Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Say It With Diamonds by Lucy King

Dear Ms. King:

I felt like this book started out with the heroine as a thief* and the hero as a good guy and then someone told you to SEX it up and all the backstory and character got chopped for paragraph upon paragraph of mental lusting.   There was so much mental lusting, in such an intense and melodramatic tone, that it was surprising to me that either the heroine or the hero could function like regular people.  The heroine, in particular, with her description of her insta lust upon seeing Will (just Will not Your Grace) was in such a state I wondered if an ambulance needed to be called:

She’d like him to swerve off to the left, drag her down some dusty deserted corridor and back her up against a wall. She’d like him to lift her up, wrap her legs around his waist and crush his mouth down on hers. She’d like him to run his hands all over her and drive her mindless with need. Most of all she’d like him hot and hard and deep inside her.

At the bolt of desire that thumped her in the stomach Bella went dizzy and stumbled. Would have hit the floor had Will not caught her arm and steadied her.

‘Are you all right?’

Bella dragged in a breath and blinked a couple of times as she fought to wipe her head of the images. Oh, good Lord. She was fantasising. About Will. A duke. So much for thinking she didn’t go for the cynical weary type, she thought dolefully. And so much for sensible and mature.

‘I’m fine,’ she said a little shakily, wriggling away from beneath his grip before she did something really unhinged like deliberately letting her knees collapse and falling into his arms. ‘Absolutely fine. These heels weren’t designed for this carpet, that’s all.’

His gaze was so laser-like, so intense, that it felt as if her clothes were disintegrating in its wake, leaving her standing there in front of him completely naked. And then, at the thought of that, she went so hot and trembly she nearly stumbled all over again.

Say It with Diamonds by Lucy KingNow that we are all tipsy on our heels from lust, let me describe the plot. The heroine, Bella, is a jewelry designer and appraiser. Is she the best appraiser in all of England? She should be because the hero, Will, is bringing her a collection that is called “legendary”. It is so legendary and valuable that Will carries around some trinkets in his pockets.

The Hawksley Collection is comprised of a number of jewels the Dukes of Hawksley have given to their lovers. Alas, some of those jewels are paste, Bella discovers. Is Will worried about a scandal ensuing if it comes out that some of the jewels in this famed collection are fake? Nah. He’s a billionaire from the Cayman Islands. (also Duke of Hawksley but that is such a stupid throwaway detail that even Will is embarrassed by it. That makes two of us).

Will immediately invites Bella, this random jewelry designer, to come to his bank and view the entire collection to view what is fake and what is not. At this point, I’d be whipping out my non disclosure form but I’m not a billionaire Duke from Cayman Islands and maybe they just don’t care about those things over there.

Fortunately, because the two are so hot for each other, they have sex in Will’s limo. You know, after Will kind of rebuffs Bella and makes her leave the bank to walk home in the rain. But alas, the road to happiness for Will and Bella is not all paste diamonds and sex filled limo rides. Bella is looking to find a man to settle down with and Will, because he is a cheater and from a family of cheaters, has declared himself off limits for a relationship. This does not stop Bella from pursuing Will or Will to become enraged and jealous by Bella toddling off to date another man. But their physical attraction cannot be denied. (Lest the two are put in a hospital)

As she twisted her hair into a thick dark rope her elbow briefly brushed against his shoulder and for one sizzling moment he thought he’d been electrocuted. His entire body burned as if it had gone up in flames and his heart practically stopped.

The conflict between Mr. Commitment Phobe and Ms. Looking for Forever is understandable. I would have liked to have seen more backstory on why she was determined to be married and have a family. I would have liked a few lines that would have established her as premiere expert in her field. I wouldn’t have minded a few paragraphs about why, other than the two suffer this unrelenting lust, that these two actually belong together. I also wouldn’t have minded if the word “besotted” was used less often:

Since when had he contemplated ditching a friend for a woman? And since when had he brought forward a date because he couldn’t wait? Where had his self-control gone? And more disturbingly, where had the idea that he might be besotted with Bella come from? He couldn’t be besotted with her. He’d only just met her. Besides he didn’t get besotted. Ever.

Will let out a growl of frustration. He’d wait until Saturday because he had to. Because that was the plan. Because he wasn’t besotted. And because he had gallons of self-control. Somewhere.

I guess the good thing is that I really knew where these characters stood.  Foolish parts of the story are shown to us like Bella’s conversation with Sam, a date she used to make Will jealous. Other important parts are told to us in summary fashion:

She’d found herself telling him about her peripatetic childhood and the colourful characters that had peppered her upbringing. About how, instead of doing her homework, she’d learned to pick locks, forge cheques and hot-wire cars. Far from being appalled, as she’d rather feared, Will had been fascinated and so, encouraged, she’d gone on to tell him all about her mother and her wildly misspent youth and about how she now lived quietly in Truro, kept goats and grew herbs.

So Bella is a pickpocket, former felon* who now works as an appraiser of legendary jewels.  Will, an English Duke, ran off to the Caymans where he built an empire.  He also has a debilitating phobia that was tossed in to ensure that despite his top lofty and irrational behavior and the fact he cheated on some bipolar chick when he was in his early twenties,  Will is a “good guy.”

I guess this is like an after school special for single women wherein the moral is always have sex in limos with guys who treat you poorly because underneath their irrational behavior lurks a socially damaged and phobic man whose just waiting for the right woman to keep his pants zipped up.  D

Best regards,


* Per the author’s comment, apparently the heroine learned all these law breaking skills but never used them.  I definitely got the impression that she used them but apparently that was an incorrect impression.


Jane Litte is the founder of Dear Author, a lawyer, and a lover of pencil skirts. She self publishes NA and contemporaries (and publishes with Berkley and Montlake) and spends her downtime reading romances and writing about them. Her TBR pile is much larger than the one shown in the picture and not as pretty. You can reach Jane by email at jane @ dearauthor dot com


  1. Ros
    May 02, 2012 @ 07:59:45

    I was disappointed by this one as well. I really enjoyed King’s first two books but this one just didn’t work for me.

    I guess this is like an after school special for single women wherein the moral is always have sex in limos with guys who treat you poorly because underneath their irrational behavior lurks a socially damaged and phobic man whose just waiting for the right woman to keep his pants zipped up.

    So that’s where I’ve been going wrong.

  2. Isobel Carr
    May 02, 2012 @ 09:41:52

    Um, there’s a difference between “paste” and modern cubic zirconia (aka “fake” diamonds), and an competent appraiser and antique jewelry should be well aware that “paste” was not supposed to be “fake” diamonds, but was its own type of expensive jewelry in its day. Even today, antique examples of black dot paste are highly sought after and quite expensive. And don’t even get me started on the idea of a convicted felon every being able to be insured to work in that industry (which happens to be one my BFF worked in for 20+ years, so I know a bit about how it works).

  3. Jane
    May 02, 2012 @ 09:43:57

    @Isobel Carr: Paste is my own inference and in my ignorance, did not realize there was a difference. I know that the author refers to CZ at one point. Don’t attribute to her errors regarding this.

  4. Jenny Lyn
    May 02, 2012 @ 10:48:58

    Woe is me. Never have I ever been “thumped” in the stomach by lust so hard that it made me stumble in my stilettos, and I’ve been around some really hot men in my time. If I were to do that now around the hubs he’d ask me if I needed a cookie.

  5. Julaine
    May 02, 2012 @ 11:53:01

    So would you say that this one was so one of those “so bad that their good” groaners or more of a wall banger because I have a particular weakness for stories that revolve around antique jewelry and I can forgive much to get my fix.

  6. Jane
    May 02, 2012 @ 11:55:46

    @Julaine: There isn’t a ton about the jewelry. It’s really a placeholder detail, much like Will’s dukedom. But if you like the excerpt I quoted, there are many passages of lust induced illnesses.

  7. Julaine
    May 02, 2012 @ 11:56:35

    Edited to correct my gosh darn auto correct …

    Should read

    “So bad that they’re good”

    I hate it when I do that.

  8. Sirius
    May 02, 2012 @ 15:19:04

    Oh god, I really really love jewelry (yeah, I know I am very unique in that :)), so the idea of carrying legendary collection in his pockets amused me a whole lot, and the super melodramatic lust just nailed it – so not for me, but very funny review. Thank you.

  9. Lucy King
    Jul 17, 2012 @ 08:13:40

    Dear Jane

    Many thanks for your review of Say It with Diamonds. I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy the book but I can live with that. While naturally disappointed, I don’t feel in the slightest bit bullied by either the content or tone of the review, so this response is not me having a major strop or anything, but me simply correcting a factual error for the benefit of your many readers.

    My heroine might have learned to pick locks, forge cheques and hotwire cars (although not, in fact, how to pick pockets) but she has never put these skills into practice, and at no point during the book are we told otherwise. She is therefore not a felon, former or current.

    Best regards


  10. Jane
    Jul 17, 2012 @ 08:24:52

    @Lucy King – I don’t think commenting on a review is in any way bullying and I appreciate the correction. I am not sure where I got the impression she was a felon and it wouldn’t have bothered me in the least if she was.

  11. Lucy King
    Jul 17, 2012 @ 12:41:26

    Marvellous. Thank you. Happiness all round!

%d bloggers like this: