Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Unbound by Cara McKenna

Dear Ms. McKenna:

Lately, a number of erotic romance authors (Charlotte Stein and Abigail Barnette, for example) have been writing books that deliberately use the basic trappings of Fifty Shades of Grey to subvert its themes and reclaim the genre. I don’t know if it was intentional, but this novel struck me as accomplishing a very similar goal by going in a completely opposite direction. It’s a dark, intense, very surprising and unexpectedly brilliant story.

Unbound by Cara McKennaNote: I knew very little about the male protagonist of this story going in, and even if you read the blurb, it’s deliberately vague. Therefore I got to experience learning about Rob’s inner life from intriguing hints, always just one step ahead of Merry, and frankly, that was awesome. I would hate to ruin that experience for anyone, but I don’t see how I can discuss the book in any meaningful way without revealing Rob’s secrets. So I’m going to have a large spoiler section and leave it up to readers how they want to proceed. I’ll have a spoiler-free wrap up at the end; read the comments at your own risk.

Unbound is what I classify as a “cabin-fever” romance: there are really only two characters (I don’t think any secondary characters even get spoken dialogue except in memory) and almost everything that happens is about their interactions in one particular space. It’s far from a claustrophobic-feeling read though — both characters are very physically active throughout the story, and it’s set in beautiful, demanding wilderness.

Merry sets off on a three-week hiking trip in the Highlands, partially as an homage to her dead mother, partially to process the significant changes that have been happening in her life. She’s lost 100 pounds, a really crappy lover, and quite possibly her best friend, and gained a new perspective on herself. Now she’s trying to figure out where to go from here, while loving how it feels to get away from the obsessiveness of dealing with her weight:

Out here, her body wasn’t a collection of desirable parts and shameful ones, a thing to be tricked and punished and outsmarted, outwilled. It was merely a vessel for food and water and sunshine, a structure of muscle and bone, a capable and ready thing.

When her hike is interrupted by a debilitating attack of gastritis, she just manages to make it to a lonely cabin she’d spotted. There she is somewhat reluctantly aided by Rob, an Englishman who’s lived as far from humanity as possible for two years, relying on his routines, hard work, and solitude to control his raging alcoholism. He can’t turn her away, but having company makes him uneasy, especially since he feels incapable of socializing without the lubricant of alcohol.

Merry, intrigued by Rob’s shyness, “manly” lifestyle, and understated good looks, gently and carefully seduces him. But then their encounter goes in an unexpected direction.

[spoiler]

“You feel so…” Rob couldn’t seem to find an adequate word, and abandoned the search. “Tell me what you like.” He swallowed again, eyes glassy and drunk. “Tell me what to do.”

There was something more to that final request. She could taste it on her tongue, simply watching his lips form those words. Tell me.

Hints about Rob have been unfolding in thrilling bits and pieces and now we’ve almost reached one part of the puzzle: he’s sexually submissive. But there’s so much more going on in what he calls his “neurological rat’s nest”:

“Are you into that? Bondage and that kind of thing?”
He shut his eyes tightly, but he couldn’t hide from the question. “I suppose.”
“That doesn’t bother me.”
When he opened his eyes, he found her smiling down at him, the gesture seeming to brighten the space between them, though he couldn’t feel its warm. Not yet.
“That nearly comes standard, these days,” she offered lightly.
“It’s not that I’m into it. It’s not that I just like it. It’s…”
She lay down and wrapped her arm around his middle, taking his hand and holding it at his heart. He didn’t think he’d ever felt so perfectly suspended between comforted and disturbed.
She squeezed his fingers. “It’s what?”
“It’s the only thing I like, nearly.” The admission tumbled out like a rock, juddering up through his throat and lodging itself between them. But once it cleared, he found the depths of his lungs, the relief of a full breath, the ability to swallow.
“How interesting.”
He laughed sadly. “No, it’s really not.”

Rob has fetishes, and his kinks are mostly not cute, mainstream or glamorous — not just bondage, but ropes, pain, humiliation and cock worship. And like his alcoholism, there are no halfways about it — he can’t get off without somehow involving his kinks or retreating into his own head, which of course has been very emotionally draining on his previous lovers. But Merry is in exactly the right head space to take a dominant role, and she discovers how exciting it is to be able to totally blow Rob’s mind. And Rob discovers for the first time that he can harness his compulsions in order to be truly present with Merry, and give her what she desires as well.

I’ve never encountered such a raw, visceral, genuine portrayal of fetishism in erotica. For much of the sex scenes we’re inside Rob’s head, and the intensity of his feelings as he finally gets what he most needs is overwhelming. The complicated balance between two partners when they’re wired so differently is also captured here, and the story honestly shows Rob’s deeply internalized shame without shaming him.

Merry is less obviously intriguing, but I was impressed with her character as well. The experience of having lost a lot of weight hit the mark with me: the physical hangovers like sagging breasts, the tedious obsessiveness with calories, exercise — “fucking numbers” — the happiness at having changed coupled with resentment at not having been good enough before, and the lasting insecurity that comes from feeling unseen and unappreciated as you were.

I also thought Merry embodied a desire that may be at the heart of romance for many readers, the desire to be fiercely wanted:

He lowered to his forearms, nose brushing hers. “What do you want to feel? The way I always want to feel degraded — what do you want to feel with this man? With me?”
“Desired. Like, cherished.” She mumbled the final word, looking sheepish. “Just like the way guys look at girls in stupid romantic movies.”
A deep sadness rose in Rob, to imagine her fantasies were made of such stuff. Did this mean she felt denied those simple things in her waking life? This kind, affectionate, beautiful woman?
You’re the last man on earth who should think he can fulfill those needs, said a hateful voice.
But perhaps the only man who’s yet bothered to offer. That alone made him feel worthy of the task.

Many people theorize that this longing to be desired is what’s behind the love of dominating, obsessive romance heroes. I don’t know if there’s truth in it or not — I myself enjoy almost all kinds of heroes — but I loved seeing the dynamic playing out with a man who’s pretty much literally as far from the alpha stereotype as you can get, and for whom this has previously been an area of utter failure.

[/spoiler]

The relationship that ensues is confined not only by space but by time; Merry has to return to California for her father’s wedding. (An event especially hard to miss since he’s finally legally able to marry his boyfriend.) As the inevitable parting approaches, the suspense about what will happen between them builds — particularly as Rob has yet to tell Merry about his alcoholism, and how impossible he feels it is for him to return to regular society. Waiting for that axe to fall was brutal – the longer it took, the worse I knew it was going to be.

I really hope this book will find its audience.  It’ll inevitably make its way onto lists of favorite bad sex scenes in romance, and the relationship conflict, arising out of Rob’s shame and fear, is very affecting, but readers who heavily favor traditional romance conventions probably won’t go for it. And it’s certainly not perfect. Rob’s self-loathing gets wearying (though for a dry drunk, I don’t think it’s at all exaggerated) and as in a previous McKenna book, the characters smirk so often, I wanted to reach into my ereader and force a different expression onto their faces. I’m a little iffy on the ending as well, which is kind of an uneasy mix between realism and fantasy, with quite a lot happening offstage.

None of those quibbles was significant enough to outweigh how beautifully written and brilliant the book is in general.  It won’t be for everyone,  but if you’re looking for nuanced portrayals of complicated characters I can’t recommend it enough. A

Sincerely,

Willaful

AmazonBNSonyKoboAREBook DepositoryGoogle

Willaful

Willaful fell in love with romance novels at an early age, but ruthlessly suppressed the passion for years, while grabbing onto any crumbs of romance to be found in other genres. About seven years ago she finally gave in and started reading romance again, and has been trying to catch up with the entire genre ever since. She loves exquisitely written historical romance, intense m/m, and crazy, over the top categories about equally, and hopes to be buried with her e-readers. Look for her on twitter or at her blog at www.willaful.wordpress.com

24 Comments

  1. Kati
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 08:08:41

    I loved this book ridiculously. The writing is fantastic, the sex scenes were…unexpected and really transformative for the characters, and it’s chock full of angst, which is a total win in my book.

    I’m so glad you reviewed this one, Willaful. It’s one of my favorite reads of the year, for sure! Extraordinary writing and a truly lovely romance.

    ReplyReply

  2. BJW
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 08:12:02

    Cara McKenna writes the most beautiful love scenes. I loved her “Curio” series and I’ve read all of her novels. “After Hours” is another of her wonderful novels.

    ReplyReply

  3. Isobel Carr
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 12:53:48

    SOLD!

    ReplyReply

  4. KZoeT
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 13:01:26

    Cara McKenna writes smartly dialogued, realistically working-class, and deliciously-flawed characters so she’s an auto-buy for me. I wasn’t aware Unbound was out … and there it goes straight on to my e-reader.

    ReplyReply

  5. NH
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 13:11:51

    Great review. This was a wonderful book. I don’t read much m/f romance anymore (m/m is more my thing), but Cara McKenna is an auto buy. Her male characters are incredibly interesting and nuanced, and her female characters don’t make me want to throw things.

    ReplyReply

  6. BethP
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 13:29:50

    What struck me, after reading the book, is how sympathetic Cara was towards Rob. He was self-admittedly “fucked-up” with his alcoholism recovery, his fetish and his guilt and self-loathing. But – he was also, ultimately, a good guy that I was rooting for in the end because of how she wrote his character.

    And while Cara doesn’t write that love will redeem him and make him all better, she writes a sympathetic character who was capable of receiving and reciprocating that love.

    I too felt that too much of the ending happened off-stage (more alluded to as potential to happen), but I was willing to believe in it ultimately occurring, just to make myself happy.

    An amazingly well-crafted book of characters that were much more complex, and ultimately more interesting, than the norm.

    ReplyReply

  7. Christine Rimmer
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 13:38:28

    Strangely, I’ve been hesitating over buying this because I adored After Hours so very much, I’ve been afraid this one won’t measure up, somehow–even though every book I’ve read by McKenna/Maguire has been simply excellent. But this does it, Willaful. I’m clicking through right now to buy. :D

    ReplyReply

  8. Willaful
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 13:46:15

    @Christine Rimmer: I haven’t read After Hours, so I can’t make a comparison, but I hope you’ll enjoy this one as much.

    ReplyReply

  9. Willaful
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 13:48:31

    @BethP: Yes — it’s really important to write a character who’s very ashamed without making that shame part of the authorial voice, and I was so happy with the way McKenna did that.

    ReplyReply

  10. Andrea
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 13:54:48

    Great review. I loved this book as well, and am anxious to read more McKenna!

    ReplyReply

  11. JacquiC
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 14:10:22

    I also loved this book. I think the author did a great job of portraying Rob as a lovable person, despite the fact that he was, as he says himself, totally fucked up. Yet somehow she managed to make it believable that Merry would fall for him. Yes, a lot of the end of the book seemed to happen off stage, but also I loved that the book didn’t rush to magically work out all the issues between the characters, including the simpler geographic ones.

    ReplyReply

  12. Christine Rimmer
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 15:16:49

    @Willaful: Get After Hours. Get it now. :)

    ReplyReply

  13. Willaful
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 15:17:37

    @Christine Rimmer: Yes MA’AM!

    ReplyReply

  14. Mandy
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 15:26:07

    After ‘After Hours’ anything this author writes is interesting for me. Great review. I clicked on the buy link straight away!

    ReplyReply

  15. Maya Banks
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 16:49:47

    I too adored this book but then I’ve enjoyed a LOT of her backlist. Not ALL of her books work for me but the ones that do REALLY work and I LOVE them. What I loved so much about this story is that the author didn’t pull any punches and she made a theme I wouldn’t normally read or enjoy a kickass read for me. I love ANY author who can take something that doesn’t normally appeal to my reader buttons and make me love it despite those hang ups or quirks. This got a solid, unreserved recommendation from me

    ReplyReply

  16. Ducky
    Oct 18, 2013 @ 18:09:20

    Rubs hands – I just started this. Makes me glad to see it get a great review.

    Cara McKenna is such a refreshing voice in erotic romance. I discovered her because of a review of “Willing Victim” here a couple of years ago which I ended up loving. Recently I also loved her “After Hours”.

    ReplyReply

  17. LeeF
    Oct 19, 2013 @ 11:23:31

    Oh, jeepers- you make me want to read her whole backlist. I can see me getting hooked on another author.

    ReplyReply

  18. Ann F.
    Oct 19, 2013 @ 20:03:40

    I bought this book yesterday based on your review and read the entire thing last night. What a great read! Thanks for the recommendation.

    ReplyReply

  19. Willaful
    Oct 19, 2013 @ 20:29:33

    @Ann F.: *beam*

    ReplyReply

  20. KZoeT
    Oct 20, 2013 @ 11:00:42

    Willaful, you’re so right about this being a genuine portrayal of fetishism. Where most romances treat fetishes as happyfunplaytime! (and fetish play certainly can be), it was refreshing to read about Rob’s crippling relationship with his fetish and the powerful role shame had in his life.

    I found it interesting that Rob’s fetish that was revealed first and that his alcoholism was The Deep, Dark Secret he kept from Merry.

    Though I loved the book, I feel this was more Rob’s journey than a shared one with Merry. Where I see big, transformative moments for Rob through his interactions with Merry, I’m still not quite sure what Merry got out of the short time they had together.

    Still, Unbound is a great book and one of my top reads for this year.

    ReplyReply

  21. Willaful
    Oct 20, 2013 @ 12:36:05

    @KZoeT: It is an interesting reversal. I think it’s part of Rob’s having his life so carefully set up so he can *avoid* the fact that he’s an alcoholic, instead of actually dealing with it. But once you’re having sex, your true sexual nature is hard to hide.

    And I agree, there could/should have been more about what Merry gets from the relationship.

    ReplyReply

  22. Dabney Grinnan
    Oct 21, 2013 @ 19:20:28

    Nice review, Willaful. I am one who liked this book less than After Hours. To me, Rob is so defined by his kinks and his alcoholism that I struggled to find who he was–maybe if he was–someone outside of those traits. I realize this is a romance and as such focuses on the romantic/sexual relationship between Merry and Rob but I wanted a fuller picture of him. I also wondered why Merry’s friends had to be so nasty now that she’s thin. She was set up to be looking for affirmation in a way I found depressing.

    I remain a fan of Ms. McKenna. This is a strong work. It just didn’t hit the high notes for me that After Hours did.

    ReplyReply

  23. Dabney Grinnan
    Oct 21, 2013 @ 19:21:58

    Nice review, Willaful.

    I am one who liked this book less than After Hours. To me, Rob is so defined by his kinks and his alcoholism that I struggled to find who he was–maybe if he was–someone outside of those traits. I realize this is a romance and as such focuses on the romantic/sexual relationship between Merry and Rob but I wanted a fuller picture of him. I also wondered why Merry’s friends had to be so nasty now that she’s thin. She was set up to be looking for affirmation in a way I found depressing.

    I remain a fan of Ms. McKenna. This is a strong work. It just didn’t hit the high notes for me that After Hours did.

    ReplyReply

  24. Willaful’s Best of 2013
    Dec 24, 2013 @ 08:02:09

    […] 2) Unbound by Cara McKenna. My review. […]

Leave a Reply


7 + = 15

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

%d bloggers like this: