Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Sea of Tranquility by Katja Millay

Dear Katja Millay:

Sea of Tranquility is about a high school senior who moves in with her aunt about two hours from her hometown. Her transfer to a new high school is intentional. She wants to remove herself from everyone who knows her and everyone she knows. She doesn’t speak. Her parents agreed to this plan because the girl hasn’t spoken in nearly two years and they are desperate for her to be “better.”

She dresses up as goth girl barbie: tight fitting clothes and a ton of makeup. Her goal is to alienate everyone and be left alone. (I didn’t understand that if she wanted to be antisocial why she would choose to dress in stilettos and skirts that barely covered her ass. These were attention seeking outfits and even at the end when Nastya was being fully honest with herself, this wasn’t addressed).

At the age of 15, Nastya Kashnikov was nearly beaten to death by another boy when she was walking home from school.  The reason why she does not know. He’s never been caught.  Nastya believes that she died and now she is this other being; the one without a dream of Julliard.  Barely able to make it through the night without nightmares; barely able to walk through the day without terror, Nastya writes down her assault every night believing it keeps her sane.  Her intent was to be alone but at her new school she is inexorably drawn to Josh Bennett.

Josh is an emancipated 17 year old boy who is best friends with a popular jock but interacts with almost no one else.  Nastya is intrigued by his solitude during school, the respect the students seem to pay him, and his almost force field like ability to keep everyone at bay. One night she goes running and ends up at his house where she finds Josh woodworking during the midnight hours.  When he doesn’t make her leave, she keeps returning.  He doesn’t understand why she is there, but the mystery of her makes it impossible for him to turn her away. Josh is an incredibly lonely young man. In some ways he is more nihilistic than Nastya but in others far more optimistic and open.

Other students play fairly large roles in the story.  Drew, Josh’s best friend, is an unrepentant man whore but becomes close friends with Nastya.  Sarah, Drew’s sister, is one of the evolving mean girls at school.  Nastya reluctantly becomes the subject of a amateur student photographer. There is a sort of Breakfast Club feel to it.  No one is exactly who they appear on the outside.  Drew isn’t just the manwhore.  Sarah’s anger toward life stems from resentment toward Drew that is only acknowledged late in the book.

What I liked so much about this book was how it was brought home for me.  Nastya acknowledges that she had been wallowing in self pity for three years instead of healing.  Josh makes a tough decision regarding Nastya and his relationship, one that is very mature.  Drew and Sarah’s secrets are revealed and make them three dimensional. The characters, even the villain, were nuanced.

The biggest problem is in the pacing. It takes a while to lift off, but I felt like the characters were very genuine. They talked about tough issues such as the existence of God, forgiveness, healing. Even though I chafed at the pace, in retrospect I am not sure what to cut. I would have missed reading out on some scenes. I do recommend the book, but I recommend it with caveats that it is slow and takes some time to delve into the characters’ point of view.

While the characters are in their teens, this definitely had a New Adult feel to it, in part because there is almost no parental involvement. Josh, as I stated above, is emancipated and Nastya’s aunt works nights, leaving the two alone together for large swaths of time. It was an emotionally satisfying book in large part due to the ending. There is no cliffhanger here. B

Best regards,


AmazonBNSonyKoboAREBook Depository

Guest Reviewer


  1. Readsalot81
    Nov 16, 2012 @ 12:37:18

    I really enjoyed this one, although the first 1/3 of the book really kind of frustrated me. In retrospect, I can see why the author chose to frame it that way , but without dialog from the heroine, the first part of the book felt slow and uneven. I made myself push through because I really wanted to see where the story went and I’m glad I did, but it was a struggle.

  2. Jane
    Nov 16, 2012 @ 14:37:58

    @Readsalot81: Yes, while you are reading it, you are thinking COME ON NOW but at the end you are all “yeah, I got your point.”

    I couldn’t think of what I wanted excised only that it was sluggish in the beginning.

  3. Ruthie
    Nov 17, 2012 @ 03:19:31

    I loved this one. Didn’t mind the pacing at all, though I think the book improves as it goes, and I wondered later if it got revised much after being written. The hero’s first scene doesn’t make a lot of sense when you look at his later characterization.

  4. The Sea of Tranquility by Katja Millay Book Review | The Allure of Books
    Nov 28, 2012 @ 02:44:00

    […] Reviews: For What It’s Worth Dear Author Aesta’s Book Blog Glitter, Bliss & Perfect Chaos Tags: contemporary, review, […]

  5. Eleanor
    Nov 28, 2012 @ 11:00:59

    I’d just like to comment that I read this review after having read the book and I’m glad because this review is full of spoilers. As a reader, it’s distressing when reviewers give away so many details of the book that are meant to be revealed throughout the course of the story. I’m not trying to disrespect your review, however, here you have given away that the main character doesn’t talk, revealed what happened to her at 15 and what she is writing in her notebooks. This isn’t at all fair to readers who have not yet read the book.

  6. Fred LeBaron
    Nov 28, 2012 @ 13:28:22

    Pretty darn good point Eleanor raises about the spoilers, do you guys ever flag those for your readers? Cause this review, although thoughtful and well written, pretty much is a synopsis of the whole thing?

  7. Allison Mack
    Jan 12, 2013 @ 13:42:52

    I totally agree, Eleanor! I read the book prior to this review and would have been so disappointed because she does totally spoil the plot!! What some say was a slow start for me was just a reason to read faster! I couldn’t wait to find out more and more about each character! Bravo, Katja!

  8. Daily Deals: A contemporary three pack; a Japanese theif; a ruined pianist; and a gossip driven Regency
    May 20, 2013 @ 14:21:36

    […] really liked this book and gave it a B-. The minus is because the first third is a bit slow (and should have been cut down) but after the […]

  9. The Sea of Tranquility by Katja Millay | Katie's Book BlogKatie's Book Blog
    Mar 13, 2014 @ 09:43:22

    […] Dear Author’s review: “It was an emotionally satisfying book in large part due to the ending.” […]

%d bloggers like this: