Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Noble Satyr by Lucinda Brant

Dear Ms. Brant,

When you offered DA the chance to review some of your books, I got all excited. After all, I adore mid 18th century Georgian era set novels and that seems to be your specialty. Since I try to read series books in order, I decided to try “Noble Satyr” first. It also attracted me because based on the excerpt provided at your website, it looked like a book in which I’d get the down and dirty edition of life at Versailles plus a truly unsavory villain. But while it started off differently from lots of historical romances I’ve read, ultimately it failed to maintain that freshness.

“Paris and London 1745. Abandoned at Versailles by her dying grandfather, Antonia is pursued by the lascivious Comte de Salvan who plans to wed her to his drug-addicted son then make Antonia his mistress. When the libertine Duke of Roxton snatches Antonia from Salvan's clutches, she believes herself rescued. But has Antonia merely swapped one seducer for another?”

Antonia is initially presented as a young woman who’s been hauled around Europe and lived at the Court of Versailles where glitter gilds the surface but darkness lurks just beneath. In an age when females were married at 15 and she’d seen what she’d seen, I expected a bit more from her. Though she appears to have a plan for her future, and does put it into effect, all too quickly she starts this breathless little girl thing where she stutters and stammers in the presence of the Duke, acts totally flustered and comes off as too naive. I guess this is supposed to signify how lacking in experience she is compared to the rakehell Duke yet I couldn’t shake the disappointment of watching her lose what sophistication you’d given her to begin with. She also never seemed to grow as a character. At the end of the book, though she’s now a married lady and has gone through some harrowing experiences, she still acts very much as she did at the start of the book.

The Duke of Roxton also intrigued me when the story began. He honestly seemed to a true rake. Women want him and men want to be him. He’s got this “I’m a Duke in an age when this means something and I’ll act like it” mentality. He’s dictatorial, he’s autocratic and if something doesn’t interest him – screw it. He’s got power and presence and isn’t above the snub or put down. At first, he couldn’t care less about Antonia’s problems and I found it refreshing that such a man isn’t instantly transformed by the power of lurve. It takes him a while and when he does fall, I feel as if I’ve seen his change of heart and believe it.

But while I like the character of the Duke, the age dynamic between Roxton and Antonia veered further and further off as the story progressed. She’s a young 17 and he’s – what? closer to 40? And while sometimes this type of disparity in age doesn’t bother me, here it did. After Antonia comes to Paris to live with Roxton and his sister, he and his friend Vallentine seem to treat her as a pet – indulgently laughing at her outrageous statements and actions. She also often sits on cushions and footstools at Roxton’s feet and they call her minx and chit. All this kept hammering home how young she is compared to them and frankly, by the end, it icked me.

The plot also sputtered out for me. The book starts promisingly with a truly horrifying fate in store for Antonia if she doesn’t act quickly. She does and initially avoids it. Then when she gets to England, here’s another surprising twist in that her self absorbed grandmother hates her and is willing to let the villain get Antonia in his clutches again. But along the way comes the “one night for true love” – okay six nights but the basic premise is the same as I’ve read before. Then there’s the Big Mis, which I saw coming a mile off, until Roxton and Antonia are reunited in love. But wait, there’s still more of the book left! So I guessed at what might happen to reach the end and wasn’t wrong. When a book starts off in a fresh way, I hate it when I end up predicting what’s coming.

Oh, and I know this is a minor issue but by the end of the book, I found it more and more annoying. Roxton has this verbal tick of adding ‘er’ in his sentences whenever he’s pausing to think or for effect. Had I made it a drinking game I would have been sloshed off my ass but as it was, I was beginning to mentally rewrite his dialogue which is never a good sign with me.

I know this is your first published novel and even though you’ve gone back and reworked it some, I think it shows. Had I read it years ago, I’m positive that my grade would have been higher but the dependence on some tired tropes and my uneasiness with the age difference between the hero and heroine cancel out my initial delight in what is fresh about it to me. I would like to try another of your books to determine if it’s just ‘first novel blues’ and to see if you’ve stretched as an author. But for this one, it’s a C-

~Jayne

nook | Borders
| Sony| Smashwords

Another long time reader who read romance novels in her teens, then took a long break before started back again about 15 years ago. She enjoys historical romance/fiction best, likes contemporaries, action- adventure and mysteries, will read suspense if there's no TSTL characters and is currently reading very few paranormals.

13 Comments

  1. GrowlyCub
    Dec 09, 2010 @ 15:39:07

    Shades of ‘These Old Shades’?

  2. Tweets that mention REVIEW: Noble Satyr by Lucinda Brant | Dear Author -- Topsy.com
    Dec 09, 2010 @ 15:49:31

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by rissatoo and dearauthor, dearauthor. dearauthor said: NewPost: REVIEW: Noble Satyr by Lucinda Brant http://dearauthor.com/wordpress/2010/12/09/review-noble-satyr-by-lucinda-brant/ [...]

  3. Jayne
    Dec 09, 2010 @ 16:03:23

    @GrowlyCub: Yes, and in a bad way.

  4. Pep Brown
    Dec 09, 2010 @ 21:00:28

    Okay, let me start off by saying I am a BIG fan of Lucinda Brant’s novels. Yes, there are shades of “these old shades” though I disagree with “in a bad way” even it is an imitation of the great Georgette (but there are plenty of those out there, good and bad!) I found Brant’s take on TOS refreshing and full of humor. I agree that Antonia’s girliness is a bit grating but just like Leonie she is exuberant and young and perhaps it is more that those around her change for the better because of her. Read NS for the humor, the dialogue and the setting. The sequel is just as good (IMHO), so Jayne, I hope you will satisfy your curiosity and put in a request to Ms.Brant.

  5. Lucinda Brant
    Dec 10, 2010 @ 01:12:20

    Dear Jayne,
    Thanks so much for taking the time to read and review Noble Satyr. I appreciate your candor and while disappointed it wasn’t to your taste, at least it didn’t end up in the DNF pile, for which I am mightily relieved. I am happy to send you the next book in the Roxton series, Midnight Marriage, about Roxton and Antonia’s son Julian, if and when you would like to read it. You will be pleased to know that the hero and heroine are both in their twenties. As to whether you will like their story… I await your review.
    Regards
    Lucinda

  6. Jayne
    Dec 10, 2010 @ 05:42:42

    @Lucinda Brant: Sure, I’m willing to give it a go though it might be awhile. I should have also mentioned that I appreciate the exerpts for your other books which came along with the file for Noble Satyr.

  7. Lucinda Brant
    Dec 10, 2010 @ 06:54:09

    Dear Jayne
    Trust the excerpts were useful.
    Just let me know when you have the time and I’ll send along Midnight Marriage.Happy to wait for the review.
    Regards
    Lucinda

  8. Estara
    Dec 10, 2010 @ 14:49:14

    I think it’s a great idea there is a free chapbook on Smashwords to let me sample the style of the author and she even included coupons to buy her books cheaper in 2010.

    I had great luck with P.B. Ryan whom I hadn’t heard of before reading about her Gilded Age mystery series here, so I’ll check out the samples offered at least.

  9. Ange
    Dec 12, 2010 @ 00:37:12

    I LOVED this book. It’s like one of those old classic swashbuckling adventure movies starring Douglas Fairbanks Jr and Jean Simmons. You’re sooo right Jayne that Roxton has this “I'm a Duke in an age when this means something and I'll act like it” mentality. He's dictatorial, he's autocratic and if something doesn't interest him – screw it.” And that’s what makes it so wonderful when he comes all unstuck over Antonia.
    I loved the scene at the theatre when after two months apart he surprises her and then doesn’t know what to say to her – he is so not himself, so not the Duke in control of everything and everyone! You know at that moment he has fallen hard for her!

    The gripe about the age difference between Roxton and Antonia surprised me though. I had no trouble with this, in fact it never occurred to me to question it. Probably because my Dad was 18 years older than my Mum. They met when she was 16 and married when she was 18. That was in the early 60s and no one batted an eyelid (as I’m guessing no one would have in the 1700s or 1800s for that matter). Dad was considered a great catch by my Mum’s parents because he was a freelance photographer, had his own business and so could support Mum (and he was a very handsome Italian, but I’m biased on that score!).
    Off to buy the sequel!! With coupons, thanks Estara for the heads up on this!

  10. Jayne
    Dec 12, 2010 @ 18:55:04

    @Ange: I don’t think the age difference would have bothered me so much had I not been reminded of it so often. I agree with you that it was probably quite common then but the ‘cutesy’ pet names used for Antonia make Roxton seem almost like a nasty, older leering relative whom you try to avoid at family get togethers.

  11. Melinda Brown
    Dec 13, 2010 @ 08:08:50

    Where can I find a copy of this book? I can’t find it on Worldcat.org or Amazon.
    Thanks,
    Melinda

  12. Lucinda Brant
    Dec 13, 2010 @ 08:41:43

    @Melinda Brown: The link below will take you to the Noble Satyr page where there are direct links to purchasing the book at various estores.
    http://lucindabrant.com/noble-satyr.php

    Alternatively, the nook and Smashwords links at the end of the review will take you directly to the purchase page for the book (the Borders and Sony links don’t seem to work)
    Regards
    Lucinda

  13. Heather
    Jan 06, 2012 @ 13:38:23

    Lucinda Brandt has found a new follower!! Her book Noble Satyr was a hit in my eyes. Antonia and the Duke of Roxton are two great main characters….with lots of depth and the ability to make me want to read on……wondering what is around the next corner for them. Antonia is sweet and I wanted to protect her, just like the Duke did!! The Duke…well all the ladies in the book thought he was wonderful….just like I did. I could not put the book down….and definitely wanted more!! Good to know that the next book of the Roxton series….is next on my list of books to read!! Thanks Lucinda!! (your newest fan!!)

%d bloggers like this: