REVIEW:  The Gift by Eva Cassel

REVIEW: The Gift by Eva Cassel

I'm always looking for good f/f/m and this story was recommended to me by another reader.   The only other Harlequin Spice short I've read, Tonight, My Love, by Tracie Sommers, was very memorable.

The Gift is sexy, unique, and well-written.   It opens with Mia and her husband, Evan, at a cocktail party.   They've been married ten years and still have that spark.   The sex is fantastic because they both like to mix it up and keep things fresh.   I loved the portrayal of their relationship as erotically charged and never complacent.

The Gift by Eva CasselMia enjoys watching Evan flirt with other women.   He does it to arouse her.   It's a game they play, each teasing the other.   After the party, she decides to buy him an erotic massage for his birthday.   While she is ordering the sexual services by phone, the provider (madam?) offers a "couples special."   Mia can be massaged, too, for the same price.

At first, Mia hesitates.   She wants to watch, not join in.   She'd also rather have a male masseur for herself but she chooses a female for Evan.

As a reader who bought this story for the f/f content (which isn't easy to find at a mainstream publisher!), I stumbled over Mia's thought processes.   The last thing I want to read about is a reluctant three-way.   In order for any sex scene to work for me, the participants must be willing.

Luckily, Mia is intrigued by the idea of doubling their pleasure and agrees.   On the night of Evan's birthday, she can hardly contain her excitement.   Evan doesn't know about the surprise, but Mia looks so hot and bothered that he can hardly contain his erection.

Most of this story is sex, and everything below can be considered a spoiler.

[spoiler]The lady masseuses show up.   Not just one, but two erotic experts.

I feel deflated.   This isn't a steamy ménage!   Why is there is a superfluous masseuse?

But I'm already halfway through the story so I go with it.   Mia watches Evan get his erotic massage, which is apparently code for "hand job."   The extra masseuse is in training.   Ha!   Whatever.

After Evan ejaculates all over the main masseuse, who is wearing a sporty outfit (because she's a professional), it's Mia's turn to be stimulated.   We finally see the reason for the second worker-’to penetrate Mia anally with a sex toy while the first one penetrates her vaginally.

If my description sounds clinical, it's because the scene reads like an explicit and well-researched sex manual.   The women reminded me of nurses performing orgasm surgery.   Mia and Evan don't talk to or touch each other during the encounter.   She watches him; he watches her.   Then she's blindfolded, and they can't even make smoldering eye contact anymore.

I think I get what the author was going for.   The couple has made it a habit to separate at social functions, not giving in to the urge to chat or hold hands.   Once they get home, they're all over each other.   Staying apart actually brings them closer together.

I can appreciate the craft of this story, and the author's intent.   Mia's chemistry with Evan is scorching and her arousal is described in lush sensual detail.   But the truth is that the scenario didn't work for me on multiple levels.   Let me break them down.

  1. Evan gets off first.   Wouldn't it have been more exciting if he'd watched Mia and the masseuses while aroused, rather than satiated?
  2. This is an exhibition/voyeur fantasy, not really f/f.   There is no attraction between Mia and the workers.   They are strangers doing a job.   I think I would have preferred some kind of sexual connection.   Basically, if I don't believe the characters would kiss each other, I'm not sure I want to see them engaged in sex acts.
  3. Did I mention the fourth wheel?   Awkward!

On the other hand, the above elements are a matter of personal taste.   The story might work better for a reader who isn't into f/f.   Kissing creates intimacy, and most m/f fans don't want the heroine to have a full-on lesbian encounter.   The extra woman cuts that tension by making a ménage unlikely.   Mia's climax as the finale can be considered female-centric.

[/spoiler]

I was looking for spicy f/f/m and probably wouldn't have been satisfied with anything less.   The Gift turned out to be a different package altogether.

But I can't mark down this story for not being my favorite fantasy any more than I can fail a BDSM for being "too ouchy."   Cassel writes well and I loved the married-not-dead dynamics.     This isn't a throwaway piece.   B

~Jill Sorenson