Comments on: Miss Snark Gives Publishing Advice to Anne Stuart

By: Robin

Robin — Mon, 06 Nov 2006 02:24:35 +0000

I think AS understands that publishing is a business just fine.

Which makes me think this hasn’t exactly been a shocking heads up to those who know her — if she’s really as open as she appears, it’s difficult for me to believe she hasn’t shared that particular opinion before. I didn’t even see her comments as personally directed so much as a dismayed reaction to the way the business of publishing has overtaken the respect for the books as books, which is hardly a new revelation. The conversation about marketing techniques over at RTB reveals similar sentiments.

By: Sybil

Sybil — Sat, 04 Nov 2006 13:33:57 +0000

I think they can only go dixieland on your ass if they can say they are bigger than you…. (the players are a lil foggy in my mind and I am too lazy to go look them up) none of them were in a place to be giving ~~beating up on~~ ‘advice’ Anne Stuart.

The way I look at it… Stuart has done ok for herself so far and managed to publish a book or two. I don’t think the AAR interview will hurt her.

But hey I just woke up and have to go to work for 4 hours, what do I know?

By: Rosie

Rosie — Sat, 04 Nov 2006 09:41:35 +0000

Robin, I agree. I re-read the comments in the interview and I personally think the tone is one of stating her personal opinion. There doesn’t seem (to me) to be any personal animous or axe to grind. In fact I think AS understands that publishing is a business just fine. I would call her comments as being disappointed in the people she works with rather than trashing them.

Anne at LETS GAB posted about this as well. I commented

“…while it probably wasn’t the smartest thing she’s ever done, I don’t think it’s as bad as everyone is making out. It’s just an opinion which she states and seems to realize she’s shooting herself in the foot.

If Mira is treating her as she says not much will be done. I don’t think they or Anne are worried either way.

By: Jane

Jane — Sat, 04 Nov 2006 02:14:17 +0000

I think its back up. iBOAS.

By: Robin

Robin — Fri, 03 Nov 2006 19:33:36 +0000

Where is MIRA’s response; I couldn’t find anything on Isabel Swift’s blog, even though someone linked to it.

Although I can see this issue from both sides, I imagine that there is a tremendous amount of pressure for authors to keep to the party (publisher) line and say nothing that could be interpreted negatlively about their publisher. And I think that’s bad, for all sorts of reasons, especially if it stems from fear and not respect. A publisher isn’t hiring an author as an employee; they are purchasing an author’s product — big difference, IMO. OTOH, I can see how a publisher would feel unmotivated to work harder for an author who trashes them (although I personally don’t think that’s what Stuart was doing). What always disturbs me a little, though, is how so many people come out to slap someone like Stuart on the wrist for being a bad little girl. I find those sentiments like “publish me instead” or “she should be punished for her transgression” particularly disconcerting because they give me an image of so many sharks in blood-shot water.