Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: The Lady’s Secret by Joanna Chambers

Dear Ms. Chambers:

It’s always exciting to read a debut book by a fellow blogger, although it can be a bit daunting, too. What if I don’t like it? Will that affect the way I read your blog? Fortunately, I enjoyed The Lady’s Secret, a book that mixes old and new genre conventions in interesting ways. In one sense it reads like a love letter to many older trad Regencies, but with a progressive streak that updates and adds new dimension to vintage tropes like the cross-dressing heroine and her brother who is trying to prove his legitimate claim to an earldom.

The Lady's Secret Joanna ChambersWhile her brother Harry travels the English countryside, looking for written evidence of their parents’ marriage, Georgiana Knight works at the Camelot Theatre in London, where she makes sets and costumes, her promising acting career cut short by crippling stage fright. Georgy and Harry inherited their actress mother’s share in the theatre, but Georgy still works hard, in part because Harry is using a good portion of their savings trying to confirm their parents’ marriage and, ultimately, his claim as the legitimate Earl of Dunsmore. Their parents married in secret after their father was told he’d be disinherited if he married an actress. After his death, their mother was paid off to keep quiet about the marriage, and her suspicious death has left Harry and Georgy financially stable but technically illegitimate. And while Harry is optimistic that he can find evidence of the marriage, Georgy has another plan: get into the current (i.e. illegitimate) Earl of Dunsmore’s house and search for evidence there.

Finding a way inside one of Dunsmore’s homes is easier said than done. However, a position becomes available in the Earl of Harland’s household, which would give Georgy the opportunity to visit Dunsmore’s house with Harland’s other servants for Dunsmore’s holiday house party. The problem is that it’s a position as valet to the earl himself, which would require Georgy to function in a state of daily intimacy with the man she is trying to fool into believing she is both a male and an experienced valet. Still, the temptation of being able to search Dunsmore’s house for evidence is immensely appealing.

It is a foregone conclusion that George Fellowes will get the job; the real challenge is in putting her considerable acting skills and somewhat androgynous appearance to use in close quarters with other servants and a “beautiful” man who makes her “ache.” Where Georgy is slight and almost boyish in appearance, Nathan has “lushly, extravagantly lashed” eyes and a mouth that “might have been thought almost feminine in its beauty, were it not for the firm, purely masculine line of the jaw beneath.” Where Georgy is spare in speech and manners, Nathan is elaborate and highly decorated, and elegant dandy who nonetheless thrives under Georgy’s unassuming but highly attentive maintenance.

For me, the first half of the book is the most interesting, because there seems to be no rush to reveal Georgy’s secret and let the sexxoring begin. Instead, Georgy spends the first part of the book watching and learning about Nathan and his household – how he prefers to be shaved and dressed; how his cravat should be tied, how his body looks and moved as he casually displays himself in Georgy’s presence. She is attracted and intrigued, but not tempted to reveal herself. And Nathan suspects nothing amiss, even after a facial massage Georgy gives him to relieve a headache physically arouses him:

 

Bloody hell. He had been aroused by Fellowes! No, he amended the thought quickly. He had not been aroused by Fellowes. Just by Fellowes’ hands on him. An anonymous pair of hands had brought him pleasure—that was all. Any pair of hands would have done the same.

 

These rationalisations did nothing to relieve his horror though. He felt embarrassed and awkward. And exploitative. Especially when he remembered what had brought Fellowes to his door—a master who had tried to take advantage of Fellowes’ youth and inexperience.

But still there is no unveiling, or even suspicion on Nathan’s part, that George is other than he seems. I appreciated this, because as difficult as it often is for me to suspend my disbelief that these young women make convincing young men, it is particularly frustrating to me when the cross-dressing device is used primarily as foreplay. In The Lady’s Secret, however, Nathan and Georgy move on from the massage incident, and it is not until some time later that Georgy’s secret is revealed. And even then the relationship between them does not change. I won’t spoil the secret of how Nathan finds out, because it’s quite a delicious scene, but I will say that his discovery is probably my favorite part of the book, because instead of calling Georgy out, he decides instead to observe her:

 

She was like that secret drawer in Lady Dunsmore’s tea chest. Now that he knew the secret, he wanted to know how it worked too. He wanted to see her with other people and watch how she did it.

 

Nathan, who has a scientific bent of mind, studies her like she initially studied him, although for different purposes. And what is wonderful about this part of the book is the way their relationship beyond master and servant, but not yet friends or lovers, begins to develop, with Nathan testing and teasing Georgy, trying to understand what she’s about and enjoying his secret knowledge of her:

 

He levered himself off the bed and stretched his long body with languid grace while Georgy, who was trying not to look, brought a straight backed chair forward for him to sit on while she shaved him. As soon as he sat down she began to dab lather over his face, noticing that his eyes were on her own face as she did so. It was disconcerting. Usually he was inattentive, his gaze elsewhere, but today he followed all her movements, and when she finally leaned over him, brandishing a razor, he tilted his chin to stare up at her. The silence between them seemed to take on weight and charge—it became a physical thing with uncomfortable edges.

 

It’s not just a sexual thing, although mutual attraction is part of it. There is a real intimacy in the relationship between a man and his valet, and the way Chambers plays with the budding sexual attraction in the context of this other intimacy is very well-done – you feel the tightness of desire between the two, the uncertainty, the slipping of the masks and yet at the same time the remoteness between two individuals of such apparently different social status. The writing throughout is also quite nice, not florid but not completely spare, either.  There is some over-description and explanation of things I wish had been trimmed a bit, but overall there is a real deftness to the construction of this part of the book.

Where things break down for me is when Georgy discovers that Nathan knows her secret, and the two begin what feels like a much more conventional relationship. The snapping tension loosens and for some reason the growing emotional intimacy did not feel as powerfully wrought. Georgy’s agenda – which she does not immediately share with Nathan – keeps some distance and tension in the relationship (can she trust him?; can he trust her?), as does the social inequity between the two and Georgy’s own resistance to leading the conventional life of an earl’s mistress. That Georgy does not give up on her quest to find evidence of her parents’ marriage at Dunsmore’s home adds a good deal of plot suspense, as well, and much of the second part of the novel is taken up with the complications that arise from Georgy’s determination and Nathan’s curiosity about what she is up to. In fact, I really love a curious and scientifically minded hero, although I even felt that part of Nathan’s character weakened over the course of the book, giving way to the equally clichéd and definitely not my favorite insensitively boorish aristocrat type.

There is also a secondary relationship between two male aristocrats that intersects in interesting ways with Georgy and Nathan’s relationship. I liked that the relationship was not included for titillation or novelty; Chambers constructs several clever scenes that make a substantial contribution to the central plot and romantic relationship, and for the most part she handles the relationship with a cognizance of its necessary secrecy. However, there is a point later on in the novel where a very unlikely (and dangerous) public scene seems to contravene the previous discretion shown (and while homosexual feelings themselves were not a capital offense, in 1810, arrest for sodomy was still very much a frightening possibility). This shift wasn’t a deal breaker for me, but it did seem a bit inconsistent, given the previous handling of this relationship.  I also think it is a difficulty inherent in wanting to give two men a happy romantic outcome during a period in history when their relationship was a crime.

Ultimately, it was the gradual slipping of Nathan and Georgy’s relationship into the conventional romantic mode, combined with the rather dramatic and somewhat clichéd resolution to the unfairly-denied noble inheritance subplot, that kept The Lady’s Secret from being a perfect read for me. Not that I did not enjoy the book as a whole – and I especially appreciated its generous length – but the promise of the first half or so was just so high, I wanted that wonderful engagement I had with the characters to last longer. Still, I would recommend The Lady’s Secret as a book that makes nice use of many genre conventions, making it both a familiar and a novel read and a substantially promising debut. B-

~Janet

Goodreads | Amazon | BN | nook | Sony | Kobo

isn't sure if she's an average Romance reader, or even an average reader, but a reader she is, enjoying everything from literary fiction to philosophy to history to poetry. Historical Romance was her first love within the genre, but she's fickle and easily seduced by the promise of a good read. She approaches every book with the same hope: that she will be filled from the inside out with something awesome that she didnʼt know, didnʼt think about, or didnʼt feel until that moment. And she's always looking for the next mind-blowing read, so feel free to share any suggestions!

16 Comments

  1. Janine
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 11:54:57

    I’ve been curious about this book, so it is great to read such a thorough review of it. I’m glad to hear that Georgy isn’t unmasked too quickly, as that was one of the problems I had with Pam Rosenthal’s Almost a Gentleman.

  2. KB/KT Grant
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 12:01:54

    I really enjoyed the secondary story with Osborne and Dunsmore. Would love for the to have their own book,

  3. Liz Mc2
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 13:31:56

    I think I’d rate this more like a B+, but I enjoyed your thoughtful review and agree with a lot of your points. The leisurely first half, with its reflections on clothing, disguise, and the intimate relationship between master and servant was my favorite part of the book, really fresh and with some wonderful writing.

    The second half was more familiar-feeling, but one thing I really liked about it (without being too spoilery) was the way that the “black moment” in the relationship turned on the class difference between the lovers, something which so many books treat as inconsequential. I thought a lot was resolved too quickly/neatly at the end, including that issue, but this is definitely one of the books I enjoyed most this year.

  4. Karenmc
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 13:50:35

    I enjoyed this book quite a bit. Everything in the first half of the book is allowed to unfold without any rushing, and Nathan surprised me when he didn’t immediately have an “Aha!” confrontation with Georgy when he discovered her secret.

    I look forward to reading more from Ms. Chambers.

  5. Jennie
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 14:12:10

    I may check this out – it sounds intriguing, though I am not usually fond of cross-dressing heroines. Thanks for the review.

  6. Estara
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 16:26:47

    I already bought this on the strength of the too short excerpt at Carina Press, so I’m glad to see it holds up so well. I have to move it up my TBR ^^

  7. eggs
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 18:17:11

    I have a sad confession to make: I bought this book but couldn’t get past the first few pages for the stupidest reason ever. The heroine’s name. If it had been spelled “Georgie” I would have been good to go, but with the “Georgy”, all I could see was “Gee!Orgy!”. I’ve tried about half a dozen times and can’t get past it.

    I’ve heard others say they can’t get into a book because of the hero or heroine’s name, but this is the first time it’s happened to me. I feel guilty about it, too! Like I’m punishing the book for something that’s not it’s fault. Sorry, book! It’s not you, it’s me …

  8. Robin/Janet
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 22:40:59

    @Janine: I almost mentioned the Rosenthal book in my review, but when I think about how Phoebe’s reveal is handled and how it belittled the incredibly powerful reasons for her alternate persona I get pissy, so I thought it best not to. But I think I can say that book made me even more sensitive to use of the device. ;D

    @Liz Mc2: I suspect that if I felt the first half weaker than the second, my grade might be a bit higher. But not everyone reads that way, so I totally get why you’d grade the book higher.

    @Karenmc: Although this book is set in 1810, I consider it a Regency Era Romance, and the combination of its luxurious length and homage to trads makes me want to recommend it as a Harlequin SuperRegency.

    @eggs: Maybe you could think about Georgy Girl instead? This is where it would be most convenient if you could read it in digital and swap the name out, lol.

  9. Janine
    Dec 07, 2011 @ 23:39:34

    @Robin/Janet: Agree on the Rosenthal; her later books are much superior. My favorite (sort of) cross-dressing book in the genre is Kinsale’s The Dream Hunter. I love the tension that comes from the hero’s unacknowledged attraction to the heroine, whom he mistakes for a boy, and the way he later struggles to find that boy in her and has difficulty relating to her as a woman.

  10. Maili
    Dec 08, 2011 @ 01:40:33

    @Robin/Janet:

    This is where it would be most convenient if you could read it in digital and swap the name out, lol.

    How do you do that?

    There are some books I want to read, but I couldn’t get past their names, e.g. one English heroine’s named Aubrey (usually a masculine name in Britain). Pathetic, I know!

  11. Moriah Jovan
    Dec 08, 2011 @ 11:12:30

    @Maili: You’d crack the book open down to the HTML and do a find/replace, then put it back together again.

    Which, as an author, I find the suggestion entirely horrifying.

    That said, I can think of about six ways to make the ability to change the characters’ names into an ebook enhancement.

    Despite my love of the forced-seduction trope, I simply can’t bring myself to read Gaffney’s To Have and to Hold because the hero’s name is Sebastian. One of my characters’ names is Sebastian, and he is the least likely of any of mine to behave the way Gaffney’s does. But I wouldn’t change the man’s name so I COULD read it.

  12. Janine
    Dec 08, 2011 @ 12:52:29

    @Moriah Jovan: It’s hard not to encourage you because I want everyone to at least try to read that book.

  13. Moriah Jovan
    Dec 08, 2011 @ 12:54:31

    @Janine: Trust me, if the hero’s name were ANYTHING but Sebastian, I’d read it because that book sounds right up my alley.

  14. Janine
    Dec 08, 2011 @ 13:02:46

    I understand. The hero of my WIP is named Jasper and I remember when I read Pam Rosenthal’s The Edge of Impropriety, it was at first an adjustment for me to get used to a Jasper whose physical appearance and personality were different from my Jasper’s.

    Also, after reading THATH, I don’t think I could ever name a character Sebastian. Gaffney’s “hero” (well, half-villain, half-hero) is just that much larger than life.

  15. Estara
    Dec 08, 2011 @ 14:02:18

    @eggs: If you open the .epub – with Sigil or another .epub editor (from what I remember Carina Press is DRM-free) you could do a search and replace with Georgie for Georgy ^^ – then you could see if it really was just the name problem or the book itself.

  16. Walking a Mile In His Trousers: Inspired By Joanna Chambers’ The Lady’s Secret « Sonomalass's Blog
    Jan 30, 2012 @ 20:22:39

    [...] I was really looking forward to The Lady’s Secret, and I’m pleased to say it did not disappoint. Joanna Chambers mentioned in a discussion elsewhere that some thoughts I shared about the device of cross-dressing (in an old post on the defunct blog) were relevant to her use of it in this book. For which, yay! Because the device is used well here — and by “well,” I totally mean “the way I like it.” (Note: this is much more a consideration of the use of the cross-gender disguise that a comprehensive review of the book; as such, it contains some spoilers. For a review that covers other aspects of the book, I recommend Janet/Robin’s review at Dear Author. [...]

%d bloggers like this: