Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Three Weddings and a Murder by Tessa Dare, Leigh...

This anthology contains stories by Tessa Dare, Leigh LaValle, Courtney Milan, and Carey Baldwin. The four authors–who call themselves The Bodice Rippers–published this anthology to raise money for the fight against breast cancer.  When the women were interviewed by USA Today, Ms. Baldwin said:

We are a group of four friends who, inspired by the many examples of philanthropy in the romance community, decided to take action in the fight against breast cancer.

We are participating in the Sept. 22 Avon Walk, which has raised more than $423 million for research to find a cure or prevention, as well as for programs that enable all patients to access quality care. Support for the medically underserved is a key priority.

We’re proud to be part of the romance community and want our team name to reflect that. While the term “bodice rippers” has been used as a derogatory way to refer to romance novels, we want to emphasize that what lies beneath the bodice is an important concern for every woman.

As part of our fund raising efforts, we put together Three Weddings and a Murder. This book is more than a compilation of reunion stories. It’s a labor of love from four friends, and it’s not intended to be a single-genre anthology. What ties together three historical romances with a contemporary romantic thriller is our love and respect for each other and for our readers. Like the readers in our community, the stories are diverse. We will donate all profits to the Avon Walk.

So, it’s a book one can feel good about buying, especially given it costs just 2.99. The anthology isn’t spectacular–I loved one of the stories, liked two (one more than the other), and disliked the fourth–but it’s a pretty good read at a great price for an excellent cause.  I give the collection, overall, a B.

Three Weddings and a Murder by Tessa Dare“The Scandalous, Dissolute, No-Good Mr. Wright” by Tessa Dare.

This was my favorite tale of the four. Eighteen year old Eliza Cade is the youngest of four sisters. Eliza’s parents see her as their most troublesome daughter–due to a reputation wrecking choice she made as a young girl–and have refused to allow her to come out into society until her older three sisters are wed. Eliza chafes mightily under the limits imposed upon her. One night, at a ball hosted by her parents to announce one of her sisters’ engagements, Eliza is hiding out in her family’s morning room, peeking at the dancers through the keyhole, and gossiping with her sister. When her sister leaves the room, Eliza is mortified to realize there’s a man in the room, a man who’s heard all the embarrassing things she’s just said. When she realizes the man is none other than the scandalous Harry Wright–the sort of scoundrel no young lady should ever be caught alone with–she’s both appalled and enthralled. The two share a tantalizing conversation and make quite an impression on the other.

Over the next four years, Eliza and Harry are thrown together in various situations. Harry’s actions on the surface appear to be those of a debauched, unprincipled womanizer, but the truth about the Scandalous, Dissolute, No-Good Mr. Wright is not as it appears.

This is wonderfully told story. Ms. Dare, in fewer than 150 pages, creates a compelling, interesting plot and two winning protagonists.  Eliza and Harry are just right for one another—their interactions sparkle and sizzle with wit and desire.  This story gets a solid A and ranks up there with the very best of Ms. Dare’s work.

“The Misbehaving Marquess” by Leigh LaValle.

This novella is also a treat. Its heroine, Catherine Raybourne, the Marchioness of Foster, was abandoned by her husband two weeks after their wedding. She was caught in a compromising position with another man and James, the Marquess, left her in anger. She’s heard not a word from him for the past five years and is beyond shocked to find him, one quiet Wednesday afternoon, taking tea in their library. When she asks why, after all this time, he’s returned home, he tells her, given the recent death of his cousin, he now needs an heir.

Thirty minutes later, Cat still could not catch her breath. Jamie had made the preposterous statement with utmost calm, his face quiet, his gaze steady on hers. As if he’d said “I need a new pair of boots.”

An heir.

Her skin burned with the very word.

It was not the thought of children that unsettled her. Not even the knowledge of how children were created.

It was the memories. Vivid flashes of heat that thrummed under her skin. Jamie in her bed. The shock of his mouth everywhere. His skin impossibly smooth against hers. The places she craved him. Jamie filling her, again and again, the madness between them. Her unimaginable pleasure.

Five years of a cold bed and she had not forgotten a thing.

Cat and Jamie grew up together and were very much in love when they married. Cat’s behavior, though innocent, enraged Jamie; his abandonment angered her equally.  Cat has spent the past five years working on Jamie’s estate and being desperately lonely. Jamie has traveled the world, always thinking about the woman he left behind. When he returns, the passion the two have always had for one another is still potent yet neither finds it easy to move past their hurtful past.

Ms. LaValle is an excellent wordsmith–I loved the language in this story. She does a nice job of showing the reader how both Jamie and Cat feel–their conflict and its resolution is deftly portrayed. Ironically, what I liked least about the story was its length. It was longer than it needed to be and overly and unnecessarily dramatic in its last quarter. Nonetheless, it was an enjoyable read. I give it a B.

“The Lady Always Wins” by Courtney Milan.

Frankly, I was surprised I didn’t enjoy this novella more. I loved two of Ms. Milan’s earlier novellas–“The Governess Affair” and “This Wicked Gift” but wasn’t as enchanted with this one.

The hero of this novella, Simon Davenant, returns to the village he grew up in to woo and wed his childhood sweetheart… in three days. The woman, Ginny Barrett Croswell, is newly widowed and the last time the two spoke, “seven years, two months, and… four days ago”, the two had a raging argument over Ginny’s decision to marry another man. At the end of that fight, as Ginny reminds Simon, he threatened her.

“You’ve allotted three days to accomplish all your threats?” Now she did smile. “My. You’ll be working quickly. When last we spoke, you said that if I married Mr. Croswell, I’d regret it.”

“I don’t believe I used quite those words. But yes, you’ve got the general gist of my sentiment.”

She put her head to one side, looking off into the distance. “You claimed that when he passed away, you’d seduce me, and once I’d fallen in love with you, you’d stomp on my bleeding heart and leave me weeping.” She recited those words as sweetly as if she were discussing a favorite recipe for plum preserves. “Oh, don’t give me that freezing look; I’m just trying to make sure our memories are in accord.”

There was only one thing for it. He was going to have to lie.

He reached across the table and took her hand. “You’ve got one thing wrong, Ginny. I didn’t just claim that I’d do those things. I promised I would.” He stroked his thumb across her palm. “And you know I always keep my promises.”

Simon, who has made a fortune on the railways, is about to lose all of his wealth to a competitor… in three days. He knows–for this is the reason she rejected his suit seven years ago–Ginny won’t wed him if he’s a poor man. Ginny grew up destitute and has, her entire adult life, refused to ever risk such privation again. Simon still determinedly seduces her, keeping his upcoming misfortune a secret, sure having her is worth any cost.

This story didn’t completely engage me. While I enjoyed interactions between Simon and Ginny–Ms. Milan’s romances are sensual and her characters well-spoken–I didn’t like either Simon’s deception or Ginny’s continued insistence on the importance of creature comforts. I also found the resolution of the story to be too tidy. I enjoyed the writing but not the plot. I give “The Lady Always Wins” a B-.

“Solomon’s Wisdom” by Carey Baldwin: Ms. Baldwin’s story is by far the weakest in the book. For starters, it’s awkwardly matched to the other three. And, it’s a wreck of a tale.

“Solomon’s Wisdom” is a contemporary romantic suspense tale set in Tangleheart, Texas.  Twelve years ago, Anna Kincaid confessed her love to then bad boy Charlie Drexler. He promptly left town. Charlie, now a pediatrician, has returned to Tanglewood to convince Anna to give him another chance. Charlie and Anna both are filled with lust for one another, but Anna is unsure if she can trust the guy who walked out on her without a word. I couldn’t make much sense of their story. I could feel the heat between them, but didn’t believe in their love. For starters, twelve years seems like an awfully long time for two gorgeous successful people to have been unable to move past their high school crushes. But the larger problem is that Ms. Baldwin spends far less time on the romance part of her story than she does on its suspense component.

And her suspense story is whacked. In just over 100 pages, Ms. Baldwin has shoot-outs, child-abuse, obscure medical conditions, villains stomping about in menacing hand-tooled alligator boots, and suspicious suicides.  The story is almost impossible to follow and difficult to care for. The bad guys are caricatures–I found myself giggling when I’m pretty sure I was supposed to be scared–and the good guys ridiculously lucky. The plot is implausible, psychologically manipulative (Baby in DANGER! Baby in DANGER!) and pretty much ticked me off. “Solomon’s Wisdom” gets a heartfelt D from me.

AmazonBNSonyKoboARE

I loved romances when, back in the mid 70's, in junior high, I read every Barbara Cartland novel I could check out from the library. Then, thanks to a savvy babysitter, I got my hands on the hot stuff. To this day I can remember how astonishingly steamy I found Rosemary Rogers' Sweet Savage Love. I abandoned romance when I went to college and didn't pick one up again until 2007 when I got my first Kindle. Since then, I’ve read countless romances; loved many, liked more, hated some. Most of what I read is historical and contemporary romance, but I’m open to almost any genre. I like my books to have sizzle, wit, and plots that make sense. I’d take sexy over sweet any day. I’m a sucker for smart heroes and smart-mouthed heroines. When not reading or writing about reading, or wishing I could rule the world, I'm meddling in the lives of my kids--I have four, ages 17 to 21--, managing my husband's practice, doing bossy volunteer work, and hanging out with Dr. Feelgood.

12 Comments

  1. barbara
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 12:07:56

    I so agree with your assessment of the stories. I wrote an almost identical review right after I read it, and gave the stories and the book as a whole the same ratings. The first three had excellent writing and I really liked the stories. Ms. Milan’s was not as good as her previous novella’s but the twist at the end was fun. I had read the previous book of Ms. LaValle so I knew Cat’s story. It was nice to see her HEA. Of course, Harry and Eliza were my favorite. What a wonderful love story. I say to other readers…..just enjoy!

    ReplyReply

  2. Shayera
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 12:57:44

    I so completely agree with you about this anthology. I’ve read Ms. Dare’s story about 6 times, simply because I think it’s so wonderful.
    The other stories in the book didn’t really move me that much. I read them and… yeah, that’s about it.

    ReplyReply

  3. KatieF
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 13:29:40

    I haven’t read the last story yet, but totally agree with your assessment of the first 3. Tessa Dare’s story was by far the strongest. I absolutely loved it! I liked but didn’t love the other 2.

    ReplyReply

  4. Phyllis Laatsch
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 14:50:16

    I read the first 3 stories one evening then went to sleep. The next evening, I picked up my e-reader again and read the 4th. A couple of pages in, I had to exit and double-check that it was the same anthology and I hadn’t hit the wrong button or something. Then it seemed like a reunion story, but then all of sudden there was someone shooting at them??? I love historical and suspense stories about equally, but the two in the same anthology threw me. I felt more like it was a rough draft and the author was pantsing it the day before deadline. Which is totally unfair of me, since I know how hard it is to know how to fix a story you’ve written.

    So yes, the Dare story was great. What I liked best was that it took place over several years of them meeting, then not seeing each other for a long time. It gave the story a lot more depth.

    The Milan and LaValle really close behind for me, though. Good stuff.

    ReplyReply

  5. Bren
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 15:07:29

    Whatever your tastes happen to be, you have to admit that four novellas by previously-published authors for a great cause at $2.99 is well worth the price… even if you only like one or two of the novellas. Just my 2 cents.

    ReplyReply

  6. Lou
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 15:49:51

    I enjoyed the first three stories, but the last story was terrible. I couldn’t understand what the hell was going on.

    ReplyReply

  7. Author on Vacation
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 17:22:57

    Sold. And kudos to the authors for supporting such an important cause.

    ReplyReply

  8. Rosie
    Jul 02, 2012 @ 20:03:53

    Dare’s novella was absolutely wonderful. It was witty, charming, emotional and had a fantastic ending. I loved Harry and Eliza. Worth the price — especially since it’s for a good cause!

    ReplyReply

  9. cbackson
    Jul 03, 2012 @ 11:49:59

    I generally agree with this review, although I haven’t read the last story yet (out of fear of the WTF). My only disagreement is with regard to the Milan story: while I agree that it’s not of the quality of some of her other novellas, I completely understood Ginny’s fear of poverty. One thing that makes Milan unique is that she doesn’t shy away from the grinding horribleness of poverty in her historicals (“This Wicked Gift”, in particular, stands out in that regard). Ginny isn’t afraid of lacking creature comforts; she’s afraid of starvation, of having to prostitute herself, of living a life of day to day fear and struggle. What both “This Wicked Gift” and “The Governess Affair” make clear is how truly desperate the situation of poor women in the 19th century could be. You see shadows of this in novels of that (and earlier periods) – the Bennetts don’t just want to marry off their daughters because they like weddings, they know that without a brother, the girls will be both defenseless and poor when they’re gone.

    ReplyReply

  10. Dabney
    Jul 03, 2012 @ 12:54:51

    @cbackson: I understood Ginny’s fear of poverty and didn’t like her any less for the choices she’d made in the past. I struggled a bit however with her insistence on bringing it up over and over again in her present. Especially given the resolution of the story, it seemed a bit overdone.

    ReplyReply

  11. Anna Cowan
    Jul 03, 2012 @ 18:04:15

    just bought it! I don’t always have the attention span for a full historical these days – so three novellas by great authors sounds fab.

    ReplyReply

  12. Laura Hunsaker
    Jul 04, 2012 @ 00:00:01

    This review is what pushed me to read this the other night-I’d bought it when it first released, but I just didn’t have the chance to read it. Your review pushed me to make time. I was up til after 1am reading Tessa’s story and I just loved it. I’m finishing up the rest of the anthology tonight and I can’t wait to dive into Courtney’s story.
    Thanks for the great review!

    ReplyReply

Leave a Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

%d bloggers like this: