Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Harlequin’s revamped manga line; A Prince Needs a Princess...


A Prince Needs a Princess. Story by Barbara McMahon, art by Reiko Kishida.Retail: $7.99.Rated T for Teen, 12 and up, sweet kisses only (I’d say a little younger would be OK too).I believe it’s based on McMahon’s Harlequin Romance The Tycoon Prince, from 2003, but has been reworked into a YA romance.B for young girls, C+ for older readers.

Dear Harlequin,

Harlequin Manga seems to be going through some permutations.That’s good.There was a lot of room for change.When I bought the very first manga that you published, I couldn’t get past two things: the fact that you were using romances from the early 80s to attract readers who hadn’t even been born then, and that awful purple and pink ink.

A Prince Needs a Princess by Barbara McMahon and Reiko KishidaIt seems like you eventually realized some of the same problems.That horrible ink is still there (Note: “Printed in Flirty Pink Ink!” is not a selling point for me), but at least the aged feeling is gone.The covers have an updated look, more modern.You’ve stopped selling the purple adult line, which I think is a good move because those titles would only attract grandmas, and I don’t know all that many grandmas who are interested in manga (though I know a couple!).

You’re also no longer available at the anime and manga stores online.Only at chain bookstores, and your own website.I think that says something about your purpose, that you don’t care about dedicated manga fans, you want to pull in young readers who go to regular bookstores to get them used to the name Harlequin.You’re trying to repackage yourself.Harlequin Pink is your Joe Camel, so to speak. And it might work.

I bought five of your new Pink titles so that I’d have a good idea of what you were aiming for.For the record, I don’t recommend the six manga from the first attempt you made, unless someone finds them at a garage sale for a steal (they aren’t horrible, they’re just rather like one’s Aunt Betty tarted up as someone half her age and dress size).But I’m curious to see what the new brand of Harlequin Pink stands for.

Here are my thoughts on the first, A Prince Needs a Princess:

I honestly opened this manga fully prepared to dislike it.To my surprise, I did not.Despite the fact that you still use pink ink *sigh* I enjoyed the book and read it through to the end.It has a few things going for it.First off is the art.I had to choose from a number of Harlequin Pinks to buy and review.The hottie on the cover caught my attention immediately.I figured if I had to suffer, I was going to suffer staring at a pretty man.

The artwork was nice.Not outstanding, but nice manga artwork reflecting recent shoujo styles.The characters are easy to tell apart, and all are modern in their demeanor, with the possible exception of the king who reminded me of some kind of cross between God and King Lear.What’s with the bathrobe and hermit look?But really, I was staring at the gorgeous hero too much to worry about the old man.There are also some nice background details to give the reader a feel for the settings, though of course plenty of the requisite flower and star type backgrounds to emphasize the romance.

But here’s what I liked most.Unlike the other manga titles you first released, this newer title is just that, newer.The characters all look, dress and speak like we do in the 21st century (excepting His Royal Grandpa).The heroine was dressing in things I could probably walk into a store today and buy.The hero had a normal modernCalifornia style.This story doesn’t contain the trappings of 80’s romances, because it was published in 2003.The covers reflect a more modern style that immediately caught my eye.I’d like seeing that cover on any romance.

The story is a cute one, akin to some of the teen romance flicks we’ve seen in the past few years.Clarissa is a young woman from the country of Marik, sent by the king to get his last remaining grandson and heir back.Jack, the grandson, is estranged from the man for good reason, and Clarissa finds him working as a construction worker in LA.He has no desire to be king.But after an argument he decides to go (remember this reads right to left, top to bottom):

Prince_sample

There are issues for the characters to deal with.Obviously Jack and his grandfather have things to work out.Clarissa was engaged to the former heir and is unsure about her changed feelings and how that would look.These are both worked out quite a bit more easily than one would expect.But considering the intended audience, the single volume length, and the style of the story, the ease of resolution is not out of place. It may disappoint older readers though.

But if readers here have a young girl (ages 10-14) in the house and want to buy her manga, they could make a much worse choice than A Prince Needs a Princess.And then when she was done they could pick it up the next time they needed a bathtub read. Because we’re never too old to look at pretty men. ;)

Just please, Harlequin, lose the pink.

Sincerely,

ジェーン
(Jān)

reads any genre as long as the books aren't depressing. Her preferred reads these days are in manga format and come from all manga genres, but she especially likes romance, doubly so when there are beautiful men involved. With each other. Her favorites among currently-running English-translated manga series include NANA, Ze, Ouran High School Host Club, Junjou Romantica, Blood Alone, Vampire Knight, Skip Beat, Silver Diamond and anything by the holy triumvirate of BL: Ayano Yamane, Kazuma Kodaka and Youka Nitta, including any scribbles they might do on the backs of napkins.

13 Comments

  1. Dionne Galace » Blog Archive » Why I Shouldn’t Have a Credit Card
    Mar 14, 2007 @ 10:12:03

    […] brooding, glowering tycoon or sheikh looking like Tuxedo Mask. That is hot. Inspired by Jan’s review of a Harlequin Ginger Blossom, I decided to hot-foot it to eharlequin.com and buy a few of my own. […]

  2. Keishon
    Mar 14, 2007 @ 11:54:36

    Are they serious with the pink? Ugh.

  3. Jan
    Mar 14, 2007 @ 12:10:35

    Yep. They must have done a study and ended up using some whacked out middle schoolers who wanted to trick them and said “Oh yeah pink ink is cool, especially *flirty pink ink*”.

    To be honest, the manga phonebook anthologies in Japan (called phone books because they’re about 600 pages of phonebook style paper) use colored ink for some of their stories. Most are printed in black, but then you come across stories in purple, blue, red, and green prints. They tend to be the lower quality stories in each edition. I don’t know if those pages are cheaper, or what drives that. I find it really annoying though because the print is usually not as sharp, and not as easy to read, so I’d rather not see the tradition continued here.

  4. Ann Wesley Hardin
    Mar 14, 2007 @ 12:53:07

    Oh hey, slightly OT but I went and bought Train Man on your rec. Absolutely loved it. Adorable! My kids love it too. Gonna get the rest in the series now. Thanks!

  5. Jan
    Mar 14, 2007 @ 13:32:05

    [quote comment="24604"]Oh hey, slightly OT but I went and bought Train Man on your rec. Absolutely loved it. Adorable! My kids love it too. Gonna get the rest in the series now. Thanks![/quote]

    ^__^ That’s so great to hear! One thing I love about manga is how it bridges the generation gap. You start reading it and suddenly you become “cool” with the kids in your family and new paths of communication open up. Hopefully you’ll find some other series to share too. Some of the ones I’ll be talking about here might be suitable (though some will not). All will be clearly identified for age groups though.

  6. Meril
    Mar 14, 2007 @ 22:39:06

    Yes, the pink was a definite turnoff in me buying anything out of this line. It bugs me enough in the Japanese magazines. At least when most of those manga are collected, they’re printed in normal black!

    I’ve seen Harlequin Pink manga for sale at Wal-mart. It’s with the rest of the YA stuff in the book section, not with the adult romance.

  7. Jan
    Mar 15, 2007 @ 08:00:24

    [quote comment="24626"]I’ve seen Harlequin Pink manga for sale at Wal-mart. It’s with the rest of the YA stuff in the book section, not with the adult romance.[/quote]

    That’s really interesting! I’ve not been in a real store and looked for them. I wonder if Harlequin has made deals with Walmart and others to stock them that way? Though I know that can simply be the judgment of the store employees. There are bookstores I’ve heard of that misguidedly shelve yaoi in gay/lesbian studies, and I know the publishers didn’t ask for that.

  8. Suzie
    Mar 15, 2008 @ 06:12:17

    They use coloured ink in Japanese manga magazines because they use second-hand paper, so they tint the pages to camouflage the fact they’re 2nd hand paper. Also since the color changes with every story, it makes it easy to remember up to where you read, you don’t need a bookmark =) (since the magazines are big 400 to 1000 pages, they can take a few days to read)

    Here is a link where they epxlain it in detail:

  9. Suzie
    Mar 15, 2008 @ 06:19:59

    Wait, I read it wrongly (sorry) :( Actually they do use 2nd hand paper but they don’t color it on purpose. The paper, which is made from scraps of paper like old newspapers, printing offsets etc is originally colored. :)

  10. After being ‘robbed more than a 7-Eleven,’ Strikeforce’s Masvidal ready to prove worth | mmanews99
    Oct 19, 2011 @ 10:10:01

    […] Josh Barnett  David Baron  Phil Baroni Don Barr Pat Barry  Vitor Belfort  Robert Berry David Bielkheden This entry was posted in Uncategorized by admin. Bookmark the permalink. Proudly […]

  11. Kimbo Slice wins 2nd pro boxing fight with another brutal KO | Ultimate Fighting
    Oct 19, 2011 @ 10:10:18

    […] Acacio Bernard Ackah  Terrance Aflague Yoshihiro Akiyama  Gilbert Aldana  José Aldo  John Alessio  This entry was posted in Uncategorized by admin. Bookmark the […]

  12. HDNet Announces New Television Deal With ProElite | angelas place
    Oct 19, 2011 @ 12:41:49

    […] Grant Campbell  Gesias JZ Calvancante  Luiz Cane  Dos Caras Jr   Phil Cardella Roan Jucao Carneiro This entry was posted in Uncategorized by admin. Bookmark the […]

  13. LRyneQey
    Feb 28, 2012 @ 16:24:58

    Good afternoon, I used to write a bit in the soap and entertainment blogs however havent been on here for ages now! So what are the most popular themes?

    treatment cancer

%d bloggers like this: