:08:30

    I just checked – there’s whole series of these knitting books: ‘Cyprus Hollow Yarn’. Which perhaps explains the need for everyone in the town to be knitting obsessed.

  6. Jayne
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 16:47:04

    @Ros: Naomi does knit but for some reason she hides it from the knitting community there. She was taught by one of her former patients – who died from cancer – who lived in the town and who had come to…either San Francisco or Los Angelos where Naomi was in residency which is how they met.

  7. Jayne
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 16:48:00

    @Ros: I kind of got the feeling that there had probably been previous books in the series.

  8. Ros
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 17:07:36

    @Jayne: Secret knitting? Stealth knitting? I am boggling.

  9. Jayne
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 17:13:38

    @Ros: Naomi is very reserved and just can’t let loose and tell people she knits. She just freezes up. So, yeah, it’s stealth knitting!

  10. cleo
    Nov 08, 2011 @ 19:49:53

    @Ros: That so sounds like Debbie Macomber and her knitting / romance series. It took me maybe one and half books to figure out that they were all going to be the same.

  11. Meagan
    Nov 09, 2011 @ 00:12:54

    Haha, knitting is a bit cultish. I’m a crocheter, and I always feel a little out of the loop when I go to yarn-craft meet-ups. Although I must say that crocheting has become less of the red-headed stepsister recently. ;-)

    In any case, good review. Like Ros, I’m a bit wary to pick up a knitting/yarn-crafting book, but I do appreciate you going out of your comfort zone to read this one for us!

  12. Sunita
    Nov 09, 2011 @ 07:04:50

    Thanks, Jayne! I remember a bunch of knitting books coming out a while ago (there were knitting mysteries, too) when the knitting fad was at its peak.

    Like Ros, I’m boggling a bit at the idea that a love of knitting would be something to hide. Any shoutouts to Ravelry or the knitlist? :-)

    I’m curious now about the pattern, though.

  13. Teri P.
    Nov 09, 2011 @ 11:02:49

    Hmmm..a whole book revolving around knitting? I love crafts, and although I do not knit, I don’t mind the hobby taking place in the story, as long as it doesn’t hijack the story! Along with the rest of you, I can’t imagine hiding my love of a craft either. Stealth knitting – honest, I thought you must be kidding, but I guess not!

    Christina Skye’s new book has knitters in it, and she does an excellent job of working this in to the background of the story. I cross stitch, and have never been able to tell others what exactly it means to me, but Skye does that in her new book, A Home By the Sea. And it has a knitting pattern at the end of the book too!

  14. eastofeden
    Nov 10, 2011 @ 13:26:26

    Have not read this one yet…but have read Heron’s other novels and yes knitting was an important thread throughout. I guess as a knitter myself I did not find it that in your face so to speak.
    Knitting as a craft/hobby is interesting…and stealth knitting is not uncommon. As knitting still has some stigma attached to it. If you sew or quilt you make works of art..but there is an attitude that knitting is for grannies and why would any modern woman spend time on such a antiquated trivial pasttime….

    As an aside Herons journey to published author is interesting..I believe she participated in NaNoWriMo and ended up with publishing contract as a result.

%d bloggers like this: