Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Deconstruction by Kit Zheng

Dear Ms. Zheng.

Dianne Fox recommended this book on her LiveJournal and since she’s part of my “trust network” and I was intrigued by the description — “seriously fantastic” and “dark and gritty and wrenching” — I went out and bought it. And oh, am I glad I did.

Deconstruction by Kit ZhengTomas is a stripper and a much-in-demand escort. But he’s also the partner of Vic, a homicide detective — they’ve been together three years. We first meet Tomas at the club after his dance; we then see him slip into bed with Vic. There’s comfort and familiarity and deep feeling, but also a sense of unease as the story starts:

But when he was sick of trying to sort out the case in his head, he worried about them, him and Tommy. Nothing was wrong, nothing specific, not that he could put his finger on. If anything, they were going too well, too easily, coasting. And maybe nothing was wrong, but there were things about their relationship that weren’t right. That they were ignoring, letting go, letting slide.

Vic is working a string of horrific murders of blond street hustlers and he’s more worried than normal about Tomas’s job and the dangers he’s subject to because of it. And Tomas is working more — which means “escorting” more — worried about money. One of his weekly regular clients is the “pet cop” of the owner of the club Tomas works at. Jon, the cop, takes illegal payments for arresting dancers the owner wants to scare away from hustling on the premises. Vic is understandably annoyed knowing that one of his partner’s clients — and therefore sex partners — is a crooked cop from his own precinct, but the unspoken deal he and Tommy have worked out is no questions, no information. Neither of them bring work home and that’s part of what’s wearing on them both.

And then, both cause and effect of the breakdown of the relationship between Tomas and Vic, Tomas and Jon start experimenting with handcuffs, domination, and humiliation. These all really turn Tomas’s crank in ways he’s unwilling to examine, mostly because he’s unwilling to examine anything:

Vic was what he wanted, but Vic didn’t want him, not as he was. That wasn’t right, not exactly. But close enough. He couldn’t get it right with Vic, just got angry and made things worse and worse. They couldn’t handle it. He couldn’t handle it. So he was throwing it all out the door with Jon. Was that what he wanted?

Later in the same scene:

So much danced on Tomas’ tongue, in the back of his throat. Selfish fury, injured pride, indignant confusion. All that Vic had said—he was nothing, a dumb hooker, what he did was selfish, for no good reason, for greed. He wanted to argue. He wanted to scream that of all people, he trusted Vic, because he thought Vic got it. That Vic didn’t care that he did what he did, even enjoyed it. But really, it had been three years of what? Lies? Pretense? They had been happy. Or he had been happy, and too stupid to see Vic getting unhappy. And he would have walked away from it all, from everything that he was, even though there was nothing for him on the other side, but now he was too goddamn pissed. He was too goddamn pissed to get a single word past his lips.

Tomas is bad at articulating anything. He’s so used to letting his body talk for him and he can’t get words out. Vic is no great shakes at it either and gets angry quickly. When things are going fine, they don’t need to talk. But they don’t then have the habit when things DON’T go well.

One of the most fascinating choices you make as an author is that we see into the heads of Tomas (mainly), Vic, *and* Jon. And Jon is a truly contemptible human being and he doesn’t get his just desserts at the end. Oh, he doesn’t win, but he’s not destroyed. The emotional climax of the book is when Jon not-quite-forces Tomas into anonymous bathroom sex with strangers and it was utterly fascinating to me how you managed to write a scene in which Tomas was utterly turned on but so totally detached that the scene itself is the furthest thing from sexy I’ve ever read, even knowing that on one level, Tomas was enjoying what was happening. That takes some mad writer skillz.

I had a niggle with the way cell phones and voice mail were used at the end — do they really work like that? But otherwise, everything was pitch perfect for the story. The one thing I felt was lacking was a more elaborate HEA — there is one, don’t get me wrong — but if you’d given me one, my inner romantic might have been happier, but the story’s soul would have suffered, and that would be a crime.

This is almost a claustrophobic book, but oh god, you feel for these men. They’re intense and this book is dark. It deals with dirty sex and dark feelings and no one should read it who’s not ready to have their beliefs about love and fidelity and the importance of sex and closeness challenged. But, fuck, it’s brilliant.

Grade: A-

Best regards,
-Sarah F.

Book Link | Kindle | All Romance eBooks

Sarah F. is a literary critic, a college professor, and an avid reader of romance -- and is thrilled that these are no longer mutually exclusive. Her academic specialization is Romantic-era British women novelists, especially Jane Austen, but she is contributing to the exciting re-visioning of academic criticism of popular romance fiction. Sarah is a contributor to the academic blog about romance, Teach Me Tonight, the winner of the 2008-2009 RWA Academic Research Grant, and the founder and President of the International Association of the Study of Popular Romance (IASPR). Sarah mainly reviews BDSM romance and gay male romance and hopes to be able to beat her TBR pile into submission when she has time to think. Sarah teaches at Fayetteville State University, NC.

7 Comments

  1. Ridley
    Jun 02, 2011 @ 17:02:38

    I love the risks authors can take with m/m. Can you just imagine if someone tried to pitch this plot for an m/f romance?

    I’ve tossed on the shopping list. You’ve never led me astray for m/m romance and I do so love grit.

  2. Sarah Frantz
    Jun 02, 2011 @ 17:28:44

    @Ridley: I was thinking as I wrote this review that it would be so difficult to pull this off in a m/f book. It’s have to be erotic romance, but it would be…very very difficult. Because you don’t have the automatic gender dynamic and issues of sex and gender, though, it’s easier to do in m/m. I don’t think it’s a lack of skill or desire in m/f authors, honestly. I think it’s our societal and generic expectations. But this book is amazing. SO worth it. Brilliant writing, too.

  3. Sunita
    Jun 02, 2011 @ 18:14:20

    I was just thinking the same thing. Dammit Ridley and Sarah, stop that. I need my brain right now.

    There is such a variety in m/m right now, from the settings to the characters to the relationships. I think because it’s a relatively new subgenre within romance (and the ebook market is more flexible), it hasn’t been locked into the “what will sell” straitjacket that mainstream romance is stuck in.

    This is not my favorite setup, but good writing is hard to pass up.

  4. Sarah Frantz
    Jun 02, 2011 @ 18:47:05

    @Sunita: See, and I have A Thing for prostitute/stripper stories. :)

  5. Dominique Eastwick
    Jun 05, 2011 @ 15:55:38

    Kit what a fantastic review, I am so thrilled for you and it really is a great book. Sarah on behalf of Aspen Mountain Press thank you for taking the time to read and review Deconstruction

    Dominique Eastwick
    Promotions and Review Coordinator for Aspen Mountain Press

  6. orannia
    Jun 05, 2011 @ 23:17:38

    After reading your review of Heidi Cullinan’s Special Delivery I took a chance on it and I was every so glad I did. And I think I’d like to take another chance on this book. It’s definitely not the sort of book I would normally read in the m/m genre, but…well…I guess you’re helping me expand my boundaries :)

    Rats! Just realized it is not available in ePub format. I’ll have to investigate whether the Mobipocket format can be converted… GRRRR!

  7. June Recommended Reads | Dear Author
    Jun 07, 2011 @ 10:00:32

    [...] REVIEW: Deconstruction by Kit Zheng [...]

%d bloggers like this: