Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Something Different by S.A. Reid

Dear Ms. Reid (actually I’m just assuming your gender here — sorry if I got it wrong).

This is a self-pubbed book that you sent to Dear Author for possible review. I enjoyed the excerpt and it hit one of my buttons pretty hard (*love* stories about prostitutes or strippers — no idea why), so I figured I’d go for it. And I’m so glad I did. I loved this story. I never know why people choose to self-pub, but some aspects of the story might raise some eyebrows (they certainly raised mine), but overall, it was a fantastic story.

Something Different S.A. ReidMichael is 34, has been married for 15 years, and has two kids. He and his wife very rarely have sex:

Michael couldn’t remember the last time he’d had sex with Frannie, and there were so many rules he was no longer tempted to try. Weeknights were out, she was too tired from housework and spin class and book club and keeping up with her favorite programs on telly. Sundays were a no-go; she tended to go out with girlfriends after church and preferred a nice long evening with the telly when she returned. That left Saturday, and then Michael had to be freshly showered, the kids had to be either asleep or out of the house, and Frannie had to be in the mood. The likelihood of all these factors coming together was about as favorable as a total eclipse. Once Michael had thought that as he grew older he’d get “past it,” as men used to say, and find himself as disinterested as Frannie. But now he was thirty-four and more frustrated than ever.

A colleague goads Michael into the rebellion of going to the local park, looking for a female prostitute. There James finds him and, after a bit of conversation, Michael takes James to a hotel where James sucks him off and fucks him. Michael and James establish a regular routine until James is attacked by another client. At that point, Michael houses James and pays for his medical bills and rehabilitation, all while dealing with specters from his past and eventually being honest with his wife and starting amicable divorce proceedings.

Most but not all of the story is told from Michael’s perspective. Honestly, it reads almost like a fable. There’s some telling rather than showing, especially of the backstory for both men, but it works with your voice and just pulled me through the story (of course, looking for some to excerpt, I couldn’t find any, so maybe there’s less telling than I thought). Michael believes in truth:

“If it’s not about sex . . . what, then?”

Michael modulated his breathing. This would be taking a chance. But he could withstand the truth, he knew he could. He could ask James to be honest and not fear it would break him.

“It’s about friendship. I think of you as a friend. What we did before – I’d like to go back to it, whenever you’re ready. But until then, I want you to stay here, James. Get better. Spend time with me. Unless … unless it’s too much. Unless you don’t think of me the same way.”

“I thought of you as a client,” James said softly. “Till you rang me up. Till I said I was out of commission and you asked if we were finished. I felt – I don’t know. I thought maybe it would hurt you, wondering why I disappeared. So I met you in the restaurant. Not because I expected you to help me. I just didn’t want to leave you in pain.” James took a deep breath. “I don’t deserve you as a friend.”

“I don’t deserve you, either,” Michael said. It was the most he could manage. There was more inside him, he knew there was, but it was like staring at the white digital page when he tried to write a piece of fiction. A disconnect that made communication impossible.

So part of the “fable” feel of the story comes from Michael’s own disconnect from his emotions, but that’s very well explained by his back-story and he comes out of it now and then and increasingly toward the end of the story. The “fable” feel also comes from the ease with which Michael and James fall into their life together and with which Michael and his wife break up. But it all fits with their established characters, so again, I went with the flow of it. And Michael’s insistence on truth and honesty means that there’s never any recriminations about James’ former profession. Both of them just take it at face value, but that’s in-character for both of them, rather than forced.

From the self-publishing perspective, I saw 4 glaring typos and missing punctuation (on two complete read-throughs) which is not bad. The formatting for ePub was a little off because the WHOLE book was one chapter, so it took a while to load on Stanza (“a while” being around 10 seconds, rather than instantly). And the cover is boring. But altogether, at a $0.99 price point, it’s utterly and completely worth it.

From the self-pubbed perspective, you also deal with topics that are potentially triggering and/or might not be acceptable at mainstream e-publishers. Those topics are potential spoilers, so click to see them:
[spoiler]Both James and Michael are the victims of sexual assault: James when he was 12 by his uncle, lasting a few years and Michael when he was 14 by his step-mother, lasting three years.[/spoiler] Also, James has herpes and he and Michael have unprotected anal sex after they find this out. The unprotected sex made me REALLY uncomfortable, but I saw it as in-character for Michael at that stage in his personal development, so it sort of worked, even if it was a little strange to read. Once they have sex without both a condom AND lube, which just…no, thank you. I mean, I’m sure it’s *possible* but it’s gotta fucking HURT.

I don’t think I’m doing a good job of saying how much I liked this book. I really really did. It was both a romance and a coming-into-his-own for Michael and even a bit for James. And everyone gets their believable HEA at the end, so it left me with the warm fuzzies. You have a gift for characterization, the dialogue sparkled, I could see how Michael was changing and growing, and I was rooting for them both right from the start.

And a completely gratuitous excerpt because I just loved the description of Michael’s love for James:

“I love you, James,” Michael gasped, dealing a final battering thrust. James screamed, his cum hotter than piss against Michaels’s belly. Then it was Michael’s turn, pressing in deep as he could, pumping his cum into James. Time shifted, blurring things between them, putting Michael into another place where there was no need for ego, reassurance, or even reciprocity. He felt what he felt for James and took the deepest possible pleasure in it; the emotion was its own reward. Finally when he was completely soft, Michael withdrew, rolling onto his back beside James. He was almost surprised when the other man curled into his arms. But he let himself enjoy it, let himself go half-weak with pleasure. This was sublime, loving, truly loving, and expecting nothing but the freedom to express it.

Isn’t that an amazing way to think about love?

Grade: B+

Best regards,
-Sarah

Goodreads | Amazon | nook | Smashwords

Sarah F. is a literary critic, a college professor, and an avid reader of romance -- and is thrilled that these are no longer mutually exclusive. Her academic specialization is Romantic-era British women novelists, especially Jane Austen, but she is contributing to the exciting re-visioning of academic criticism of popular romance fiction. Sarah is a contributor to the academic blog about romance, Teach Me Tonight, the winner of the 2008-2009 RWA Academic Research Grant, and the founder and President of the International Association of the Study of Popular Romance (IASPR). Sarah mainly reviews BDSM romance and gay male romance and hopes to be able to beat her TBR pile into submission when she has time to think. Sarah teaches at Fayetteville State University, NC.

16 Comments

  1. What Sarah was Reading in September - Dear Author
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 11:01:30

    [...] I read S.A. Reid’s Something Different twice through, the second time right after the first time. It was a self-pubbed book sent to DA for review. I *loved* it. Review here. [...]

  2. kate r
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 14:07:51

    Bought it, read it, love it.

  3. Janine
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 14:27:50

    The excerpts are really good, and the price is right. I think I’ll get this one.

  4. annabeth albert
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 15:54:05

    Great review! I wish the author had this up on nook bc I would have bought it after reading this

  5. Estara
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 16:07:03

    According to the Smashwords Author page, I’d say she’s definitely female
    http://www.smashwords.com/profile/view/SAReid

  6. Estara
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 16:08:34

    @annabeth albert: You could buy it as an .epub at Smashwords and still read it on your Nook.

  7. Chelsea B.
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 16:17:46

    Wow, this sounds intense! Thanks for bringing this book to my attention!

  8. Kaetrin
    Oct 11, 2011 @ 20:23:33

    Sold! At least this one is easier on my purse! Thx for the review.

  9. annabeth albert
    Oct 12, 2011 @ 00:25:26

    @estara I vastly prefer one click buying versus wrestling USB cord and/or digging for CC. Note to indie authors it is worth whatever hassle to getvyour book in the nook store too!

  10. Alex
    Oct 12, 2011 @ 03:25:36

    I bought this and read it last night. I really enjoyed it but something was just a little off for me. Some of the language felt as if it was an American author writing about English characters and striving for local colour but not always getting it quite right.

    For the most part it worked well but I don’t have a high tolerance factor for supposedly English characters saying things like “I took my National Health card and went to Emergency” or going to get a suit made in Marks & Spenser (it’s Spencer, plus they don’t have a tailoring service! Lots and lots of off-the-peg suits but no handmade ones)

    Maybe an English beta reader would have ironed out some of these little niggles? I know I sound fussy – I did enjoy it, honestly I did, but things like that just jar with me even though they probably don’t bother the majority of readers.

  11. Storm
    Oct 12, 2011 @ 09:15:17

    I like this review. I am going to have to find a way to get this book. Your review made me definitely want to read it and I am sure I can pass this desire on to a couple of my friends.

  12. Sunita
    Oct 12, 2011 @ 14:13:51

    @Alex: I’m only partway through this book, but I had the same problem with the Americanisms. Since the author also used a number of British words and phrases to emphasize the context, it was jarring when the American-influenced stuff popped up, and it jerked me out of the story.

  13. Smexy’s Top Ten–October 14th | Smexy Books
    Oct 14, 2011 @ 12:31:44

    [...] Different by S.A. Reid – m/m romance, $.99 Kindle, Nook. This was reviewed at Dear Author earlier this week very [...]

  14. willaful
    Oct 23, 2011 @ 13:32:12

    It’s now available for Nook, though I myself prefer to go through Smashwords — for me, a few more minutes of effort on this end is worth the ease of organizing my book on Calibre and knowing I’ll be able to use it on any ereader I might switch to in the future.

  15. Sirius
    Oct 23, 2011 @ 14:05:58

    VERY TINY SPOILER IN MY COMMENT, WHICH I DO NOT THINK REALLY COUNTS AS SUCH, BUT FEEL FREE TO DELETE IF YOU THINK OTHERWISE.

    I finished it couple days ago, I thought love story between two main characters was fine, but I could not get past the fact that *every* and when I say every, I mean every female character was in my opinion portrayed as having some sort of either villanous or idiotic traits. Michael’ wife, Michael’ stepmother (listing my beef with those two will be a big spoiler, so I wont), Michael’s daughter for crying out loud will require years of psychotherapy because she learns that her dad is gay, but his son is perfectly fine with it. (I do not believe it is a big spoiler if any, since review lists that Michael and his wife split up) Um, okay, of course generalizations are never true and any or both kids can be upset with such revelation, however if I were to put my money on it, I can see a girl having much more tolerance towards her father being gay. That is of course is an unproven theory of mine, and only one of my unhappiness with how female characters are portrayed in this book. When I read stories like this, I usually feel even more understanding towards those mm readers who prefer not to have any female characters in their stories. I do not feel like this at all, I think it will be wierd and artificial world, where characters live in the vacuum and do not interact with women. BUT when I stumble upon stories like this I completely understand readers who feel that way. I would have enjoyed this book much more if author would have decided not to have female’s characters in there. That is of course just my opinion.

  16. emmytie
    Dec 14, 2011 @ 10:06:18

    I never would have bought this one if you hadn’t reviewed it. I almost didn’t even after the review because the voice in the excerpts seemed …off or something. But it all works very very well in context. Thanks so much for this one.

%d bloggers like this: