Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Stealing Home by Jennifer Seasons

Jennifer Seasons Stealing Home

Dear Ms. Seasons:

This is one book wherein I think the grade looks harsher than it really is but I had so many problems with this book, I felt like it was the best reflection of my interaction with the story.  Others may have had a much different experience.

The story begins with Lorelei Littleton spying on Mark Cutter at a Denver bar.  Mark is a the star catcher for the Denver Rush baseball team, a team in the hunt for the pennant.  Mark’s ex-wife has  offer to pay Lorelei $100,000  if Lorelei steals Mark’s good luck charm.   despite obvious efforts to make this believable, the setup was still shaky. Lorelei was given the security code to Marx apartment by his ex-wife which made you wonder why the ex-wife simply didn’t waltz into the building and steal it herself.  (There are later implausibilities like how Mark forces Lorelei to stay with him by taking her phone away from her.  Like she can’t get out and use a phone and ask her brother to come and get her if she wanted to?)

Most of this book operates under the premise that because Lorelei is doing a number of bad things because she is desperate to save her niece,  that the bad actions are excusable. The storyline also relies on an imposition of reverse double standards. When  I mean by that is a woman who is treated like Lorelei treats Mark  would be deemed deplorable. However, because it is a woman treating a man poorly, particularly a famous athlete, her actions are to be measured on a different scale.

Unfortunately, I didn’t buy into either of those premises. The book bothered me from nearly the beginning to the end.

Lorelei and Mark hit it off at the bar.   She proceeds to go back to his apartment and drug him and rob him.   When he calls her on the robbery, she is snippy and rude to him.  She proceeds to insult him from the moment he confronts her about the robbery until they finally get together. She constantly harps on him for having lots of women.  As he is confronting her about a) robbing him and then b) trying to extort him out of money to gain the charm back, they have this exchange:

“So it’s all about the Benjamins to you, is it? You were at my house last night half naked and ready to do it. If you’re only in it for the cash gain, then guess what that makes you?”


Anger balled in the pit of her stomach, bitter and scorching. Lorelei took a deep breath and met his gaze, let her anger spark. “You calling me a whore is laughable, Mark Cutter. Don’t think I’m stupid, because I’ve heard all about you and your women. So don’t you dare stand there and throw stones at me. You don’t have the right.”

When Mark calls her out for constantly accusing him of having sex with any number of willing women, she responds that why should she assume anything else when he was willing to go home with her at the bar.  If Mark is a slut for wanting to participate in a one night stand, then isn’t Lorelei the same. Or at least, doesn’t Mark get to make the same accusations?  The Mark is a slut is a theme that gets tossed around by Lorelei in order to provide contrast to Mark’s true issues.

Lorelei also thinks that she’s better than Mark because he’s just a self-absorbed athlete.  Unfortunately we’ve seen Mark do nothing but kind things. He takes time out of his meal to congratulate a boy who’s a fan and give encouraging advice.  Mark doesn’t turn Lorelei in for drugging and blackmail. Mark never acts better than anyone, not with Lorelei and not with her brother.  The only person who is a shithead in this book is Lorelei.  I never felt any sympathy for her even though we were given a reason right away (that Lorelei’s niece will die without a $100,000 surgery).  Lorelei’s justification was never fully played out for me. She’d rather steal from someone than actually try to hold a fundraising, go to her community, ask for help?

As far as the romance, I guess I saw where the two had chemistry as the initial conflict of Lorelei’s niece’s medical condition gave way to a more romantic conflict; but overall, the two didn’t work for me as a couple. I felt more frustrated by the failed  portrayal of Lorelei as the sweet martyr than invested in the HEA of the two.  D

Best regard,



AmazonBNSonyKoboAREBook DepositoryGoogle

Jane Litte is the founder of Dear Author, a lawyer, and a lover of pencil skirts. She self publishes NA and contemporaries (and publishes with Berkley and Montlake) and spends her downtime reading romances and writing about them. Her TBR pile is much larger than the one shown in the picture and not as pretty. You can reach Jane by email at jane @ dearauthor dot com


  1. Meri
    Apr 28, 2013 @ 13:55:31

    The setup does sound shaky, and unnecessary – baseball is an interesting enough backdrop without this stuff about good luck charms and mean exes and theft to pay for a dying child’s surgery. Around the time of Opening Day, Wendy the Super Librarian came up with Harlequin romance storylines for several Detroit Tigers players, and they seemed a lot more realistic and entertaining to me (someone should write her Prince Fielder book; it would be amazing).

    Also, I have to know – is the hero named after a pitch on purpose, or is that just a random thing?

  2. hapax
    Apr 28, 2013 @ 18:22:50

    Oh, I am so sick of the “my niece / brother/ father / best pal needs an operation or they’ll dieeeeeee” trope.

    Y’know, as long as I’m being asked to buy into a fantasy anyhow, I’d much rather read a story where the protagonists had access to decent health coverage, than one in which the lack of same excused a pattern of disgusting, stupid, and criminal behaviors on the path to Troo Luv.

  3. cleo
    Apr 29, 2013 @ 11:26:22

    Too bad this doesn’t sound like the book for me because I really like the cover. Nothing as sexy as well worn denim, imo. On both men and women.

  4. Daily Deals: Some really great deals on some fairly new releases. And two freebies.
    Sep 27, 2013 @ 14:02:20

    […] stealing his good luck charm was really shady of the heroine. I never got on board with the story. (Review Here) But hey, it’s free. I guess for full priced books, 99c is the promotional price but for […]

%d bloggers like this: