Romance, Historical, Contemporary, Paranormal, Young Adult, Book reviews, industry news, and commentary from a reader's point of view

REVIEW: Dark Waters by Alex Prentiss

Dear Ms. Prentiss:

I decided to read this book because I liked the cover and the blurb made it sound like a different type of paranormal/urban fantasy story. Rachel Matre lives in Madison, Wisconsin, and runs a diner.   From all outward appearances, she is a physically fit and successful business owner but in truth Rachel is a woman who may be possessed by spirits.   (I know she is fit because the second paragraph tells me so even though Rachel’s fitness never is at issue during the entirety of the book).

Rachel was thirty-four but looked younger, with a body kept trim and firm by regular jogging. She had unruly blond hair and full lips, and a haunted l ook in her eyes that spoke of past traumas hidden deep and well.

The spirits of a local lake call to her and she visits the lake regularly to seek surcease from the passion that the calling arouses in her.

dark waters alex prentiss The story is a strange mix of mysticism and mystery.   Rachel communes with the lake spirits on a regular basis.   But recently she has felt a strange and different pull.   Ominous music plays in the background as the foreshadowing signals bad juju ahead. In another part of town, Ethan Walker, ethical architect, and one time lover of Rachel, is offered a building contract by one of the most famous developers around.   Although Ethan voices some initial concerns over the project, they are swept away with the words of the developer (whom we all know is a bad guy given the overt and heavy handed foreshadowing, once again).

The copy on the front of the book says “For a woman with burning desires, there is only one place to quench the flame.”   One might think that because this is marked as a romance, the one place would be in the arms of her lover.   I suppose this is true in one sense, but the lover of Rachel Matre is the water, not a corporeal being.   As I read the first sex scene in which Rachel is surrounded and penetrated by watery fingers, watery tonges, and, I presume watery dildoes, I kept thinking that no man could ever match the physical satisfaction that the spirits bring to Rachel.

She came to them naked, in the middle of the night, and they pulled her beneath the surface and enveloped her in sensual safety.   They took her to heights of passion she never dreamed possible, and in return she helped them right wrongs on the surface word.   She had no idea who they were or why they were here, only that they loved her and protected her.

It was like an amorphous orgy with her at the center.   All attention focused on her needs, sensing when things grew too intense and she required a moment to recover.   Yet the passion never really abated.   She was caressed, kissed, sucked and penetrated.   It went on for so long that she began to wonder if they intended to let her go.   Could she die this way? she thought, after innumerable orgasms.   And would she care?

You would expect after an opening like that that we would explore, at least in some small measure, how and why a romance with a physical being like Ethan Walker, a man she had shared a one night stand with in the previous book, Night Tides, would be preferable to the underwater orgy.   Yet, there is nothing in the book that addresses this. Instead, the entirety of the book is focused on good water spirits and bad water spirits.    At one point, Rachel is seduced to a puddle of boneless wanting by bad water spirits.

I don’t think that this can or should be read as a romance because there is no romance here.   There is no exploration of a love relationship between two people.   Ethan does lust after and maybe even has tender feelings for Rachel; but Rachel loving Ethan lacks believability.

The world building is nearly non existent.   We know that there are good spirits. We learn that they are bad spirits.   Rituals can bring spirits forth and so can casually pleas from a spirit blessed being.   Whatever bounds there is to the lake magic is unknown, certainly to Rachel who makes no effort to suss out the origin of the spirits or question its control over her.

The tone of the story was very immature even though the topic was not.   I felt distanced from the story, as if it was all happening about 50 fifty away and I had to squint to make out the shapes and substance of the characters and their interaction.   The signals of who was good and who was bad was about the only thing that stood out, as if big neon signs were flashing above certain characters denoting their role in the story.

I thought the prose was very mundane with little mobility.   Strangely, because the sentences were short, the sections were short, and the prose was simplistic, it was fairly easy to whip through this story.   It’s under 300 pages and there is not much meat upon which to sink one’s teeth into.     I wished this different type of paranormal had been more engaging but it was not and given the immaturity of the prose, the lack of any character development, the weak worldbuilding, and the apathetic pace along with the unsexiness of the sex scenes, I’d have to rate this one a D.

Best regards,


Book Link | Kindle | Amazon | nook | BN | Borders
| Sony| Kobobooks

Jane Litte is the founder of Dear Author, a lawyer, and a lover of pencil skirts. She self publishes NA and contemporaries (and publishes with Berkley and Montlake) and spends her downtime reading romances and writing about them. Her TBR pile is much larger than the one shown in the picture and not as pretty. You can reach Jane by email at jane @ dearauthor dot com


  1. Ammarylis
    Jan 15, 2011 @ 14:28:42

    Wait, let me get this straight. The protagonist had sex with “deep waters”? I will never look at detachable shower heads the same way again.

    Great review, Jane. I will not be reading this book ever. It’s kinky in a bad way.

  2. Jaclyn
    Jan 15, 2011 @ 16:03:19

    *sigh* I look at this book, turned away, looked again and thought, “maybe?”, then turned away. Then a couple days later thought, should I give it a try? The cover is evocative, the blurb made it seem like it was something different. From your description it *was* different. Thanks for the review, Jane, I’m glad I skipped this one.

  3. Kaetrin
    Jan 15, 2011 @ 18:21:13

    Well, at least the cover is pretty.

  4. Barbara
    Jan 15, 2011 @ 22:18:30

    Let’s hope it’s not any water in or near Madison. Our local lakes are…less than sparklingly clean. The woman would need a double prescription of Diflucan.

    This is why I just can’t read any books set here. I made the mistake of reading one that was set in the general area just this last week and it drove me up a wall.

    I lose every single ability to suspend belief, no matter how hard I try.

  5. K. Z. Snow
    Jan 16, 2011 @ 13:01:36

    I sure hope the lake wasn’t Monona. The plane carrying Otis Redding and the Bar-Kays went down there, and, as far as I’m concerned, setting this kind of action in that particular body of water would be tantamount to sacrilege.

%d bloggers like this: