Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Private Arrangements by Sherry Thomas

Dear Mrs. Thomas,

By now I’m sure you’ve heard the accolades from other review sites of how this title might herald The Return to Great Historicals of yesteryear. How it takes a Victorian setting plus two well thought out lead characters and mixes them to yield a scrumptious book for those of us tired of yet one more Regency set historical much less those who’ve given up on historicals at all. True, it’s flush with Dukes or near Dukes but I’ll forgive you those since you don’t inflict a nobleman spy on me. I’ll allow much authors who resist that worn out and threadbare plot.

Private Arrangements by Sherry ThomasGigi and Camden are not perfect people. Far from them. Gigi is almost breathtaking in her pursuit of a man she, in her budding youth, feels is the perfect man for her. One Duke has slipped through her fingers at the last minute by slipping off a four story building after a night of drinking. She’s not about to let his cousin do the same. Much less when he’s so wonderful a man. His long-standing bespoken arrangement with a spineless young European aristocrat is too tepid to be allowed and an obstacle she quickly removes.

Camden is sucked into the intense allure of a woman not thought to be beautiful yet breathtaking to him anyway. Her concentration on him, her delighted responses to his courtship started once he recovers from the brief shock of learning his betrothed has married another, her obviously barely banked sensuous nature are heady nectar to him. Which makes the revelation of her scheming plan all the more cutting to him. Rage crystallizes into a cold hearted revenge taken the day after their wedding night.

After ten years of separation and several affairs on both sides, they’ve settled into a two continent marriage that suits them both. White hot anger has banked into cool disdain as each proceeds to get on with life. That is until Gigi decides to petition for divorce and Camden arrives back in England to make life hell for her with a private arrangement before he’ll agree to her request.

I don’t do cartwheels of rapture over prose but must agree with Janine that the descriptions, word choice and writing style of “Private Arrangements” are among the best I’ve seen in quite a while. Even tone deaf readers will probably enjoy reading this book. Historical fans will like the use of anything-other-than-a-Regency setting. It seems that Victorian set books are tentatively on their way to becoming the new venue of choice. I hope they don’t overwhelm the market place and become blase. I did think that while the setting is well done, there were few elements that really nailed the book down to any certain year. Perhaps that’s just because the last quarter of the 19th century seems fairly generic with the exception of the new divorce laws and automobiles.

I mentioned that Gigi and Camden are flawed but don’t get me wrong, I liked that. It allows them to grow and mature into people who can finally appreciate the other for everything and all that they are. It’s something that they couldn’t have done when they married and doubtfully done at points throughout their separation. Camden had to finally admit that Gigi was right about the fact that he and his betrothed weren’t suited and she had to understand on a visceral level that what she did was wrong.

So, why the B+ grade after paragraphs of praise? The final separation between Gigi and Camden along with the reasons Gigi gives that set it in motion seemed ‘off’ to me. Here are two people who finally seem to be communicating honestly with each other, to have worked out their differences, to be headed towards that final blissful clinch and she brings out what I can only think of as a tepid, lukewarm barrier that doesn’t match her take-no-prisoners approach to life. It comes off as a contrived plot device and is jarring when placed against the rest of the story.

I didn’t let this one disappointment ruin my overall feelings for the book. There is so much to enjoy about the whole that I look back on my reading experience with a great deal of pleasure and am anticipating what you’ll offer us next. B+


Goodreads | Amazon | BN | nook | Sony | Kobo

Another long time reader who read romance novels in her teens, then took a long break before started back again about 15 years ago. She enjoys historical romance/fiction best, likes contemporaries, action- adventure and mysteries, will read suspense if there's no TSTL characters and is currently reading very few paranormals.


  1. Janine
    Mar 27, 2008 @ 16:23:11

    Very nice review, Jayne. LOL re. doing cartwheels over prose — yes, I have been known do that sometime and I really adored the writing in this book.

    As I am just discussing with Robin/Janet, I didn’t feel that the separation at the end was extended in a contrived way. It worked for me, and I explain why over on the comment thread for Robin’s review.

  2. Bonnie Dee
    Mar 27, 2008 @ 18:19:52

    I’ve read enough reviews of this book now that I’m convinced. It sounds like a thoughtful, intelligent read and I’m buying a copy.

  3. carolyn Jean
    Mar 27, 2008 @ 19:36:56

    I can see what you mean about the false barrier. It didn’t seem to come from the emotional core of the story like other elements did.

  4. EC Sheedy
    Mar 27, 2008 @ 19:53:15

    I’ve already praised this book on Sybil’s blog, but I’m happy to chime in again. I finished this book last night. It was a non-stop read for me, and I loved every page of it. I agree, Jayne, the language is beautiful.

    I’ll definitely be watching for Sherry Thomas’s next book!

  5. Jennie F.
    Mar 28, 2008 @ 00:09:58

    I didn’t have a problem with the separation at the end, because I thought the reasons behind it were proof that the heroine really had grown up and repented her previous actions. I think perhaps she was afraid to be “selfish” because of the disastrous consequences she’d suffered the first time around with Camden.

  6. Jackie L.
    Mar 28, 2008 @ 20:16:08

    What I loved about the book was the way the problems I have with historical novels in general were solved. Most of the heroes seem too American for an Englishman to me. In this novel, the problem was solved by having a hero who lived in America for 10 years.

    And the deft way the big misunderstanding was handled was fabulous. By the time I figured out the big mis, I was already involved in the novel and sympathetic to the characters. The gradual way it was revealed was like peeling back layers so the big mis seemed so much more believable than many I have read.

    It certainly doesn’t read like a debut novel to me.

  7. Jayne
    Mar 29, 2008 @ 05:04:29

    It never read that way to me either Jackie. It has such polish and assurity (is that a word?).

  8. Kathleen MacIver
    Mar 29, 2008 @ 09:05:41

    I liked it and didn’t like it. The full reasons, (if you’re interested and don’t mind spoilers) are posted in the last review thread.

    Would anyone here like me to pass on my copy to you? It’s in pristine shape. I’ll drop it in the mail media rate if someone wants to give me your address. (Use the contact form on my website, please.)

%d bloggers like this: