Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

GUEST REVIEW: Ten Ruby Trick by Julia Knight

A while ago I mentioned some troubles with a DRMed book I got at Diesel Books in one of Dear Author’s open threads for readers. I tried everything in my power to open it but failed, the nice people at Diesel Customer Service weren’t able to help me, so I just gave up on it. A little later I got contacted both by Julia Knight and Carina Press, offering me a working copy of Ten Ruby Trick, to compensate for the one I couldn’t open.

Since I think this speaks well for Carina Press’ customer service, but mostly because I liked the book so much, I asked Jane if I could do a guest review, to make the circle round. And here we are!

Dear Mrs. Knight,

Ten Ruby Trick Julia KnightAfter the trouble with opening your book, I gave up. You were a new author to me, and I didn’t feel motivated anymore to pursue it. I was pleasantly surprised when you contacted me, but also a little worried I wouldn’t like the book after all these troubles. Lucky, the opposite was true. I loved it.

Ten Ruby Trick is a wonderful mix of fantasy, swashbuckling adventure and romance. I think it’s more a fantasy with strong romantic elements than a true fantasy romance, mostly because the romance doesn’t follow standard romance tropes at all. We meet Van Gast and Josie in the middle of their relationship, and we know that Van loves her from the first chapter on. The love he feels for her (and his insecurity about her feelings) is definitely one of the moving forces in the story, but it isn’t the plot. Likewise, while there’s a Happy Ending, it has to do with the main plotline (which I don’t want to spoil here, because discovering what it’s all about is one of the appealing things about this book), and the romantic conflict is solved fairly quickly.

It was very refreshing to read a novel from the hero’s POV, and a hero who admits his feelings to himself at that. Van Gast is a racketeer famous for his way with the ladies, his success at pirating, and his little-magicks that warn him of trouble. He was a delightful hero thanks to his view on life, his devotion to his love for Josie, and his joy in being a racketeer. The sections where he had to run, best an adversary or fight where amongst the most enjoyable parts of the book.

If there was a choice between the sensible-but-dull thing and the stupid-but-exciting thing, Van Gast would say “fuck it” and do the stupid thing every time. Life was too short for dull and sensible when exciting was so much more fun.

He’s also known for his hatred of Josie, and their fights are famous amongst all racketeers. Only that hatred is a scam invented by the both of them, which results Van being unable to confess his feelings to anyone. It doesn’t help that Josie is a very elusive woman, always slipping away, and very guarded with her emotions.

 She grinned her lopsided grin at him, the one that always made his stomach flip. The one that meant she was going to kill you, rob you or take you to bed. He was never sure, from one moment to the next, which it would be.

Josie was the stupid-but-exciting thing, the never-quite-in-his-grasp thing that always kept him coming back for more, kept him from taking the tumbles of others, even though freely offered, even though it was expected of him, of any racketeer.

Josie is strong willed, courageous and brave, a little scarred by her past, but very, very loyal. You can’t help but feel anything but admiration for her during her struggles. Even though I loved reading from Van’s POV, I wouldn’t have minded to see more of her POV at all.

When Josie goes missing there’s no one Van Gast can turn to, since he’s supposed to rejoice about it, and it makes for a very interesting conflict.

The blurb doesn’t do this book justice at all. Everything that’s in it is true, but it fails to point out the book’s strong points, like how awesome and strong Josie is. But worst of all, it barely mentions the original (and OH SO CREEPY) magic system, which is responsible for one of the meatier antagonists I’ve read in a while. In fact, he’s more of a anti-hero than a true villain, and I think it’s strange Holden isn’t mentioned in the blurb.

From the opening scene on, his situation turns your stomach, and you can’t help but root for his freedom and the destruction of the mage-bound that binds him to do as told. Even when that freedom comes at the cost of Van Gast and Josie’s life. It’s been a while since I’ve been as torn up as a reader who to root for, and just like the characters, I didn’t see a way out where everyone would be alive and free. I think that takes great skill as a storyteller, and I’m in awe of what you did here.

Holden’s storyline is responsible for the more emotional part of the book. Sympathy, pity, despair, betrayal, and a whole lot of anger; Holden caused quite the roller-coaster of emotions, and at one point I really felt suckerpunched.

The side characters were well established as well. The Master, the true villain of the book, was incredibly creepy and despicable, covered in shiny crystals he might be. Skrymir was a great sidekick, and I wouldn’t mind reading more about the Gan, who seemed like a cross between Vikings and George Martins’ Dothraki. Likewise, a story about Quint, the information gathering pimp woman would definitely interest me as well. I just haven’t had enough of this world.

There are a couple of things that kept this from an A rating. I wouldn’t have minded an epilogue – the resolution of the romantic conflict, while fitting to the characters, wasn’t entirely satisfying, it was a little too quick for that. The editing wasn’t as tight as it could have been at some places, there were a couple of sentences here and there that felt strange to me. I smelled one particular plotline from miles away, so that twist wasn’t a surprise for me as much as it was for Van Gast. And I can’t help but prefer love stories with a little more steam.

(Did love the strong language and blood-spilling though, you didn’t hold back on those points at all, and it fitted the story and characters perfectly)

Ten Ruby Trick might seem a typical swashbuckling romance at first, but it’s so much more. It’s a story about first love, old lovers and new lovers. It’s as much a story about freedom and what you would do for it as a story about what you would do for love. It’s a story about free choice and the dangers of Utopian societies. About trust and betrayal and a tiny bit of revenge.

There’s typhoons, bar fights, explosions, cannonfights, a whole lot of bloodloss – on the side of the good guys, bad guys and innocent bystanders. There’s whores, magicians, ambitious crew members with a personal agenda and a whole bunch of slaves who are forced to do what they don’t want to do. It’s wonderful, thrilling and exciting, and yet touched on some more serious themes between all the adventure.

I’m very grateful you contacted me and made me read it after all, because I loved it, and really want to read more books set in this marvelous world.

So thanks Julie Knight and Carina Press!


~Jan Oda

Book Link | Kindle | nook
| Sony| KoboBooks | All Romance eBooks | Carina Press

Guest Reviewer


  1. Jan
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 13:26:20

    Hey Jane, thanks for having me!
    If anyone has questions, I’m more than available :p

    One tiny thing, I think the second quote tag was closed too soon, it should end after the next paragraph (that ends in racketeer).

    It’s possible I noted it down wrong though :)

    Also, I wouldn’t tag it under futuristic, since it’s fantasy all the way.

    Thanks again!

  2. Moriah Jovan
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 14:10:58

    Question so not related to the review:

    Carina’s offerings are non-DRMd. Why does a Diesel copy have DRM applied?

  3. Jane
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 14:13:29

    @Moriah Jovan oh oh, I might have the answer to that. I was meaning to post this at some point. Someone emailed me a while back:

    The process embeds fonts, though, and if they’re commercial fonts, InDesign automatically encrypts the resulting EPUB file — i.e., it puts DRM on it. The first time I did it and tried to open the file in Calibre, it came up, and it was a complete surprise to me. The DRM lock on it was unintentional on my part. I had to tweak the EPUB file to remove the encryption, or use open-source fonts. Had to do a lot of Googling to learn how to do either of these.

    In other words, a lot of the DRM books out there are probably unintentional on the part of the publishers. If they’re using fonts that require a license, and if they’re using InDesign for both their print and ebook editions (very, very likely on both counts given that InDesign is the industry standard), then it’s possible their EPUB files are just getting automatically encrypted.


    I should add, though, that there’s an option in InDesign NOT to embed the fonts, which easily eliminates the possibility of the DRM being applied (and results in smaller file sizes, too). I think it might embed them by default, though (I’m not sure), and if the designer creating the EPUB file isn’t aware of it, voila — unintentionally DRMed books. I’ve read that some e-readers don’t even support embedded fonts (like Stanza), so in many cases it’s kind of pointless to include them anyway — best to turn off the option to embed fonts. But other e-readers do support them (I’ve read that the Sony Reader does), and book designers do like having control over their typography, so I imagine that a lot of EPUBs have embedded fonts in them.

    I think it’s Adobe’s way of protecting the licensing of commercial fonts, because when fonts are embedded, the font files are actually included in the EPUB package; the export works fine without encryption, even with the embedded fonts option turned on, if only open source fonts — like LinuxLibertine, Bitstream Vera, DejaVu, etc. — are used. There’s a way to keep the commercial fonts embedded and the EPUB file DRM-free by tweaking the EPUB file afterward, but it requires “unzipping” the EPUB, getting into the code, and removing a specific file from the package.

    Sometimes a retailer takes an epub and reprocesses it. Kobo does this to avoid using Adobe Digital Editions encryption. These new packages can add DRM.

  4. Moriah Jovan
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 14:37:31

    Thanks, Jane. I didn’t know that.

    I wish publishers would quit hard-coding stuff readers and their devices can’t read and don’t want anyway.

    Stop embedding fonts altogether.

    Stop specifying a background color.

    Stop hard-coding font size.

    Keep it simple so the device can be set to the reader’s preferences. It’s about the customer. Make it easy for the customer. PLEASE.

  5. Julia Knight
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 15:04:04

    Hi Jan

    So glad you liked it after all the hassle! If you liked the Gan, check my website for other books about them. And I’m almost done with a sequel for Van Gast and Josie :D

    Thanks again!

  6. Moss
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 15:06:46

    Terrific review Jan! I haven’t seen this book around, but it sounds like a must-buy. Bit sad that it isn’t steamy, I do like my swashbucklers to come with as much bodice ripping as possible, but will try and get over that one little glitch. Congrats!

  7. Estara
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 15:30:20

    Okay, this sounds a) cool as a crossover and I read fantasy a lot
    and b) like the bits I liked most about The Death of the Necromancer by Martha Wells – the interaction between Madeline and Nicholas as a team working to solve the big issues threatening them and the country (though since Necromancer is surely longer than a Carina Press release, we also get other great side characters there).

    To say it differently this goes on my TBB.

  8. sarah mayberry
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 17:50:44

    Adding to TBR pile right now…

  9. Angela
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 18:27:10

    Going to check this out. Thanks for the review!

  10. Tina
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 19:33:57

    Ooh, this sounds interesting. I like a good, complex antagonist as much as I do a good hero/ine.

  11. Jan
    Jul 05, 2011 @ 20:35:28

    @Moriah Jovan: While what Jane said might be possible, I also believe Diesel adds DRM to all the books they sell, regardless if the publisher wants DRM or not.
    Normally I try to avoid DRM as much as possible, but Diesel had some deals back then I couldn’t resist temptation for, and well, I regretted it afterwards. They did try to help with all my problems, and were very cordially, but nothing worked, and it turned me off DRMed books for good I think.

    @Julia Knight: I didn’t know you had other books planned/written for the Gan, I’ll be sure to check them out!

    @Moss: It’s very much swashbuckling without the bodice ripping. It’s not like there isn’t any steam, it’s just isn’t taking the center stage, since the heroine went missing for a big part of the book. And even if it were steamier, the relationship between Josie and Van is so equal, I don’t think bodices would be ripped without pants being torn.

    @Estara: While Josie and Van are a team (but in secret shhhh…), the issue they are dealing with here they are dealing with it separately, since they are forced apart on it. I have no idea how long Necromancer was in comparison with this, but with over 100.000 words it’s longer than the average Carina Press book.

    I think I addressed everything :)
    I’m really glad so many people seem enthusiastic about it, because for me it very much felt like one of those unexpected hidden gems.

  12. Christine Bell
    Jul 07, 2011 @ 09:41:46

    This is one of my top ten favorite books of all time. I want to say up front that I’m a Carina Press author. That said, I’m posting strictly as a reader and booklover here. I was positively enthralled while reading this tale, and ended up taking a vacation hour from work to get to the end. I’d never read Julia’s work before, but am now a huge fan. Can’t wait for the sequel!

  13. Annie
    Nov 29, 2012 @ 23:50:22

    Can i get some spoilers on the revenge plot? Is it between the loverrs? And some spoilers on the betreyal as well. Thanks.

%d bloggers like this: