Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Through the Evil Days by Julia Spencer-Fleming

Trigger warnings: [spoiler]Implied sexual abuse of children, rape threats, attempted rape, murder.[/spoiler]

If the book interests you, you may want to try out the audio version.


evilDear Ms. Spencer-Fleming:

It’s eight books into this mystery series, and the achingly forbidden love between Reverend Clare Fergusson and police chief Russ van Alstyne is finally legally and morally sanctioned. How do you continue to keep the romantic tension going?

By throwing everything but the kitchen sink at them, apparently. On what should be a peaceful honeymoon in a remote cabin, Russ and Clare have to deal with threats to both of their jobs, Clare’s unplanned — and to Russ’s mind, much unwanted — pregnancy, various murderers/kidnappers/meth dealers, a missing child who will die shortly if not found and given medical treatment, and a destructive ice storm that makes the already complicated situation mindbogglingly difficult.

The story follows several threads — primarily what’s going on for Clare and Russ, and what’s happening with police officers Hadley Knox and Kevin Flynn, who are partners and erstwhile lovers. In each thread, the characters are investigating the missing child case while also dealing with some serious personal angst. There isn’t a lot of belaboring of the past, but we’re given enough background info to follow everything; a reader could probably even enter the series here without much trouble, though would get so much more out of it by reading the previous books first.

This entry leaned more towards romantic suspense/police procedural than mystery, and I was mostly happy with the romantic and personal elements. It would have been good to see Clare process around her pregnancy a little more: not only did neither of them want children — both have life-sucking careers, Russ is in his early fifties — but she’s suffering from PTSD and newly sober. Moreover she was unwittingly drinking and using drugs while pregnant, and their child is considered likely to have some special needs. I suppose it fits Clare’s protective and impulsive personality that she leaps to a decision to continue the pregnancy, but some acknowledgement of the serious impact this will have on their lives would have made me respect her more as a character. The lack of it certainly infuriates Russ.

More time is spent on Russ’s journey through anger and resentment, as life seems to roll over him, “one chaotic accident after another.” (He has no idea how very much more chaotic it’s shortly going to get.) When his suppressed feelings inevitably burst out, it’s an exquisitely painful moment for them both.

As a suspense story, this initially felt perfect: tense, not too gory, complex without being too complicated. I compared it favorably to recent Karen Rose books in which not only are the body counts unbearably high, but the threads of all the continuing characters tie themselves into unravelable knots. But then at some point, someone mentioned once again the need to find the missing girl in time, and suddenly I was in an action movie and there was a little clock ticking in the corner of the screen, and I was only surprised it wasn’t one week until Russ’s retirement.  The view of the man behind the curtain continued to dog me for the rest of the story: although the writing is always excellent, the suspense plot began to feel very pat and by the numbers.  The scenes from the missing girl’s point of view are written in a cliched style, more childish than childlike, that didn’t fit the description of her as very bright. Violence against women is also used in a way that felt manipulative. [spoiler]A chilling rape threat against Clare just fizzles out when it’s not longer a useful way to torture Russ. Not that I wanted her to be raped! But the convenience of the plot device really stuck out. [/spoiler]


Countering that complaint, it was powerful to see Clare — who steadfastly refuses to carry a gun because she insists would never use it — putting up a tough fight when she’s in a bad situation. She’s a priest, but she’s also been to war, and learned a lot about survival. Hadley is also very tough in her police work, though she gradually unbends to lean on the emotionally balanced and dependable Kevin when her personal life gets out of control. And since the incredibly rigid conventions surrounding pregnancy and abortion in romance are one of my biggest pet peeves, I’m glad to see a sympathetic and popular character showing realistic emotions around the issues.

As in many of the previous books, the story ends on a bit of a cliffhanger — which did not help my overall feeling of being manipulated — though not the really intense kind that leaves you tearing your hair out in frustration.

I keep going back and forth on a grade, because before I hiccuped on the genre conventions, I thought the book was very good. But in the end, I had to give it a “really liked — with reservations” grade. B-



AmazonBNSonyKoboAREBook DepositoryGoogle


Willaful fell in love with romance novels at an early age, but ruthlessly suppressed the passion for years, while grabbing onto any crumbs of romance to be found in other genres. She finally gave in and started reading romance again in 2006, and has been trying to catch up with the entire genre ever since. Look for her on twitter or at her blog at

One Comment

  1. Emily A.
    Nov 12, 2013 @ 12:47:17

    I haven’t read this latest in stallment of the series. I guess that puts me at a deficit for this review on Dear Author. I want to say that so often reviews at Dear Author feel more they’re for people who’ve read the books than people who are considering reading the books.

    That being said I’ve read the rest of the series and I can’t imagine a worse mother than Clare Fergusson. She is constantly putting herself in danger for reasons I often think are stupid. I think she is impulsive to the point where putting the child in danger will be inevitable. I think she is often not very kind or tactful and she is busy not only with her job, but in doing Russ’s job as well. I find Clare unlikable in general. I have been disappointed by some turns in the series already.
    As for Russ, I adore Russ, but I wish was stronger and tougher particularly with Clare. His age is also a consideration. He has demanding job, but being a father of infant is also demanding, especially in his mid-50s. I think men are often given more room to complain about inconvient babies, (contrast for those who know Ross’s and Rachel’s reaction to their unplanned pregnancy.) Of course like Russ, Ross had more life experience. It would have been bolder in my mind to have a woman pregnant and uncertain, especially under the circumstances.

    As for her writing of children, yes absolutely. I felt in book 6 I Shall Not Want that Hadley Knox’s children came off much younger than alleged ages. They were supposed to be 6 and 9, and they came off as 3 or 4 and about 5 or 6. I felt the children were not well written and while I adore Hadley and Flynn, that was a weak book for me in the series.
    I just finished book 7 and need time to recover before book 8. Given this review, I may need more time away from the series than I planned.

%d bloggers like this: