Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Geek with the Cat Tattoo by Theresa Weir


Shy music geek Emerson Foshay breaks into a cold sweat and is rendered speechless whenever Lola Brown, the girl of his dreams, steps into his guitar shop, but once a stray cat named Sam follows him home everything changes and Emerson becomes the coolest guy in town.

Setting: Minneapolis, Minnesota

Cast of main characters: Emerson Foshay, shy music geek

Lola Brown, Melody’s (Girl With the Cat Tattoo) sister

Sam the cat, Max’s (Girl With the Cat Tattoo) brother

Dear Ms. Weir,

Ever since Sunita – and a lot of other people – and I fell in love with Max the Cat, we’ve been waiting for the follow stories of his lost brother and sister. During Max’s run through the DABWAHA competition, I silently cheered the novella on and sighed about the fact that we probably wouldn’t get the next one until 2014. Then! imagine my happy face when a friend emailed me that “Geek with the Cat Tattoo” was coming out sooner, now in fact. My whoop made my own kitties give me the side-eyed, “back away from mom slowly because she’s obviously off her rocker” look. Yes, I talk to my cats and firmly believe they understand every word. I must ask, though, why Sam isn’t on this cover?

Geek with the cat tattooPoor Sam hasn’t had an easy time of it. On his third owner as the story opens, Sam knows the gig is up and that he’s about to be homeless again. But better tossed out the front door then driven out to the country and dumped with a bunch of feral, wild cats. Things look up – just slightly – when he comes across a drunken young man. It’s then that Sam decides that instead of letting a new owner claim him, he’s going to claim a new owner. Sam might deny his nurturing ways but something in the man brings them out and a tentative meow along with a gentle nudge causes the man to pick up Sam and take him home.

In a romance novel this would be considered the cute meet. I know all about romance novels thanks to Second Owner, who was addicted to them and read more than one a day. I learned a lot about romance from her. I miss Second Owner.

“Hello,” my new friend says, with wonder and surprise in his voice. He reeks of beer. I mean reeks like it’s coming out of his skin. But I can feel the kindness emanating from him too. This man/boy has a good heart. A smart cat knows these things.

He reaches for me. My initial reaction is to dodge his hand, but I force myself to accept his touch because he needs to feel the comfort I can bring him. I might be an opportunist interested in food and a warm bed, but I can also comfort a human. A lot of people might not believe that about cats, but it’s true. We aren’t just selfish jerks interested in nothing but our own well-being. If that’s how I rolled I would have been happy with First Owner and Third Owner.

Emerson might live in a semi-dump but Sam feels he’s got potential. Their first day together also shows Sam that Emerson needs some matchmaking help when a lovely young woman arrives in the instrument repair shop where Emerson works. As usual when the woman he loves appears, Emerson falls to pieces and it’s only with Sam working from the shadows with his mind suggestions that smooths things along.

The two begin a tentative relationship which is more friendship at first since Lola still isn’t sure about Emerson, a man she thought hated her because of what she thought was his rudeness at the store. It isn’t that he’s rude – just shy and painfully socially awkward. Given to introversion myself, I could immediately identify with Emerson. Although I can’t recall ever just walking away from anyone, going into new social environments can be a challenge for me too.

But somehow with Sam at his side, Emerson becomes the more smooth talking, social person he’s always longed to be. Emerson can’t explain it and certainly doesn’t want to tell anyone for fear they’d think he’s off his meds but Sam seems to calm Emerson and give him social courage. Sam knows that Emerson can’t rely totally on him and doesn’t want to risk losing who he thinks might be his forever owner by mind-messing with Emerson too much so some awkward moments lead to setbacks in the romance a time or two.

Lola has her own issues with confidence in her music and fear of getting involved with another loser boyfriend after her last one grifted her so there are times when she is understandably less than thrilled with the way Emerson acts. However their first time together all night is beautifully yet succinctly described when Lola tells her sister Melody of the way Emerson took exquisite care of her and cried.

“He cried.”
That got Melody’s attention. “What?”
“He cried.”
“Maybe he was just…I dunno, exhaling and inhaling in a trembly kind of way. Guys do that during orgasm.”
“I don’t think that’s what was going on.”
Silence from the other end.
“Mel?” Without waiting for a response, Lola continued: “I think that’s when it happened. I think that’s when my heart started to hurt. I think that’s when I began to wonder…if I love him.”
“You hardly know him.”
Lola nodded in agreement even though her sister couldn’t see her. And the nod was more of an affirmation of her identical response—as in how could this happen with someone she hardly knew. “I just think…. Well….” She touched a finger to her lip and dropped her voice even more, and now she felt like crying. “I just think he’s very special.”

I think he’s special too as he’s making something just for Lola. Something to help her realize how wonderful a violinist she is and given what his apprenticeship mentor tells Emerson about the PITA it is to make a violin … yeah, he’s very special. The sweet courtship he works out as a way to “speak” to Lola without getting tongue tied is wonderful too.

Just when everything is looking up, disaster strikes. Now comes your famous leavening of the sweet with the angst. Something Awful is done by Evil Third Owner and Sam ends up in danger. I was along for the heart stopping wild ride Lola and Emerson take to save him and I wept when they thought All Was Lost. If readers are pet lovers, they will too. The reunion scene had me crying even more.

Emerson lunged forward and fumbled with the latch, finally releasing the door, metal clanging.

The cat jumped from the cage to his shoulder.

“It’s Sam!” Emerson said with joy in his voice as he reached up to pet him.
Lola put a trembling hand to her mouth and let out a choked sob, then she began to laugh.

Emerson coaxed Sam off his shoulder so he could hold him to his chest and pet him. The cat meowed and purred. With Sam between them, Emerson and Lola put their foreheads together.

Okay at this point I thought everything was done, everything was fine. But you pulled a swift one on us and ratcheted up some more angst. “WHAT?!” I thought. The novella is almost over. How will she fix this? Ah, there was a way and it worked to show Lola how much she means to Emerson and that he’s worth a little fixing-uping from time to time.

I finished the story with a contented, happy sigh. Emerson has the woman he’s longed for from afar, Lola has found a special man who cherishes her and gives her confidence and Sam, well he’s found Fourth Owner – aka forever owner. Oh and his brother Max too in a very catlike way.

Although the cool customer is my long-lost brother, this kind of thing has to be taken slow, even with family.

Max saunters toward me, jumps on the couch in one graceful motion that I can only envy, and plops down on the opposite end and does that half-closed eyes thing that makes a cat look like he’s smiling.

I do it back.

Life is good.

A- (because no cute Sam cover)


P.S. – I had already intended to make a donation to my local no-kill animal shelter as a Christmas gift to another pet loving relative but after reading this novella, it’s gonna be bigger.


AmazonBNSonyKoboAREBook DepositoryGoogle

Another long time reader who read romance novels in her teens, then took a long break before started back again about 15 years ago. She enjoys historical romance/fiction best, likes contemporaries, action- adventure and mysteries, will read suspense if there's no TSTL characters and is currently reading very few paranormals.


  1. Tanya
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 08:27:44

    I love Theresa Weir. I love her blog, I love her Instagram feed. But mostly, I just love her books. Max was a hoot and half, but I didn’t actually love his owner. However, Sam’s couple sounds like pure perfection (no, not going for the purr pun, can’t do it!). I am loving my end of the year novella feast, and this one just got added to the list.

  2. Jayne
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 08:39:38

    @Tanya: List, what list? It’s out today! $2.99 at Amazon and Kobo – which are the only ones I’ve checked so far. The Kobo link isn’t quite working but type in Weir’s name and it comes up. Meow.

  3. Sally W.
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 08:44:30

    Jayne, you made my day. I bought it.

  4. Elyssa Patrick
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 09:28:54

    Okay, this review made me think I might realllllly like this book and series. I believe I bought the first one but haven’t yet read for one reason or another. But your review made the book sound so fun and charming, and I’m so looking for fun and charming. Also, Sam sounds adorable. *one clicks*

    Btw, on a separate note, I so miss your movie reviews, Jayne.

  5. cleo
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 09:29:30

    Yay. I loved the first novella. Now I have something to look forward to when I’m done with my current grading hell.

  6. leslie
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 09:42:47

    Thank you!
    Max is the face I see every time I open my phone. I loved the first book, so happy to get Sam’s story, gotta go buy it now!

  7. Jayne
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 09:49:14

    @leslie: Don’t lose that book cover as it’s now been changed to a Max-in-the-Hat-less one. ::Sob::

  8. Jayne
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 09:58:41

    @Elyssa Patrick: You can read this one without having read the first one and be fine. As for the movies … let me think about it.

  9. Sunita
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 10:18:05

    Oh Jayne, you made me sniffle and hug the cat I’m hanging out with at the moment (she didn’t really get it but she put up with it). Max is such a hard act to follow, but it sounds like Sam has managed it. I should say Theresa Weir has managed it, but I persist in thinking there are real kitties writing these novellas.

  10. Susan
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 11:28:06

    Yay! I feel as if I got an early Christmas present! I had no idea the second book was out, and it sounds terrific. I’ll have my hankies out when I read it–I just know I’ll do the boo hoo.

    My Giving Tuesday donation was to a local no-kill cat shelter. There are too many Sams out there who need help.

    Thank you, Jayne.

  11. Lada
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 14:01:34

    Thanks for the great review, Jayne! Just downloaded this one and I agree about the cover. This one is fine but the Max-in-the-Hat cover was awesome.

  12. Liz C.
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 16:54:14

    I’m so excited this is out! I loved the first book so much, so I bought it for my mom for Christmas — now I can get her book two as well (and me too :))! I really don’t like the new covers – they make the books look like every other contemporary romance book out there.

  13. Jayne
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 17:57:43

    @Sunita: Perhaps she has kitties as crit partners? I hugged and petted mine a lot too while reading the novella.

  14. Jayne
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 18:01:09

    @Lada: @Liz C.: Re: the cover. My friend and I were discussing it and debating if it’s a marketing thing or if they just couldn’t get another cute cover with a cat like the first time. Checking back and reading the comments on Sunita’s and my reviews and the ones during the DABWAHA tournament, it seems like the original cover was such a hit but perhaps it was felt this one might sell better. I dunno.

  15. Jayne
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 18:07:12

    @Susan: Yeah I boo-hoo’d when I was reading it, I boo-hoo’d when I was writing the review and checking the quotes – I was a mess, but a happy one.

  16. cleo
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 18:12:14

    @Jayne: I loved the original cover – it captured the quirkiness and tone of the book perfectly, although I guess it doesn’t say “romance” the way the new (blander) cover does. Didn’t she self-publish these?

  17. Laura
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 18:43:18

    Whee! Early Christmas present for me, I loved the first one!!

  18. Jayne
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 19:09:47

    @cleo: I’m not sure but I think you’re right about the self publishing.

  19. MikiS
    Dec 20, 2013 @ 22:54:45

    Even though I tend to avoid novellas, I had to try these series after this review!

    And FYI – I bought the first one at Kobo. Even though the Kobo page shows the new (series) cover, the downloaded ebook still showed the cover with the kittie with a tall hat.

  20. Willaful
    Dec 29, 2013 @ 00:08:38

  21. Jayne
    Dec 29, 2013 @ 09:14:44

    @Willaful: Well fuckety! From elation at the early publishing of novella #2 to boo-hooing at the fate (maybe just for now, please!) of the last entry, this series has taken me for an emotional ride.

  22. What Kelly’s Been Reading: The “I Survived the Polar Vortex” Edition
    Jan 16, 2014 @ 11:02:10

    […] course I had to read all of Morgan’s backlist, and most of Florand’s. I also holy-crap-adored Geek with the Cat Tattoo by Theresa Weir, which extended my Good Book Mood enough to dig into the TBR for some Nicole Helm (Flight Risk), […]

%d bloggers like this: