Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Dark Soul: Volumes 3, 4, and 5 by Aleksandr...

Dear Mr. Voinov,

Your Dark Soul series has been a roller-coaster ride for me. It is not a genre romance, even though it has some very romantic moments. It features themes I rarely seek out, including menage, BDSM, and protagonists in organized crime. Purchasing all five volumes is not inexpensive. It is quite brutal in places. And while I enjoy serialized fiction, this one is more like a set of linked short stories in parts than a serialized novel.

Dark SoulAnd yet. And yet. I read each installment with apprehension but also eagerness, and they have rewarded me handsomely. I put off reading Volumes 4 and 5 for weeks, in part because I wanted to give them the attention they deserved. I’ve already talked about Volumes 1 and 2 here and here, so this review will cover the last three installments. I’ll do my best to avoid spoilers, because part of the pleasure and impact of the story comes from the way you’ve put it together. For readers who find my plot summary inadequate, there are reviews at Goodreads and a number of blogs that provide more answers.

The overall storyline is relatively compact: Stefano Marino, a avowedly heterosexual mob boss with a beautiful wife whom he loves, falls hard for Silvio Spadaro, an assassin who is the lover and heir of another boss. That boss sends Silvio to Stefano to assist him in a battle with the Russian mob. Volume 3 begins with the Russians’ attack on Stefano and Silvio’s retaliation against them, two acts that bring them together physically and emotionally, and it introduces a character from Silvio’s past who becomes part of the campaign against the Russians. This installment reveals more about Silvio, from his ruthlessness as an assassin and a person, to his sexual needs, to his vulnerability when he was a child. Stefano finally starts to come to terms with his attraction to Silvio and realizes it is not something he can wish or repress away.

In Volume 4, Silvio and Franco’s onslaught on the Russia mob continues and the relationship between Silvio and Stefano deepens, and both developments have their inevitable consequences. The mob war escalates beyond something that can be dealt with by merely buying off local law enforcement, and Donata is no fool. Stefano’s personal and professional existences are both up for grabs by the end, and it’s not at all clear which way the resolutions lie. Stefano is deeply conflicted because he is growing more emotionally committed to Silvio, but he also loves Donata, and he wants to keep everything the way it is and somehow add Silvio into the mix. Plus, he is trying to maintain his mob supremacy in the face of increasing threats.

Volume 5 has to wrap all of these loose ends together. And it does, with style and assurance, all the while introducing another major character. Savvy readers should deduce the backstory of the new character fairly quickly. Since I was slow on the uptake, I was kind of annoyed at first that this character became so important, although I understood why he had to for storyline reasons; then I finally got it and everything made sense.

In this final episode, the Russians are basically out of the picture but Stefano and Silvio have to deal with the increased law enforcement attention that accompanies their demise. Stefano tries to find a way to salvage his marriage while still hanging on to Silvio and fighting off challenges from within his organization. We also find out more about Silvio, which I found extremely helpful. By the beginning of Volume 4 I was starting to wonder if he was a sociopath. The ultimate explanation for some of his personality made sense to me, although I’m still ambivalent about how trustworthy he is and how fully he can commit to other human beings. But I could definitely see why Stefano didn’t want to have to choose:

He stood and slipped out of bed and closed the door behind him on the way, smiling to himself. Compared to Donata, Silvio was the polar opposite. Not a graceful or early riser. And that would be less funny if Silvio weren’t a sicario. If he killed a stranger for absolutely no personal reason, how would he respond if unduly irritated?

But of course, all that was idle bullshit, especially considering that the big issue in the back of Stefano’s mind was his wife. He kept checking his phone in the hope of a text from her. He sometimes touched her profile on his phone, especially when Silvio was asleep or occupied with something else. He’d snapped a photo of her on one of the date nights, dressed in a gorgeous red dress, her hair tumbling down. It showed up every time she called him, and sat as a tiny thumbnail right next to her name. Donata Marino.

And he was hiding away from her in this hotel, fucking Silvio, finally sating that hunger and that deeper need, the terrible affection for another man. But, truth was, he was hiding, still avoiding her.

I needed time to work this out for myself. I needed to know if it was real. And God help me, but it is.

I thought that the way you resolved these threads was ingenious from a storytelling point of view, but I wasn’t completely convinced in terms of the characters.  What I mean by this is that everything worked in terms of the characters as they appear in the book, but I wondered if real people would work things out the same way (and it’s definitely a testament to the quality of the characterizations that I came to think of them as real people).

First, I  thought Stefano needed to experience the consequences of his various decisions a bit more than he did. I didn’t want him to grovel more or be punished, exactly, but resolutions seemed to come a little too quickly (this may have been a consequence of page length). Second, I wasn’t fully satisfied by way Stefano made the decisions about his future and the ramifications of those decisions for both him and Donata. Stefano made them unilaterally even though they affected both of them, and I had trouble believing that it was as easy for the two of them to live with the decision as it seemed in the end. Even when you hate something, it’s hard to shift the patterns and habits of decades. And while I was pleased that there was an HEA in the end, I had trouble believing the characters were as free of their pasts as they seemed to be. So, in some ways, Volume 5 was the least satisfying for me.

Overall, though, the way the characters and the plot unfolded over the installments was really well done. Stefano goes from being confused and not very self-aware to decisive and much more in control, as well as more honest with himself and those he loves. Donata, when she finally appears on the page, is worth the wait. She’s a little too understanding in the last installment, but she’s a strong woman who seems to be making thoughtful and considered choices. And Silvio becomes less of an enigma and more of a human being. He’s still the same Silvio we met at the beginning of the first volume to a great extent, but we see him less as a gorgeous assassin and more as the complex young man that he is.

The quality of the writing sustains a high level of quality throughout the five installments; it is taut, focused, and perfect for the subject matter. The sex scenes are explicit, hot, and critical to the development of the plot and characters. There is an m/m/f scene which is extremely well done. If readers aren’t fanning themselves throughout, I’ll be surprised.

I am so glad I stretched outside my comfort zone and picked up this series. I want to reiterate, this is not a genre romance. It’s not easily classified, either as conventional m/m or menage. There are some extremely violent scenes, and the characters do some pretty unlikeable things. They are ultimately sympathetic, but it takes some of them quite a while to get there, and all readers may not make the journey with them. But for those who do, this is an incredibly rewarding read. It’s not perfect, but it’s very hard to forget.

Grade for series: A-/B+


Sunita has been reading romances almost as long as she has been reading. Her favorite genres these days are contemporary, category, and novels with romantic elements. She also reads SFF, mysteries, historical fiction, literary fiction, and the backs of cereal boxes. As of January 2015, all the books she reviews at Dear Author are from: (1) her massive TBR, (2) borrowed from the library, (3) received as gifts from friends/family, or (4) purchased with her own funds.


  1. Isobel Carr
    May 25, 2012 @ 15:17:08

    What the heck is going on with shift from third to first in the excerpt?

  2. Sunita
    May 25, 2012 @ 15:28:12

    @Isobel Carr: Sorry that’s my fault. The last paragraph is in italics in the text but when I formatted in WordPress the whole excerpt was italicized so it got lost. I’ll bold it when I’m back at the computer.

  3. Jenny Lyn
    May 25, 2012 @ 15:42:18

    Great review, Sunita! I was wondering when you would get around to the rest of the series. Unlike you, I glommed onto them all at once. As soon as I finished one I’d jump right into the next.

    Your thoughts on this series mirrored mine almost exactly. I loved them all, but Vol. 5 was probably my least favorite. I was appreciative of the way Donata was always treated with respect on the page, even when her husband is lusting after a man. She’s never painted in a bad light throughout the entire series. Stefano was perfectly flawed and I found myself wanting more scenes from his viewpoint.

    Silvio made me uncomfortable in parts (specifically with his brother and the Russians), and I wasn’t completely convinced that he’s not a sociopath. He certainly has no boundaries, sexually or otherwise. But by the end I started to see him as more human too.

    I love Aleksandr’s voice and his characterization. He can write gut-wrenching violence in one paragraph and tender the next.

  4. Isobel Carr
    May 25, 2012 @ 16:13:30

    @Sunita: Oh, good! I just kept reading it and getting more and more puzzled, LOL!

  5. Merrian
    May 25, 2012 @ 19:38:27

    I loved this series of linked short stories. I think the structure sets us up because we are only seeing the characters at certain points of their journey, not with them every step of the way which is how a series unfolds. This means as readers, we are expected to take somethings as given. I wonder if this works to make us more at ease with Silvio’s character with his sociopathic tendencies because we have to take him as he is? I thought the people and their relationships were all true to their own understanding of their worlds and their own internal logics and that this consistency carried them through the story arc and is a wonderful strength in the writing. It is often something that other authors fail at.

    You have put your finger on my one discomfort – Stefano’s unilateral decision-making which has implications for the ending of the story – you can’t take the Boss out of the Boss?

    I loved these stories and my own rating matches yours Sunita.

  6. Sunita
    May 25, 2012 @ 21:20:35

    @Jenny Lyn: @Merrian: It’s interesting how Silvio is the more immediately compelling character, but Stefano is the one who really grows and changes over the course of the five volumes.

    I thought about Volume 5 a lot, and it’s difficult to see how it could have been done differently without substantially changing the structure of the installment and/or adding another volume. Maybe it’s just that I wanted the denouement and conclusion to be longer and more drawn out. I think the storyline is really clever, I just had to suspend more disbelief. Which sounds silly when you think about the OTT aspects of some of the parts that came before!

    It says something about how compelling the whole series is that it’s only at the end that I start to complain about realism.

  7. Susan
    May 25, 2012 @ 22:33:56

    Thanks for the series wrap-up. I have vol I in my queue–looks as if I’ll need to move it up. (I read AV’s Country Mouse just last night.)

  8. REVIEW: Never A Hero by Marie Sexton
    Jun 08, 2013 @ 11:02:05

    […] seemed like a great way to reacquaint myself with the Riptide list. I’d really enjoyed the Dark Soul series, and while the Tucker Springs books are very different, they are squarely within my preferred m/m […]

%d bloggers like this: